Slashdot Mirror


Student Fights University Over Plagiarism-Detector

(Maly) writes "CBC is reporting that MCGill University has lost a fight to have students first turn papers over to an anti-cheating website before handing them in to professors. The student refused to hand in three assignments to the service, received a zero on those assignments, then fought the ruling. The story doesn't have many specifics, such as the venue of the fight (court or some internal university tribunal), but it is an interesting case. As a recent graduate of the social sciences, I find that practice appalling. The student is right to refuse, as he gets no compensation from the service for making money off his original work (assuming it was original!!). Although I don't like the idea, and I'm glad I never went through it, I suppose its analogue would be mandatory drug tests in sports."

10 of 949 comments (clear)

  1. ha by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Firsts0rz :-D

  2. FUCK the GNAA--Join BPAA Instead! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Join BPAA Today!

    BPAA (BISEXUAL POLYNESIAN ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA) is the first organization which gathers BISEXUAL POLYNESIANS from all over America and abroad for one common goal: Being BISEXUAL POLYNESIANS.

    Are you BISEXUAL?
    Are you a POLYNESIAN?
    Are you a BISEXUAL POLYNESIAN?

    If you answered "Yes" to any of the above questions, then BPAA (BISEXUAL POLYNESIAN ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA) might be exactly what you've been looking for! Join BPAA (BISEXUAL POLYNESIAN ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA) today, and enjoy all the benefits of being a full-time BPAA member.
    BPAA (BISEXUAL POLYNESIAN ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA) is the fastest-growing BISEXUAL POLYNESIAN community with THOUSANDS of members all over United States of America. You, too, can be a part of BPAA if you join today!

    Why not? It's quick and easy--only 2 simple steps!

    Talk to one of the ops or any of the other members in the channel to sign up today!

    If you are having trouble locating #BPAA, the official BISEXUAL POLYNESIAN ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA irc channel, you might be on a wrong irc network. The correct network is EFNet, and you can connect to irc.secsup.org or irc.isprime.com as one of the EFNet servers.

    If you have mod points and would like to support BPAA, please moderate this post up.

    This post brought to you by a proud member of BPAA

    ` ______xde___BISEXUAL_POLYNESIAN_ASSOCIATION_OF_AME RICA_ |
    | __________________________________________________ _____ |
    ` __________________________________________________ ______'

    bpaa representative #648437

  3. Fuck I'm Bored by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    C'mon, Crapdot, post some more stories already. Jesus fucking christ almightly, it's been a slow newsday here. :p

    1. Re:Fuck I'm Bored by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Whenever you're bored and you're in front of a computer, just learn a programming language. It's saved me from boredom many a time.

    2. Re:Fuck I'm Bored by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Dude, I'm _employed_ as a programmer, and I get enough of it at work. I'm counting the days until my options vest and I'm OUT the fucking door and retiring to a tropical island starting a new career.

      Fuck learning a new programming language. I need more Slashdot stories. :-)

  4. Re:Hrmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    The same that happened to freedome.

    Is that the same thing that happened to the Astrodome?

  5. LOTR: ROTK is a travesty, and here is why. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    - Shelob book form is very, very old and slow. She's deliberate and single minded but not the speeding oversized tatarantula you see in the film. Heck in the film all Shelob is is just some unimportant oversized arachnid - no personality at all.

    - Shelob sits her ass on Sting, it's not thrusted by Sam - that fight went on way too long.

    - The sheer size of Shelob's sting was so large you'd think Frodo would have a pretty major abdominal wound in addition to the poison. But when he wakes there's nary a scratch on him. Oh hey the audience wont notice right? Continuity Mr. Jackson!

    - Why doesn't Shelob just run in and grab Frodo when he's bungey jumping in her webbing - that's what real spiders do - and if Shelob is just an oversized house spider than that's what she would have done. Not exciting enough right?

    - No Christopher Lee! Saruman is the star of the whole film and book. Who else can dish out sure fire insults in old English like the master of Orthanc? If it weren't for Saruman there would be no second book and we'd never see those Hobbits get their comeuppance.
    I am buying the DVD just for those deleted scenes alone.

    - Eowyn was never referred to as Dernhelm. Where were those references?

    - Aragorn's army of undead buddies never made it to Gondor proper. Aragorn releases them before that point cos he's such a nice geezer.

    - The crypt of the undead is supposed to be completely pitch black. Gimli is in fear because he can hear the dead following them but not see them. La-de-da we have CGI now. No need for plot exposition let's just bung undead people all over the place - it looks good or something.

    - The same goes for Shalobs Lair. It was much, much too bright - I'm serious!

    - The seige of gondor was likewise much too bright. The book labours to make clear the failing of the daylight hours. Through many chapters - not just one. But Mr. Jackson - our camera people will have nothing to film! We can't have that! Quick stuff in some daylight - otherwise people will have to use their imag-i-nation.

    - Gandalf takes on Denethor with his staff. WTF? What happened to stern words and plot exposition. No the audience has an average I.Q. of your average po-tat-O. I am insulted at Mr. Jacksons low opinion of me. This is insane.

    - The secret path into Mordor that Gollum leads Frodo and Sam to is not so secret after all. In fact - it's right on the doorstep of Minas Morgul, city of the Ringwraiths. Just look at the film. All those thousands of Saurons fell soldiers marching past and not once catching a glimpse of the stupid Hobbits mucking about in plain view.

    - In that same scene the leader of the Nine Riders is on Horseback, not flying like in the film. Not exciting right?

    - Theoden mucks around before going to Gondor. That's right - he sits on his ass and trys to figure out how to look after his people. He DOES NOT moan about Gondor's lack of assistance - and where is the all-important red arrow?

    - the real Denethor was much crazier - the guy in the film was one of those Goth posers who rely much to heavily on giving out heavy stares and trying to act like they don't give a fuck - well, hey neither did I. How about the human side of Denethor(that's right - there used to be one).

    - Since when would any sane king send his best horsemen against a herd of way oversized Oliphaunts? Horses are not necessarily faster but I would bet a sixpence that they are more maneuverable. Theoden have you ever heard of flanking tactics? Not just once mate - not just once.
    The carnage was un-fricking-believable. Speechless.

    - The Legolas/Oliphaunt scene. Empire Strikes Back - Hoth Scene anyone? Lego-man the force will be with you - always!

    - What the f*** was wrong with those Eagles? In the wild Eagles(it doesn't matter what species) take their prey off to an eyrie and eat the f***ers. Picking the Hobbits up - cool. Not eating them afterwards - not cool. No Gandalf versus the Eagles sce

  6. Plagerize this. (Socre:10, Informative) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    GOATSE MIRRORS WANTED
    The troll community have witnessed a terrible loss this week as Goatse.cx disappered from the Internet. We now need mirrors of the website, and links to new discusting pictures. Even if you are not a fan of goatse, Slashdot just wont be the same without it.

    So please, post your worst below me.

  7. MOD Parent up AS FUNNY by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Post of the year so far.
    I laughed my ass offf!!!!!!!

  8. Can we stop the Slashdot editorializing? by BTWR · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Can we stop the Slashdot editorializing? I mean, look at this story. The first half is very fact-oriented and neutral. It presents the case in question, the student's views and his initial punnishment. Do we need the poster's opinion as well? That is the sort of comment that should be reserved for the COMMENTS section, not the main article...

    anyone else agree that we're seeing this much more recently?