Slashdot Mirror


Cingular to Offer Radio Service

Mika24 writes "Red Herring is reporting that Cingular Wireless will launch a new over-the-air-radio service in conjunction with the TV service they will offer with MobiTV." The music programming will be done by Music Choice and will include rock, urban, country, reggae, jazz, electronica, and classical. From the article: "MobiRadio uses the improving screen capabilities on cell phones to offer album art and information about songs and artists during playback. Cingular said it will expand that capability to let subscribers purchase related ringtones and other content while the music is playing--a set of features made popular by satellite radio providers."

13 of 76 comments (clear)

  1. I don't get it by ThatGeek · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I don't get it. At all.

    What's the point of this service? All those guys and gals with ipods won't care; they already have a better tool for playing the music that they like. Few others will have earbuds for their phones, so they'll either have to put the music on speaker phone (often not available on cells) and annoy everyone around them, or hold their phones up to their ear for hours at a time while they listen to the music.

    I can't wait until people start using up their airtime minutes listening to messages like "this music brought to you by [advertiser's name here]".

    Rather than trying to bundle music with phones, why can't they bundle wireless more cheaply? Even just improving connectivity with email would be pretty huge in my mind.

    --
    What are you eating? isItVeg?.
    1. Re:I don't get it by squiggleslash · · Score: 2, Insightful
      I would assume the point is to provide quality radio stations that would otherwise be unavailable to consumers without XM/Sirius receivers. Remember - FM radio in America sucks. It's not difficult to better it. If the price is low enough, people will sign up.

      The real question is not "What's the point?" but "Is this a viable package?", and everything I've read on this deal has essentially had so much missing it's impossible to say. IF Cingular doesn't plan to charge people 3c/kilobyte or at their absurd mMode/MediaNET rates (which pretty much precludes listening to a 64kbps stream - supposedly MP3Pro is "FM quality" at that rate - for more than a few minutes), and IF cellphones are provided with easy stereo-out (which might just mean an adapter for the headset socket), then it's almost a reasonable idea. People currently considering XM/Sirius may be tempted, as theoretically the form factor is more practical.

      Until Cingular does more than waffle about it in press-releases, it's hard to tell what they're actually selling.

      --
      You are not alone. This is not normal. None of this is normal.
  2. Who really wants this? by TheoGB · · Score: 4, Insightful

    My mobile battery is fine now and can deal with day to day stuff but I can't really see it coping much with TV in my hand.

    And on top of that, I'm at a loss to think how often I'd really want to squint at a screen that size. While it's true that I normally have my mobile with me, something like the PSP or similar isn't much larger and seems far more practical.

    That's before I even think about what the cost must be to receive these broadcasts.

  3. Lame. by Seumas · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This might have been interesting 20 years ago. I don't want to watch crappy choppy videos on my cellphone screen. *Maybe* on my Treo 650, but probably not there either. And I certainly don't want pre-programmed "music choice" crap from some lame network running over Cingular.

    Hell, I don't really even need my Treo. It was just a good deal, so I went for it even though I don't use 95% of the features.

    Let's quit with the iPod+Cell thing already, eh?

  4. over-the-air-radio service by Patrik_AKA_RedX · · Score: 5, Funny

    Wireless radio? Who had ever tought that would be possible. Now we'll be able to listen to radio in our cars! Soon these might even be small enough to be carried around. I expect that to happen in the near future, sometime around 1950 or so.

  5. Re:Offering radio services, meanwhile... by DilbertLand · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I've heard people claim that Apple doesn't add the FM tuners to the iPod because, in general, the receivers aren't great quality and they don't want the complaints about less than ideal radio reception. It's the only explaination I can see as to why they won't add a 15cent chip to a $400 player....

  6. Re:Like Satellite Radio by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Personally, the reason I don't use Satellite Radio is I'm already being nickel and dimed to death with monthly ISP bills, cable bills, phone bills, etc... I just draw the line at paying a monthly fee for radio when I can turn on my car radio and receive local stations for free. Although my favorite local station just changed their format and I find there's less quality locally now, it's still not enough to make me want to add yet another monthly luxury fee to my budget when there's a free alternative available. This is also why I still play MUDs and not WoW or whatever other subscription based graphical games are in favor currently.

  7. Yet Another Pay-Twice Solution by montale127 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    i already get all the tunes i want for free on my cingular phone - and i mean ALL: everything i have at home already, everything i listen to on internet radio (mostly the kickass stuff over at http://www.somafm.org/), everything in the Virgin Digital library of, what, 2M songs.

    oh, right, and all my podcasts

    for free

    why do these guys think i'm going to be willing to pay AGAIN for music just because the device is different? once you've put the Web on a device (and, ok, a streaming player that's got access to any URL), i'm done

    what i'm wondering is: do you think that local storage will be like 80% or 50% of the way you get your stuff to your phone in a year's time?

    the orb freeware http://www.orb.com/ STREAMS my stuff to me, local or online somewhere - transcoding it on the fly to adapt to my at-the-moment bitrate and default media player. for Net radio while driving, that's killer. but what about stuff that's at home? i haven't got a huge-ass memory disk for my phone yet...

    --
    You'd be surprised what's not on the map in this country. - Mulder
  8. Re:Like Satellite Radio by montale127 · · Score: 2, Informative
    once you can listen to cellular-radio music in your car.


    you can do that today. for free.

    http://www.orb.com/ and go to the Custom Channels thing in Setup -> Audio to add any of your Net Radio faves (say, hypothetically, the stuff at http://www.somafm.org/)
    --
    You'd be surprised what's not on the map in this country. - Mulder
  9. Re:Like Satellite Radio by putko · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I thought satellite radio and its fees were egregious too. So I got my partner one. She really loves it; after a few days of that, she entirely stopped listening to normal radio.

    The key thing is, no commercials, and perfect audio quality (except when there are dropouts). That and more than a hundred channels (although most listen to only 5 or so).

    It makes it an entirely different thing from radio. If you are used to having the satellite version in the car, and for whatever reason you forget it, and use normal radio, you feel like a total idiot, and the normal radio, with its ads and bad reception, drives you nuts.

    So if you like radio, it is probably worth it. If you don't really like radio, just wait until the costs come down more.

    --
    http://www.thebricktestament.com/the_law/when_to_s tone_your_children/dt21_18a.html
  10. Music Choice? by realinvalidname · · Score: 2, Informative

    Isn't Music Choice the service that got dumped by DirecTV (just this week) in favor of XM?

    1. Re:Music Choice? by HardCase · · Score: 2, Funny

      ...I have a niggling suspicion that Comcast owns a major piece of Music Choice...

      Suspicion validated! From a Music Choice press release:

      Headquartered in Horsham, PA, Music Choice is a partnership among subsidiaries of Microsoft Corporation, Motorola, Inc., Sony Corporation of America, EMI Music and several leading U.S. cable providers: Adelphia Cable Communications, Comcast Cable Communications, Cox Communications and Time Warner Cable.

      Egads, the seven horsemen of the apocalypse plus the antichrist?

      -h-

  11. Re:Yay! by Mike+Buddha · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Typical teenager reaction. Yes, child, everyone is trying to tell you what to do, even when they aren't. You poor oppressed thing.

    --
    by Mike Buddha -- Someday the mountain might get him, but the law never will.