Slashdot Mirror
Alternatives to SBC?
bionic-john asks: "We are a relatively small shop running 11 point-to-point T-1's carrying both voice and data. It seems weekly we have an issue, and it takes SBC at least a day from notification to resolution. To my knowledge, they are the only game in Chicago since they control all the copper which resellers just resell. The data bit is easy -- DSL with VPN, but what about the voice and central voice-mail? I have spoken with other vendors offering pseudo-VOIP using a hardware layer between their CO and our voice-switch, but it seems like the technology is still in its infancy, is not fully tested, and it's still SBC copper out the door. The strange thing with all this is, that we have just as many PRI's, and probably 1/20th of our issues involve those. It's always the point-to-point. What am I missing? What can I do?"
Start here.
goINET
:P
;)
Mr. Ashkar, you owe me.
Actually, check with your local wisps. Most of them will bend over backwards to meet your needs and get your business, and give you all of the personal attention you could ever want.
Smaller companies tend to be like that.
If you're in St. Louis though, give me a call and we'll get you straightened out.
Karma: Chameleon (mostly due to the fact that you come and go).
Does your contract with SBC include any kind of SLA?
Do your problems repeat on the same T1 or migrate from T1 to T1?
Do you experience new and different problems?
Do you have a documented history of the problems?
How many POPs or COs do your P-to-P T1s cover? I'm assuming you have a star pattern, with the center hub being one end point for each of the T1s.
Of course, a lot of this is speculative, without any solid information to go on, this is pure guesswork.
Look to see if you have an SLA in your contract. If you do, are they honoring it? If not, rattle the sabres. It may or may not make any difference. You might also start complaining to your state's regulatory office that oversees SBC.
Do they ever give you a satisfactory explanation of the problems? If the same problem keeps happening repeatedly, then you may need to escalate to higher levels of management (SBC) to address the problem. Again, it may or may not help.
If you do not have SLA, look at other carriers in the area for P-to-P T1s. MCI/Worldcom (whatever they call themselves now), Sprint, not to mention other regional carriers are likely available in that area. Get a tough SLA on that deal. Even if SBC provides the copper, if you get a deal with another "name brand" carrier that includes a tough SLA, sometimes your new provider will be more influential in getting SBC to honor their obligations.
While it certainly isn't fun, you can sometimes gain more traction with this method since SBC's failure to fix the problem is now affecting another common carrier, and not a private individual, which means the other carrier can cause SBC some serious problems. Of course, you'll often need a though SLA to "motivate" the new provider to aggressively deal with SBC.
How close are your locations? Have you considered a ds3 or fiber ring instead of point to point? Depending on what kinds of problems you are having, and if they are located at the end points, the center of the hub, or in between within SBC transport facilities, a ring approach may or may not help.
Have you contacted your sales rep? Those guys are typically on commission. Don't know if they get recurring commissions for keeping you happy, but if they do, he could be another person you can motivate to work on your behalf. If you were to jump to another carrier, even if SBC provided the copper, he'd lose his commission from your circuits.
Just a few ideas. If you want to provide more information, I'm sure myself or others would be able to provide even better suggestions.
. 62,400 repetitions make one truth -- Brave New World, Aldous Huxley
11 T-1s...
You know, that's a chunk of change. If your telco is not giving you good service, "talk" to them about it.
"Who are in control, they are not in control of anything - they don't even control themselves!" - Glen Beck
My first suggestion would be to switch from point-to-point to frame relay connections. It will add a bit of overhead, and a touch of lag, but overall, it will let your T1's "data" move through your provider's network to work around bad spots.
Secondly, your SLA with your service provider should give you quite a bit of leverage. With point-to-point connections, some service providers will only offer 2 nines, which would mean about three and a half days of downtime a year. It's not really cost-effective to build redundant datapaths for point-to-point connections, so along the entire path there are probably many points of failure.
