Slashdot Mirror


MelbourneIT Lapse Permitted Panix Hijack

McSpew writes "Netcraft reports MelbourneIT's CTO, Bruce Tonkin, has admitted the Panix domain hijacking occurred because of a loophole in MIT's domain transfer process. He doesn't go into detail about what that loophole was, or how it was closed. As a Panix user, I'd like more detail, and I'd like to know what can be done to stop this sort of nonsense happening to other domains."

8 of 200 comments (clear)

  1. hey by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    someone call the waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaambulance!

  2. I had my penix hijacked by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    FP!!!

  3. Re:Meh by Geoffreyerffoeg · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Unless it runs on MacOS or will be available in a smaller form factor of varying stylish colors, I fail to see how this is postworthy on Slashdot.

    The point is that Panix currently doesn't run on MacOS, and isn't available, whatever the form factors and colors may be.

  4. That, and... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    ..."Netcraft confirms it: Panix is dead."

  5. Speaking Of Domain Hijacking.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    How would you feel if your webmaster maliciously took your web-site offline, then, when you demanded its return, put up a site attacking your company at your old URL? It happened to a group I was involved in, the Censorware Project, currently at http://www.censorware.net [censorware.net]. The purpose of this essay is to put the behavior on record, and to give you some impressions and inferences about it.

    The Censorware Project was originally an informal collective of six people who collaborated online to fight censorware: Seth Finkelstein [sethf.com], Bennett Haselton [peacefire.org], Jamie McCarthy [mccarthy.vg], Mike Sims, Jim Tyre and myself. Several of us had never met or even spoken on the phone, yet for some time -- around two years as I recall -- we had a remarkably easy collaboration. There was no funding, no hierarchy, no titles, not even project managers. Someone would suggest a project and take the responsibility for a part of it, others would sign up for other elements, and proceeding this way we got a remarkable amount of work done, including reports on X-Stop, Cyberpatrol, Bess and other censorware products.

    Even though two of us were attorneys -- Jim and myself -- we never incorporated the group or wrote a charter or any contracts among ourselves. Mike Sims was obliging enough to register the domain, just as other members paid for press releases and the other incidental expenses which came along. Mike also served as webmaster of the censorware.org site and did substantial work [sethf.com] for the group, including writing contributions to several of the reports and lead authorship of at least one. Seth was the source [sethf.com] of our decrypted censorware blacklists [sethf.com] and managed many technical tasks, but later felt he had to leave the group because of the increasing prospects of a lawsuit [chillingeffects.org], particularly under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). After Seth left the group, the remaining five continued.

    Robert Frost said that "nothing gold can stay," and the Censorware Project was no exception. Over the summer of 2000, Mike Sims' reaction to a perceived slight from Jim Tyre was to take the site down for a week. He sent us mail at the time saying something like "The Censorware Project is now closed." [sethf.com] I replied to him that, given that the group was a collective and we all had an interest in its work product, the domain, and the goodwill it had achieved, the decision was not his to make. Sims did not reply.

    After Seth created a partial, text, mirror, Mike put the site back up a week later without explaining, let alone apologizing for, his actions. Given his continuing failure to answer any email from me (and I think from others) and the overall signs that Sims thought the group was exclusively his, I wrote him several emails requesting that he turn the domain over to Jamie or Bennett, as I felt we could no longer trust him to administer it. We also found out during that time that important email from people trying to contact us, including members of the press, was not being answered by Sims, nor being forwarded to other members.

    I ultimately became exasperated that my name was listed as a principal on what had now become a "rogue" site I had no control over. Over about a five week period, I wrote Sims several more emails asking him to delete my name from the site if he wasn't going to transfer the domain. Again, I received no reply.

    In November 2000, Sims took the Censorware Project site offline again, with a message saying "Due to demands from some of the people who cont

  6. Re:Overworked by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Recently I was asked for my expert opinion (IT admin for 5 years) on the architecture for our new groupware solution for inter-office communications. My boss told me the current plan was Windows Server with Sharepoint and SQL Server.

    Well, normally I would just go along with it and quietly get my paycheck, but this time I had been inspired by recent Slashdot postings about the power of open source. I had done some studying up on my own, too.

    So when my boss put the question to me, I responded with "That could work, but I'm thinking Ubuntu Warty Warthog or Debian Woody, with Derby 0.9 database and of course X-Bitch client to keep in touch".

    Well, now I'm unemployed just like you all and I'm looking for a job. All I know is, nobody ever got fired for buying Dell and Microsoft. Damn slashbots... a curse on you!

