Slashdot Mirror


CRTs Still Beat Flat-Panel TVs

mr.henry writes "Consumers scrambling for sexy new flat-panel televisions may want to tune in to this less-publicized feature of the trendy boxes: They don't deliver pictures as clearly as traditional tube TVs do. Consumers think they're buying the best in technology (with flat-panel televisions), but it's more of an emotional purchase."

8 of 686 comments (clear)

  1. Expensive by adennis · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The thing I like most about the new LCDs and Plasma screens is that it makes the CRTs less expensive...

    I don't mind the bulkiness because I get bonuses: Cheaper price and (not just according to this article, but personal experience) a better picture...


    but flat panels still look so cool...

  2. Size, shape and weight by SamSeaborn · · Score: 4, Insightful
    Just because a CRT has a sharper, brighter picture doesn't mean it's an "emotional decision" to buy the new technology.

    People (especially ladies) like the flat screens because of their super slim depth, massive picture size, and amazing light-weight.

    Show me a 60" CRT -- and if you can even find one, find a rec-room it would fit in, and try and lift it!

    Sam

  3. Color Gamut by andreMA · · Score: 5, Insightful
    A good friend of mine works as a digital compositor in a Hollywood special effects house and swears that LCDs have a long way to go in color fidelity.

    The issue isn't resolution or viewing angle.

  4. Re:Doesn't add up... by aengblom · · Score: 5, Insightful

    are you telling me that "Regular Ol' TVs" are better than flat HDTVs?

    No, they are telling you that HDTV's made with CRT technology (The huge, heavy boxes) display a better picture than the thing plasma or LCD screens. The article is pointing out -- quite rightly -- that general consumers have associated "thin" with "high tech and good picture."

    In fact, if you have the space, you can buy a sizable CRT HDTV for a relatively affordable price. Not cheap, but something an average consumer could afford if they were willing to sacrifice a bit.

    On the other hand, I believe this trend has continued because people genuinely really do like the thin, lighter screens.

    Like it or not a television is one of the most dominant objects in a many peoplees homes. They don't want it big, bulky and ugly.

    One theory I read awhile back was that there has always been a significant number of wealthy men who wanted to go buy a big screen televeision, but were basically restrained by their wives who didn't want the huge ugly beheamouth in their living room. Sure, that flat screen costs twice as much, but now the wife says go for it because its not ugly.

    --


    So close and yet so far from the world's perfect ID number
  5. Other Flat panel technology by zymano · · Score: 4, Insightful
  6. Re:People like my uncle by dominion · · Score: 4, Insightful

    As much as this can create some benefits for those of us who are poor (like dual g4's with 512mb ram on ebay for $400), they cause a lot of problems in the market in places where the goods are a little bit more necessary.

    Take food, for instance. I would very much like to buy organically grown, chemical and gmo free vegetables (which my grandfather was able to buy when he was my age), but because those have become yuppie foods, they're priced out of my price range. There's no reason that veggie burgers should be more expensive than real burgers, where you have to raise a whole damn cow as opposed to growing some soybeans, but because they're trendy, people pay a lot of money for them.

    The "stupid rich" create benefits for things like technology, because they offset R&D costs when the company overprices when it first comes to market. But for goods that I feel everybody deserves the highest quality, they really make life difficult.

  7. Re:Why flat-panel TVs are selling. by Anubis350 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I can tink of two reasons other than hype why flat-panel tvs are selling like hotcakes

    1)they take up far less space, its a big deal believe it or not. Its why I got a flat panel for my computer and why many people buy flat-panel tvs. The less space a device takes up, the more space there is for other things and the less cramped the room looks. and speaking of looks....

    2)They look damn sexy. Remember, these are living room pieces and you want them to look good. This isnt a piece of hardware you stuff under the desk, its displayed prominently in most peoples living rooms. In short its like furniture and people want it to look good.

    3)The awe value, i.e. your friends walk in and go ohhhhh-ahhhhh.

    make sense now?
    --Anubis

    --
    "goodbye and hello, as always" ~Prince Corwin, from Zelazny's Amber series
  8. Re:People like my uncle by m_evanchik · · Score: 5, Insightful

    #Turning Economics Lecture Mode ON#

    The reason veggie burgers are more expensive is not too much demand from those yuppies, but just not enough supply from producers. There isn't a big supply because there isn't a big demand at any price. Most people prefer real meat.

    To get the economies of scale needed to provide cheap veggie burgers, a lot more people would need to want to eat veggie burgers.

    As to your Grandpa getting cheap "organic" food, my guess is that relative to his income, his "organic" food was more expensive than your organic food is relative to your income. Food prices have declined sharply over the last century.