Slashdot Mirror
E3 - First Day Shows Multitude Of New Games
Thanks to Eurogamer for its in-depth E3 coverage, as well as GameDaily's detailed write-ups and Ferrago's similarly wide-ranging coverage, as they add to previously-mentioned gaming websites covering the E3 Expo in Los Angeles. Highlights of the first day include hands-on impressions of Conker: Live and Reloaded for Xbox, a seriously in-depth Half-Life 2 interview, some first impressions of Myst IV, confirmation that Sega's signing of The Matrix Online was their 'big announcement', though Phantasy Star Universe was also announced, the list of songs for Donkey Konga, and a hands-on look at Final Fantasy XII. What other software are you most impressed by?
When I read about what I was most impressed by is the lack of original titles.
I don't mean to turn this into a session of bashing E3, because I do think it's always fun and interesting to see what's being released--or at least, what people have on their minds.
However, my reaction to E3 this year has been notably different. It seems that many of the titles are things I've heard about for a couple of years now, or are sequels. Many of the rest of the titles seem unoriginal in the sense of essentially being remakes, in actuality if not in name. So far I'm not aware of any titles that represent radically new game ideas or interesting new games that I've not heard of before. Generally, this is what I've come to expect from E3, and haven't seen it so far.
There's still plenty of time and lots of games, though, so maybe more will surface as E3 continues. It takes awhile to filter through everything, and the most hyped games will invariably be sequels to well-known series from large publishers.
My feelings about E3 intersect with your comments in a couple of ways, though:
I think a better analogy to E3, rather than film, would be car shows. Some of the fun of E3, historically speaking, comes not from finding out when games are released, but to discover new games to salivate over and hope have some upcoming release date in the not-to-distant future. E3 is somewhat like a new car show in that there are invariably new games--like new car prototypes--that may never be released, or will be released in the distant future. The point is to get a peek at what developers are up to and thinking about, and will probably be coming in the future, not to find out what actual release dates are.
In this regard, I think the lack of original, new content at E3 shifts the focus from new content to things like release dates. Because we don't have the new interesting ideas and developers as has sometimes been the case in the past, we find ourselves being concerned with release dates and stuff. To the extent that we can't say "Ooh, look at that title--very interesting idea", we have to say something like "Ooh, look, it's Monster Slayer IX--when is it coming out?"