My first thought was "Cooperative Baptist Fellowship", but then I realised the article wasn't about the Southern Baptist Convention. :-)
I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.
might some of these providers help?
http://www.rcn.com/business/index.php
http://www.abovenet.com/products/maps.html
http://work.comcast.net/smallbusiness.asp
http://www.level3.com/3385.html
http://www.cogentco.com/htdocs/map.php#
And I can tell you definitely, that you're paying WAY TOO MUCH for those T1's.
That said, I know what you want is service, not price. If you go with a CLEC (a company which resells products the ILEC (the monopoly) sells, you're going through both SBC and a middle-man.
So, it's important that you get a good CLEC which is both very service oriented and is populated with at least some ex-SBC people who can call SBC Vice-Presidents who are old friends to get you back up in a timely manner, when SBC screws you, which they'll do from time to time. I know we make those calls, when the ILEC just isn't doing the right things, but I don't know about other CLECs.
When you're getting the ILEC to do something, like diagnose a line, you're often talking to underlings who don't know what they're doing. It's hugely helpful to have someone on your side of the phone who knows both their job and thei manager's job.
Get a CLEC.
Ask around. Get a company that's been in business for more than just a few years. And watch the salesman. If he gets all excited about some point to point T1's, that means they're small (or he is, unfortunately) and that they'll CARE about your business, unlike SBC.
And don't go with MCI. They're AWFUL, unless you're a giant company.
Bell (in your case, SBC) is the resident monopoly. Since 1996 there are Competitive Local Exchange Carriers that can also offer you service. I'm not in Chicago, sorry, but do work for a CLEC in Texas. CLECs can (and it's not too hard) offer much better service than Menu Hell Bell. In fact my company has a policy of sending techs to fix problems before generating the trouble ticket -- sure that makes it harder for us to manage things internally, but boy do our customers appreciate it. Not all CLECs are worthwhile, and not all offer a savings over Bell. Some (*cough* Allegiance *cough*) are less than truthful and suck big time.
Now, you need to find a "facilities-based" provider. This is a telco with a switch or more and its own fiber (usually not copper). But it is the "last mile", that is, the fiber from the CLEC's line into your building to your wiring closet that is usually provided by Bell. That line, then, needs to be tested by your CLEC's technicians and if it does not pass sufficiently, your CLEC needs to demand a different circuit to be installed.
Implicit in my words above is the thought that you would be using T1s for voice, data, and/or integrated circuits and not just unbundled copper loops. You indicated that this was your situation when you referred to "PRIs".
If the customer wants to be completely on a CLECs fiber network (to the CO, of course), then such a customer will likely need to pay to have the line pulled and the building lit. That can run $40/foot for buried cable. Ariel is less expensive, of course. If your CLEC has fiber nearby your office, you might want to make a deal to have it pulled for you. But it is not cheap.
Right now I'm talking with a company that wants two OC-48s in their local data center. We're pricing out building out to their building versus leasing the last mile from SBC. Most likely we'll lease the last mile from Bell. It's just that much cheaper.
And, by all means, avoid VoIP unless you have only technical customers calling in. Anyone else will think you're based in a Third World Nation. Dynamic T1s (that allocate 64k channels for voice or data on the fly based on usage) are also suspect. Stick with what works: Static T1 voice and data, maybe an integrated T1 for smaller businesses.
-- @rjamestaylor on Ello
We also use SBC for our P2P T1 and our DIA T1 at our locations, but have not had ANY problems during business hours. I do get a larger amount of emails telling me they are doing maintence. Overall, I had one outage and that was when someone across the street cut our wires. We are by O'Hare so they may have a bit more reliablity built in there.
Error: Sig not found.
there's always the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship.
Oh wait.
Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
As "Copper not the problem" mentioned in the thread most of what seems to be your issue is SBC customer care. I am a sales manager with Globalcom, Inc also in Chicago. We have been in business for 13+ years for that very reason that SBC can't (or won't) provide the customer service that customers like yourself need. Assuming from the number of services you have with SBC you probably do have a dedicated account team, but that doesn't mean they know how to fix your problems. I would definitely recommend you look into working with an alternative provider to SBC, and you will likely get your best service and support from a CLEC in the market. As for my company, many of our techs are transplants from SBC and know the internal roadblocks and procedures that many times are causing your problems to not get resolved with SBC and more importantly know how to stop the recurring problems that you are having. If you are serious about getting the service (and reliability) that you need....look at Globalcom, or a similar provider, you will see a major difference. Bottom line is that SBC is too big for their own good and can't effectively support their customers....especially one's with recurring issues like yourself. Check out our website.... www.callglobalcom.com ON A SIDE NOTE: I guarantee you are also paying WAY TOO MUCH for your services..........email me if you have questions ryakos@callglobalcom.com
Unless you really have only point to point applications, look into MPLS frame or an MPLS provider. Often you can get away with less bandwidth because you abandon hub and spoke model. If you VOIP it is cheaper to MPLS, if not it might be more expensive :(
1) MPLS contracts usually come with clear and enforceable SLAs. That will help mitigate your downtime and control the vendor.
2) MPLS can hand off on DSL or frame or all sorts of ways depending on the provider.
3) is is multi-point to multi-point and you don't have to keep up with the config (just the ip scheme and routing really).
4) QoS
4a) if you like it enough you can use it for VOIP- converged networks can save you some coin.
5) There is competition in that space, so you can get good deals, and likely better service.
The local loop may still be sbc, but at least you'll be calling a better tech support group at another company.
If you want to stay with your current tech:
use standard vendor tactic: competition.
For example, call your sales rep, let them know you are un-happy and thinking about moving providers. Mention any direct comptitors (Time Warner, MCI, etc...), a name drop never hurts when negotiating.
also try to get your contract and check for SLAs. If you have no enforceable service level agreements for availability (uptime) and qos (latency at least), either renegotiate or take your requirements elsewhere.
-A
From our experiences in St. Louis (smaller setup, but point-to point T1s and PRI)
SBC has been pretty responsive, really. The problem with CLECs (and none of the responding ones have really mentioned) is that if it is a Bell hardware problem, your wait time won't be decreased a whit. On our PTP lines via SBC, we can typically get a tech onsite/at the pole in about 2 hours. When the PRI goes down, the CLEC spends 4 hours testing it, calls Bell....etc, etc - I've never had it resolved, or even seen a tech in less than 8 hours.
I'm curious about why your PRIs seem to be more reliable - both ride on a T1...so look for the differences there. And when you have an outage, is it dead to the smartjack? (i.e. are you losing the last-mile copper, or is it upstream from there) Try to find CO maps to determine where the circuits run - might you have a bad CO with a leaking roof that 5 lines run through...
I don't have any good answers for you. But look for the common thread in the outages. Demand an explanation each and every time you have an outage - try not to accept 'dunno' as an answer (you'll get a lot of those). If hardware is common with all of your PTP, look hard at that. Our PRI was extremely dodgy for a long time after installation. A newer firmware version card in the switch made a large difference.
Good luck...
Hi, I'm from the south west side of Chicago, and I've got a t-1 too, but its only 1 not the 20 that you need. My service provider is McLeodUSA, if I have a problem they can diagnose it remotely, and its ususally taken care of the same day. Its still SBC lines going out, but they get guys out very quickly if they need too. Check them out www.mcleodusa.com
A while back (pre-2000) I worked at a company that had 20+ Frame Relay lines (56K to T1) through Sprint. The contract we had with them was that they owned the line all the way to the jack on our DSU/CSU. Even if the building wiring had a problem, it was THEIR problem. I only had to call the support centre. They handled the phone comapny (BellSouth, SBC, Sprint Local, etc). I usually got a very good response time.
s printLinkFrameRelay.jsp
http://www.sprint.com/business/products/products/
The downfall was that there was no Internet connection from the same line. But the up side of that was there was no need to worry about getting hacked from every monkey on the net. I think that has changed. They might have a gateway service.