Slashdot Mirror
RGB to become RGBCMY
elgatozorbas writes "The basic color elements of television have not changed much since 1954; a half-century after RCA introduced the first color set, the RGB (red, green and blue) system used then still prevails. But Israeli company Genoa Color Technologies has broken the RGB barrier by adding one to three primary colors such as yellow, cyan and magenta, thus expanding - from 55 to 95 percent - the coverage of the visible color gamut. The promised result of this multi-primary color (MPC) technology is a television picture that, with its truer, more vibrant color and brighter image, looks more like cinema than video. Also covered in IEEE Spectrum."
I wouldn't. It's taken so long to get HDTV "standard" that it will take just as long to get this new standard in. If everybody just upgraded to HDTV, they won't want to upgrade to this. These guys were about 5 years too late it seems :(
Sometimes the most mundane improvements can be the best. All the people who swear by HDTV will be SOL, because they'll have hi-res, but improperly colored, television/movies.
RGB is a set of orthogonal colors, and a linear combination of RGB can express any color in the universe. Similar comments apply to CMY.
Adding CMY to RGB to create RGBCMY does not buy you anything. Hence, the message starting this discussion thread is misleading.
Why is the television signal so poor in generating an image? The answer is unrelated to RGB. The answer is the the following. Prior to transmission, the analog RGB signal is converted into the digital YCbCr signal. (YCbCr is also an orthogonal set of colors.) Y, luma, is sampled at a reasonable rate, but the sampling system samples Cb and Cr at only half of the sampling rate for Y.
My guess is that RGBCMY is simply a clever attempt to use CMY to restore some of the samples of Cb and Cr that were discarded.
Well, true they have to expand the gamut of existing RGB data artifically, but this is different from what you can do in photoshop. In this case the display can actually show more real colors than a conventional RGB display. Put the two monitors side-by-side, and you will be able to see colors on a RGBCMY monitor that simply cannot be reprodced on any normal RGB monitor. Have you ever taken a digital picture of a beautifully intense blue stain glass window, or some brightly colored flowers, and been disappointed when you got it home to see how bland the colors were on your monitor. The gamut captured by the camera is part of the problem, but even if it captured the colors perfectly, current monitors still couldn't display the results. These new wide gamut monitors should be able to do much better.
Having to "make up" the additional color data is just a temporary measure until content creation software and image acquisition hardware catches up to the gamuts possible with these new monitors.
I, for one, welcome our new RGBCMY masters.