ACPI and S3 Sleep on the Linux Desktop?

niko9 asks: "After reading that development would be ramped up in the ACPI department of the 2.6 kernel series, I was hoping to finally get the one feature that Mac and Windows users have been enjoying for more than a few years: S3 Sleep, also known as Suspend-To-Ram. How important is ACPI and the sleep states on the desktop to you? Are there any ACPI S3 success stories on the Linux desktop out there? If yes, what hardware are you guys using? I would also welcome comments from Mac and Window users concerning their use of sleep on the desktop."

"For those of you not familiar with S3, this feature allows you to save the current state of your machine to RAM, power down all of your internal devices (PCI cards, AGP, CPU) and shut down down all your fans. The machine is now in a deep sleep, using but only a few watts to keep the RAM refreshed. Pressing a key or the power switch brings you back to your desktop and applications in a matter of seconds. In contrast to leaving your machine on constantly, and with today's high wattage processors and graphics cards, using S3 is not only environmentally friendly, but can save you more than a few bucks on your electric bill. Getting Linux and ACPI working is a whole other story. I have had no luck getting ACPI sleep states working on an Intel D875PBZ motherboard, even with extensive help from the gentlemen on the ACPI mailing list."

Comments

Save your Mozilla tabs (OT)

[OldMiner]

You can use Tab Browser Extentions to save your tab session, either on log off automatically, or manually. Be warned, there is some slightly weird menu placement, partially due to the fact that the author is not a native English speaker. I believe Opera does this automatically, with Nordic instead of Japanese authors.

Re:Macs don't sleep to disk

[drsmithy]

I'm also impressed that included in this is logic to notice hardware changes when the system is asleep (ok, more like cat-napping). For example, I typically shut the lid and disconnect my network cable at work, then bring it home and wake it to my WiFi router, OSX will automatically sense and join the new network (same in reverse). The network libraries are robust enough to not cause terrible application-level errors or crashes.

Same goes for recognizing the plugging in or removal of an external monitor during sleep, as well as all the USB devices I've tried.

FY(and others)I XP also does all this quite well IME. Win2k somewhat less so. I've no experience using Windows 9x on laptops.

The only thing that gets a bit flaky IME is detecting external monitors when multi-monitor (ie: spanning) is being used. My D600 used to often either not detect the monitor had been unplugged (hence leaving the bit of the Desktop that had been spanned inaccessible) and/or not detect when a new monitor had been plugged in (hence requiring eith er a visit to Display Properties or another Sleep/wake cycle).

Granted if you took the battery out it would probably dump everything in ram, unless there's some kind of internal backup battery specifically for last minute graceful shutdown everything. But I guess that's the trade-off for not having to wait while half a gig of ram transfers to and from the disk.

PBs seem to have a backup battery to keep the RAM refreshed while the main battery is not present. How long it lasts I never checked accurately, but my old PB 667 certainly used to survive the typical trip through the X-Ray machine suspended - so at least a few minutes (it won't keep for a day, however).

Just wanted to chime in about the Inspiron 8200

[WhiteWolf666]

This thing is a brick in linux, because of power management.

APM works, sorta. Resume from suspend fails about 30% of the time. 20% of the time, resume works okay, but the system is really slow, and the fan stays on 'high' (really noisy) speed.

ACPI is broken. Battery, buttons, temperature, etc. . . can work, if you use a modified DSDT.
S1,S3 don't work. S1 doesn't resume, S3 doesn't turn the screen backlight off. S4,S4b resume about 60% of the time, but it already takes so long to come back up I might as well do a proper shutdown.

BOOO. I WANT A LINUX LAPTOP THAT GOES INTO S3 or S1 PERFECTLY!@!!!!

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE!

I know, I know, I should get a powerbook. In fact, I own a powerbook g4 12" DVI. But I lent it to my sister, 'cause her laptop died.

Don't get me wrong, OS X is awesome. intergrated bluetooth rocks. Lots of great things about this laptop.

But I can't install linux on it and have working power management. I like linux. I know my way around linux. I like hacking around on linux.

But on my laptop, I NEED power management.