Practical C++

jsight writes with his review of Rob McGregor's Practical C++, published by QUE. He writes "Some books attempt to do one thing really well, and others attempt a little of everything. This book is clearly an example of the latter, in full force. Weighing in at a hefty 900 pages, you would expect this book to be crammed with chapters and details on every aspect of the STL and basic C++. In the following review, I am going to cover where it succeeds in doing this, and where it fails." (This book has been out for a few years; what books would make more sense today for a C++ learner's library?) Practical C++ author Rob McGregor pages 900 publisher QUE rating 7/10 reviewer Jess Sightler ISBN 0789721449 summary Provides a practical guidebook to learning C++ Section I -- Programming 101 At first glance, the book appears to be written for people with experience programming, however reading through this section clearly dispels that myth. Here we have a section which goes over everything from for loops to if conditionals while simultaneously using verbose, duplicitous language at every step. Perhaps this was intended as a means of reinforcement, however, it seems most of the effort here would be wasted.

The technical depth is what you would expect for a novice, but without enough hand-holding and examples to make a novice feel comfortable. Making matters worse, there are numerous typos in this section, including quite a few in the examples (making them uncompilable without corrections). Some of these appear to be type-setting errors, however, there are enough to potentially confuse novice developers.

I believe that the combination of weak examples, and significant typographical errors are strong enough to give a novice much difficulty in learning the C++ language.

Having said that, the section should be provide no difficulty for any programmer with a good knowledge of any vaguely similar language (eg, Perl, Java, PHP, etc).

Section II -- Beyond the Basics

Ah, now we're getting down to Brass Tacks... this section goes over everything from Function overloading to Structure and Unions. The section on function members within structures also does an excellent job of preparing the reader for the upcoming introduction of Object Oriented concepts.

The sections on Memory management, both from an allocation standpoint, and from a bit manipulation standpoint are first-rate. Details are perhaps not as strong as they could have been, however the material is very accessible, and clearly described.

Probably my only complaint with this chapter is the overly general section on compiling and debugging programs. However, as this book does attempt to be somewhat compiler/debugger agnostic, this is forgivable. From here, we dive into the real power of C++, Object Orientation.

Section III

From the beginning, this book treats Objects as an extension of the structure syntax taught previously (with the default of Public switched to Private). This, along with the classic Plans vs. Product description of the difference between a Class and an Object are quite clear and robust.

Again, this is a solid chapter, describing the details of getting a system of classes up and running, as well as some sample data structure implementations.

And then finally, the last section is a slightly less than 200 page description of the STL. This section is probably the book's weakest part, as it is just strong enough to give you a taste of what is available, but often not strong enough to grasp the details. It's a good start, but much more attention should have been made to this subject (potentially even at the cost of some of the wasted words on how a 'for' loop works). It makes a decent introduction for someone with very limited STL background, however, there is not enough depth to reach a strong level of understanding here.

Summary Overall, this is a solid book for an existing programmer to pick up C++ concepts. A programmer with a strong knowledge of an existing procedural language (such as C) would have no trouble digesting the concepts of this book. Having said that, the poor typographical issues, and verbose wording often muddle an otherwise good book.

You can purchase Practical C++ from bn.com. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to see your own review here, read the book review guidelines, then visit the submission page.

Comments

I feel bad

[Anonymous Coward]