  7. Re:Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    /9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAQEARwBHAAD/2wBDAA0JCgsKCA0LCgsODg 0PEyAVExISEyccHhcgLikxMC4p
    LSwzOko+MzZGNywtQFdBRk xOUlNSMj5aYVpQYEpRUk//2wBDAQ4ODhMREyYVFSZPNS01T09P T09P
    T09PT09PT09PT09PT09PT09PT09PT09PT09PT09PT09P T09PT09PT09PT0//wAARCAGPASwDASIA
    AhEBAxEB/8QAHAAB AAEFAQEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAcBAwQFBgII/8QAThAAAQMDAQQGBg YFCAcJAAAA
    AQACAwQFEQYSITFBBxMUUWFxIiMygZGhQlJysc HRFTOy4fAWJDQ2YnSSohdTc4KDk8IlNUNFVFVk
    4vH/xAAaAQ EAAwEBAQAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAwQFAQIG/8QAKREBAAICAgMAAgEC BwAAAAAAAAECAxEE
    MQUSISJBEzJRI0JSgZGhsf/aAAwDAQAC EQMRAD8Ak5ERAREQEREBERAREQEREBERAXmR7I2F8j2s
    Y0ZL nHAC5HVmvqGxOfSUjRV1w4tB9CM/2j3+A+Sie86iu17kLrhWSP ZnIiB2WN8mjcgmG56+05bn
    OYa3tMg+jTt2/nw+a52q6Wqdri KS0yvHIyyhvyAKitEEm/6W35/7lbj+8/8A1XuLpbbteusxDe9t
    Rk/sqL0QTPQ9J9hqCG1LKmlPe9m0Pi3P3LqrddbfdIzJb6yG oaOPVvBI8xxC+bldp6ielmbNTTPi
    lactexxaR7wg+mEUVaV6 S5opGUmoT1sRwG1LW+k37QHEePHzUpQTRVMDJ4JGyRSDaa9pyH DwKD2i
    IgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIg LhekbWD7PF+i7c7FbMzL5Af1TT3f2j8l2l
    ZUx0VFPVTHEcMZ e7yAyvnO6V810uVRXVLsyTvLz4dw9w3IMUkuJJJJO8kqiIgIiI CIiC7TR9bUMY
    eBO9dDLYI3wGRg2TjktLa8duZldXUXOGCDZ2 gN3NBx1TTvp5Sx48j3rqtB6wksNWKSte59umOCOP
    VH6w8O8L nbjVRVLstByDxWCg+nGPbIxr2ODmuGQQcghVUc9FWpDUU7rHVy ZkhG1Tknizm33cfLyU
    jICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgI iICIiAiIgIiIOT6Tas0ujahrSQah7It3dnJ+QKg5TH0u/1
    Xp /7039lyhxAREQEREBERB6a5zHBzSQRzCOe55y9xJ8SvKuOgmbE JXRuEZ4OxuQW0REGXarhParn
    T19M7EsDw4ePePeNy+jKKpjr aKCqgOY5mB7T4EZXzQpn6KbkazTDqWRxL6OUsGfqnePxQdsiIg Ii
    ICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiDhelz+q8H96b +y5Q4pj6XP6rwf3pv7LlElBTGsroac
    fTdg+SC9b7TW3E/zaL Lc42juCz6qguVrbtV1NHUQ8HAjOPfxCk6x2Z0UDGxxBrAMZO4L YVun+1xF
    rnRgkcCMoIOrIImtZPSuJgkzgO4sP1T+axVvNV2a ew3aSleMQy+sjxwI/ctGgLZWyx1tyw6JmxF9
    d+4e7vWRpezO vFx2NgujjGXDv7gpfodPMip2NeQzA4AcEEcxaJaWenUSF3gAFi V1prtODro3dfSu
    3SRvG4jxUustkDHbLZQXDkQtTqG1yzUkjH R7cZGDsoIYrWw9dt0xHVv9IN5t8FjrJr6R9FWy08gO
    WHdnmO SxkBSL0O1JbdLhSZ3SQtk97Tj/AKlHS7Dotm6rWcLMn1sMjPPd n8EE2oiICIiAiIgIiICI
    iAiIgIiICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIg4fp bYXaUicBuZVMJ+DlG+ioWz6po438CSfkVK3SXCZdE1hA3xuY
    /wDzD81FOip20+q6F7zgFxb8QQg6PXmrrjHen2y21L6WnpsNcY 9xc7nv8Fn2W+3Oz3G3x11e6utt
    wIY2SX2o3Hgcrk9fUr6XV1 aXg7MxErD3ggfjlYRu7n2aloXZ2qefba7ub3fFBIvS3SMksdLV 49ZD
    Psg+Dgc/MBRTHTzSxufHGXNZxI5KYdfxTXPTcNJSgSTv kY8tzwGOKjpmlr5D6UQa0/2ZFDbkYqzq
    1oeopaeodN0VRgip dzMgB9wW66R9Tz2alhobe8x1VSC50g4sZw3eJWk0DHX2u8Tw11 OY2TgOa76O
    0PFa7pVcXapZk5Ap27PxKkreto3WduTEx20tin jqK8trKqpZUSH1c7ZDkO8VKGh9QS3LtVrrpRNV
    UZ/W/wCsZ3 nx71CoJBBBII4ELt+igyHU87hktNO7bP8AvDC9OMjpUs7aWsp7 jC3DJssf58VH6lfp
    ekAtFDHzdOT8AfzUUIC6bo5cG64txPMv H+Ry5ldBoJ4ZrS2E85SPi0hBPqIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgIi
    ICIi AiIgIiICIiAiIgIiIOf17GZNF3MDiIg74OBUDU8z6apiniOHxO D2nxByvoLVzQ7Sd1B4dlkP
    waV89xxulkbHGMuccAIJW1Na4t XaSprvb8GphZtN3+036TT4grmrBpLLmz3FuXcRFyHmtppyCpoL
    X2J07yxzttzM7gfBdHTsDWrE5vkJ/ox/8ruHj6+2Up4JmPcZ XgsxhrccFf6naG7ivQ3q5wG5Yc2m
    Z2nswI6SobUOc+QOiPBu OCwr3p2ju5D6gPErRgPa7eB3LejgvDt6sxe+P8qzqUUxE9o1qd DXFk7W
    08sMkbjjbcdnZHef3KTtIabpNO28thkE88uDLN3+A7 gsctyFbmiEtP

  8. YOU 7AIL IT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic