Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

British Police Demand Access To Encryption Keys

Posted by Zonk on from the among-other-things dept.

flip-flop writes "In the wake of recent terrorist attacks, police here in the UK have asked for sweeping new powers they claim will help them counter the threat. Among these is making it a criminal offense for people to refuse disclosing their encryption keys when the police want to access someone's files." From the article: "The most controversial of the police proposals is the demand to be able to hold without charge a terrorist suspect for three months instead of 14 days. An Acpo spokesman said the complexity and scale of counter-terrorist operations means the 14-day maximum is often insufficient."

3 of 814 comments (clear)

  1. Oh yeah, that's why we threw their tea away by SeanTobin · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Innocent until proven guilty. Although that statement is ignored just as often in the US as it is in England, laws that we pass try to at least give the impression that we respect it. So, here is how things go if this passes...

    GoodGuy has a friend who is in some domestic trouble and is hiding some of his assets in off-shore accounts. He keeps his friends account information in an encrypted folder on his computer because his friend doesn't want to lose it and trusts him.

    EvilAgentMan thinks GoodGuy is a terrorist planning on taking over the world, due to his recent purchase of a salt water aquarium, baby sharks, laser pointers and duct tape. He charges GoodGuy as being a EvilDoer(TM) and puts him in jail. While looking for evidence, he notices an encrypted folder on GoodGuy's computer. He tells GoodGuy that he must hand over his encryption keys or be charged with the crime of not handing over his encryption keys. He must decide on going to jail for something he is completely innocent of, or releasing potentially incriminating evidence on his friend. ...Time to get pricing on high speed internet access on the moon I guess. This planet's done for.

    --
    Karma: SELECT `karma` FROM `users` WHERE `userid`=138474;
  2. The Right to Prevent Self-Incrimination by westcoaster004 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    What is the difference between the right to prevent self-incrimination (i.e. the right to silence) and the right to not say your password?

    In England and Wales, "a defendant cannot be convicted solely due to their silence" yet this is saying precisely the opposite.

  3. Re:This is a major point by symbolic · · Score: 5, Interesting


    They want encryption keys, but I dare say that not ONE of the investigators (or government officials) can point to a single connection between the recent stuff in London and encrypted information. They keep demanding solutions to problems that don't exist - that's why this stuff keeps happening. If they'd try to solve the problems that DO exist, they might get somehwere- WITHOUT becoming a police state.