I hope the US government doesn't sue for copyright infringement.
Thank god for the Senate
by
canwaf
·
· Score: 5, Insightful
This worries me, the DMCA has simply be used as a hammer to knock people around who practise fair use. Canada's copyright laws are perfectly fine the way they are, and continue to strike a pleasant balance between the rights of the population, and the rights of the creators.
Since the CRIA is behind this push, we can only assume that they have the ear of the House of Commons. They were the ones who wanted, and got, taxes on recordable media given to them to promote "Canadian Talent", but they can't have it both ways...
I sincerely believe that the Senate Committee which will be spawned by the proposed amendments to the Copyright Act come around will probably come to the same conclusion as they have before.
The DMCA in the US has been a dismal failure, and there is no need to repeat this same error in Canada.
"The Canadian government politely asks its citizens to 'bend over'".
--
Karma: Chameleon (mostly due to the fact that you come and go).
How to defeat this legislation
by
stinerman
·
· Score: 3, Insightful
It all depends on who your MP is.
If you have a Liberal MP... well good luck I have no advice for you, they're pushing the bill.
If you have a Conservative MP, base your objections on the fact that this bill is designed to harmonize IP law with the rest of the world. Who cares about the rest of the world? Canada for Canadians!
If you have a BQ MP, start ranting about how this bill threatens French Canadian culture.
Finally, if you have an NDP MP, simply tell the truth. This is a sellout to wealthy corporations.
Re:How to defeat this legislation
by
canwaf
·
· Score: 4, Funny
And if your MP is Carylon Parrish, just say that it's based off an American law...
Love the quote
by
JediTrainer
·
· Score: 3, Informative
From the article: "If someone discovered the combination of your bike lock, should they be able to publish it? I think the making it public part is the real sticking point."
I would agree that no, the shouldn't be allowed to publish your bike lock combination. However, if someone discovered that the bike lock can be opened by sticking a pen in it, I should have a right to know that the lock I bought has a serious vulnerability. And the way for me to find out about it is that this information has been published.
--
You can accomplish anything you set your mind to. The impossible just takes a little longer.
Slashdot Mirror
"Okay."
I hope the US government doesn't sue for copyright infringement.
This worries me, the DMCA has simply be used as a hammer to knock people around who practise fair use. Canada's copyright laws are perfectly fine the way they are, and continue to strike a pleasant balance between the rights of the population, and the rights of the creators.
Since the CRIA is behind this push, we can only assume that they have the ear of the House of Commons. They were the ones who wanted, and got, taxes on recordable media given to them to promote "Canadian Talent", but they can't have it both ways...
I sincerely believe that the Senate Committee which will be spawned by the proposed amendments to the Copyright Act come around will probably come to the same conclusion as they have before.
The DMCA in the US has been a dismal failure, and there is no need to repeat this same error in Canada.
"The Canadian government politely asks its citizens to 'bend over'".
Karma: Chameleon (mostly due to the fact that you come and go).
It all depends on who your MP is.
... well good luck I have no advice for you, they're pushing the bill.
If you have a Liberal MP
If you have a Conservative MP, base your objections on the fact that this bill is designed to harmonize IP law with the rest of the world. Who cares about the rest of the world? Canada for Canadians!
If you have a BQ MP, start ranting about how this bill threatens French Canadian culture.
Finally, if you have an NDP MP, simply tell the truth. This is a sellout to wealthy corporations.
From the article: "If someone discovered the combination of your bike lock, should they be able to publish it? I think the making it public part is the real sticking point."
I would agree that no, the shouldn't be allowed to publish your bike lock combination. However, if someone discovered that the bike lock can be opened by sticking a pen in it, I should have a right to know that the lock I bought has a serious vulnerability. And the way for me to find out about it is that this information has been published.
You can accomplish anything you set your mind to. The impossible just takes a little longer.