Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Do-Not-Call Registry Coming to Canada

Posted by michael on from the quiet,-eh dept.

The Fred writes "The Globe and Mail reports that the Canadian federal government is looking to devise a national do-not-call registry to match the US attempt. Issues regarding the impact on charities are being analyzed."

2 of 37 comments (clear)

  1. CMA already has a do-not-call list by perp · · Score: 2, Informative
    The Canadian Marketing Association has had a do-not-call registry for a while now and it works pretty well; it has worked well for me anyway.

    They are pissed off that marketeers who do not belong to their organization are not required to do the same.

    --
    There are two kinds of sysadmins: paranoids and losers. I'm both kinds.
  2. Telemarketers for charities == phone spammers by tomhudson · · Score: 2, Informative
    Come to Mississauga. Every other week, I get a call from the Shriners, or the Peel Police, or Heart-and-Stroke, or Canadian Cancer Society, or some other charitable organization asking for pledges. This despite being told repeatedly that I would not like to receive these types of calls.

    The overhead for telemarketing for charities is horrendous - something like 60 - 90% goes to the telemarketers. Avoid them at all cost.

    And for those who don't believe it, here's a link http://http//www.forces.org/evidence/files/bryden1 .htm

    MP's Report
    Canada's Charities: A Need
    For Reform

    John Bryden, MP
    Hamilton-Wentworth
    October 1996

    ...snip ...

    In early January CBC's Marketplace did an excellent report on the high cost to charities of using telemarketing firms. These are companies which specialize in telephone solicitation.

    ... snip ...

    Not all the lines were filled out on the 1994 form but for 1992 they were. Here we find a total of $2.6 million was raised for a 77 per cent fundraising cost of about $2 million. The fee paid to "fundraising agents" was $1,350,621.

    ... snip ...

    Examples are easy to find. Goals for Youth of North York is dedicated to help in school dropouts. Its T3010 form shows that in 1993 it paid an outside fundraising agent $84,194 while raising only $102,857.

    In 1994 the Metro Toronto Branch of the Victorian Order of Nurses (VON) spent $132,385 to raise $168,779. Indeed, given that the VON is fully funded by government to the tune of more than $15 million, it is not at all clear why it should be seeking donations from the public, or receiving them from the United Way.
    Nothing has changed since the report was issued.

    Simple rule of thumb - donating to telephone solicitors just encourages them, same as other spammers.