What your about to read is true, it is the result of a 3+ year investigation. It will be difficult if not impossible for you to believe even after you read the evidence contained in public releases from military DOD, Dept. of Justice, police, US Patent Office, retired officials, private investigators and then the victims of the crime of the century and perhaps of all time. This is not fiction but something so evil and insidious I thought I should take some time and lead you into it gradually but there is no time, the criminals who are murdering men women and children in their homes by the million require a quick description of the situation; millions have already been murdered in their homes by a hideous science of implantation by microchip and or directed silent electromagnetic energy. This is the truth, a secret international organization sanctioned by all governments despite their serious differences in public with their political objectives exists; this particular international liaison takes precedence in international politics in that all officials across the globe fall silent as to its existence and activity, its as if the activity does not exist for the public. Their goal is multiple and they are the New World Order as they themselves define themselves, evil in nature and structured in the medieval way generally with kings and vassals and knights and we all the peasants if we do not have rank in their evil empire, they consider us mere livestock. At this precipitous time in history there are many events forcing mankind on the brink of cataclysm from nuclear war via nuclear proliferation, the known thinning of the North Pole and the environmental after effects that are known to follow, these two things alone have spawned an evil policy for removal of a serious percentage of the population coupled with the toppling of the free country Americans who in their ideology of freedom represent a threat to the policy being stuffed down the publics throat. The media do stories about what they are told to say, and now because of the internet we are finding out what they have been hiding, which is that those in charge are guilty of serious crimes of human rights abuse here at home. Truth is that the policy is a product of greed wherein those in the old boy power network refused to allow technical fixes out of the bag so to say; the US and European Patent offices are filled with technology that easily with very little development can end all the peoples problems, that now because these inventions were ignored has accelerated the destruction of the warming of the worlds ice which will cause tremendous problems and refusal to allow technical fixes has caused the using up of natural resources which are necessary to support the worlds population. Such statements together with outright greed have spawned the evil policy of secret genocide ( think tanks say the less people the better ). How you ask can something like that which is described here exist and go on undetected; simply put " National Security " . Your right to know under current legal dogma enacted amounts to the following fact; all facets of government are under " Admiralty Law " and this is known to exist under the current US system of law only and by the very display of a fringed flag in all court rooms throughout the US. heady stuff to understand what I say is true and it is. The web site your on is for the purpose of exposing the activities of the group described here at the preface. The secret genocide has been well thought through as a means to keep you and the mass population of the nation from discovering the truth which is millions have been killed and millions are being killed using the most obviously attacked by the electronic device described earlier. The method of hiding something so insidious being done out in the open is pure evil genius. They attack many many people out in the open to promote several agendas. One and the primary agenda is to demonstrate what they want people to understand are the symptoms of being bombarded with electronic we

zxc

[Anonymous Coward]

4th p0st

While we're discussing "practical" books...

[Yoda2]

from the last millenium , how about this little jewel?

Microsoft and Cthulu?

[Anonymous Coward]

http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb; en-us;297830

Another Question

[Anonymous Coward]

What are you planning on having for supper?

Re:Another Question

[gregarican]

Warmed over pizza with a Mexican beer or two. Next question please...

YEAAARGH!

[Anonymous Coward]

Today my candidacy may come to an end--but our campaign for change is not over.

I want to thank each and every person who has supported this campaign. Over the last year, you have reached out to neighbors, friends, family and colleagues--building one American at a time the greatest grassroots campaign presidential politics has ever seen. I will never forget the work and the heart that you put into our campaign.

In the coming weeks, we will be launching a new initiative to continue the campaign you helped begin. Please continue to come to www.deanforamerica.com for updates and news as our new initiative develops. There is much work still to be done, and today is not an end--it is just the beginning.

This Party and this country needs change, and you have already begun that process. I want you to think about how far we have come. The truth is: change is tough. There is enormous institutional pressure in our country against change. There is enormous institutional pressure in Washington against change, in the Democratic Party against change. Yet, you have already started to change the Party and together we have transformed this race. Along the way, we've engaged hundreds of thousands of new Americans in the political process, as witnessed by this year's record participation in the primaries and caucuses.

The fight that we began can and must continue. Although my candidacy for president may end today, the most important goal remains defeating George W. Bush in November, and I hope that you will join me in doing everything we can to support the Democrats this fall. From the earliest days of our campaign, I have said that the power to change Washington rests not in my hands, but in yours. Always remember, you have the power to take our country back.

Gov. Howard Dean M.D.

Third question

[Anonymous Coward]

Do you like answering questions?

Re:Third question

[gregarican]

Yes. It justifies my existence and provides me with an exaggerated sense of self-importance. Next question...

An indespensible book for the next generation

[Rogerborg]

Learn Hindi in 30 Days

Re:I concur

[Anonymous Coward]

asl?

str8/bi/gay?

spit or swallow?

y

[Anonymous Coward]

tee hee first post