Slashdot Mirror


Grokster/Morpheus Hearing Recap

TrentC writes "An article in The Mercury News reports that Senior Judge John T. Noonan, hearing arguments in the Morpheus/Grokster case (yes, it's still going!), scolded one of the attorneys for the recording industry for 'using abusive language' in referring to P2P networks as 'trafficking in pirated goods'. Noonan also questioned, in response to a claim that a study showed that 90% of the 750 million files shared on Morpheus was illegally distributed files, if the other 10% -- consisting of public-domain works, recordings of public performances and works where the copyright holders have granted permission -- consisted of enough non-infringing use to meet the criteria set forth in the famous Betamax decision. Maybe 2004 will be 'The Year The Courts Get It Right'?" We mentioned this hearing a few days ago. The EFF has audio of the hearing and case documents available. Since this case will likely decide the general legality of P2P services, it could be quite important.

7 of 170 comments (clear)

  1. RECAP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    RIAA: File sharing is bad, mmkay?
    Pepsi girl: I'm still sharing, mmkay
    Senator: Polish my knob, girl!
    Slashbot: Use Lunix!

  2. I'm a Republican! (A poem) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Oh, I'm a Republican
    I got a small schling
    I like to bomb niggahs
    and make a lot o' bling

    I got a bunch o' friends
    in high up places
    They helps me get dem
    government graces.

    You think I'm smart
    I just know who's who
    I couldn't run a fruit stand
    without the red white & blue

    I fancy myself
    A brilliant tactician
    But neither me nor m'buddies
    Could even pass basic trainin'

    See, I'm above all that
    A fightin' and shootin'
    I just say "Sic em!"
    Then run the other direction

    Don't need no history
    Don't need no schoolin'
    I got my ideology
    To keep me a shootin'

    Liberals! Faggots!
    Commies and queers!
    Socialist hippies
    Full o' pussy tears!

    I'll drop some crap
    about Jesus the Christ
    You'll buy it all
    and vote for me twice

    'Fact, Jesus is comin'!
    Real soon, now!
    So we gotta prop up Israel
    That ol' sacred cow

    Propaganda's m'friend
    But I calls it "fact"
    Even though I don't read
    'Cept for Chick tracts

    Facts? No! Don't need em here!
    We're conservatives! We work on FEAR!
    Don't like what we say?
    Well FUCK YOU, bud!
    We'll shove it down yer throat
    and tell ya it's good!

  3. ANYONE WHO REPLIES BELOW THIS POST IS A FUCKING FA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    GOT

  4. Sad news: Howard Dean dead at 54 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    I just heard the news on cnn.com -- Presidential candidate/former mental patient Howard Dean was found dead this morning in his Washington (state) campain headquarters. There were no other details. I'm sure all slashdotters will miss him. Even if you didn't like his demaguogery, you probably got a laugh out of his ridiculous opinions. Truly a leftist icon.

  5. Re:hello by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll
    Ladies and Gentlemen,
    Downloading of Movies, MP3s and Software is illegal and punishable by law.


    We hereby inform you that your computer was scanned under the IP 228.214.119.95. The contents of your computer were confiscated as an evidence, and you will be indicated. In the next days, you'll get the charge in writing. In the Reference code: #53354, are all files, that we found on your computer.


    The sender address of this mail was masked, to fend off mail bombs.


    - You get more detailed information by the Federal Bureau of Investigation
    -FBI-
    - Department for "Illegal Internet Downloads", Room 7350
    - 935 Pennsylvania Avenue
    - Washington, DC 20535, USA
    - (202) 324-3000

  6. DUDE! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Seriously, have you ever even been on a P2P network? "trafficking in pirated goods" is a very accurate description, although it is not the only thing they are used for :P Thanks to P2P networks, I am a proud owner of Windows, Office, MATLAB, Mathcad, Easy CD Creator, Alcohol 120%, Partition Magic, Paint Shop Pro, Photoshop, multiple Virus Scanners and Personal Firewalls, Freelancer, Crazy Taxi, Half-Life, Tribes 2, and thousands of other less-known titles. I'm working on Flight Simulator 2002 and 2004, but those ISOs are nearly 700MB each! It will take me a little while.
    On the less illegal side of things, P2P is a GREAT resource of porn. 15 GB and growing!

  7. Re:Not quite. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    The linux CD is $699 but the picture of Linus is free. I'm posting the picture right here.