Slashdot Mirror
What is the Scope of Computer Forensics?
Jety asks: "I do general-purpose tech support for a variety of individuals and small businesses. Today, one of my clients presented me with an interesting situation, which made me recommend that he get his own attorneys and computer forensics experts on the job. Above and beyond that, to satisfy my own curiosity and to have some insight to offer him in the meantime - I have some question about the scope of what computer forensics can accomplish, for this I turn to the experts of Slashdot, which can be boiled down to one issue: What exactly can a good computer forensics guy pull off of a hard drive - particularly once it's gone on to be used for a full week after the incident in question?"
"The sanitized details of my client's situation:
- Person A (my client) and Person B are business partners. Person A leaves the business, and before doing so copies a series of files to 5 CDs using Roxio under Windows XP.
- The computer continues to be used under normal circumstances for about a week.
- Person B confronts Person A, and Person A hands over the CDs to Person B.
- Person B hires a computer forensics 'expert', who claims that Person A accessed something like 3000 files during the 1 hour time span in question, when Person A was burning files to CD.
- Person A primarily wants to prove that the data he turned over on CD was the only data he took, approximately 50 word/excel type files, which we will assume to be true.
How detailed a record of file use does NTFS or WinXP keep? Can you really show what files were accessed during a one-hour time span seven days ago? Above and beyond the 'last modified' date? On a read/write/execute basis? Accessed by the system or by a user? Do commercial burning programs keep a record of burn jobs they've performed? Does the CD drive itself have any appreciable nonvolatile cache? Is there any other general insight applicable to this situation?"
- Person A (my client) and Person B are business partners. Person A leaves the business, and before doing so copies a series of files to 5 CDs using Roxio under Windows XP.
- The computer continues to be used under normal circumstances for about a week.
- Person B confronts Person A, and Person A hands over the CDs to Person B.
- Person B hires a computer forensics 'expert', who claims that Person A accessed something like 3000 files during the 1 hour time span in question, when Person A was burning files to CD.
- Person A primarily wants to prove that the data he turned over on CD was the only data he took, approximately 50 word/excel type files, which we will assume to be true.
How detailed a record of file use does NTFS or WinXP keep? Can you really show what files were accessed during a one-hour time span seven days ago? Above and beyond the 'last modified' date? On a read/write/execute basis? Accessed by the system or by a user? Do commercial burning programs keep a record of burn jobs they've performed? Does the CD drive itself have any appreciable nonvolatile cache? Is there any other general insight applicable to this situation?"
Way back in the day (early/mid 1980s) I did a job like this.
Person A left company AA and started company BB then started taking customers. Attorney for AA got a court order allowing inspection of all magnetic media. Of course, by the time I was allowed access to the drive, several months had passed during which time "something had gone wrong with the computer" and "I think the repair shop had to format one of the drives". Yeah, right.
In any case, they thought that a basic reformat of a DOS hard-disk removed all the data. As I started pulling off and saving directory-fragments and disk sectors which showed that they had illegally installed specialized and unusual software belonging to the former employer as well as lists of names of clients they made fundamental mistake #2 - they started blabbing "explanations" for the data I was recovering. As a former law-enforcement employee I simply listened attentively to their stories...and included the additional incriminating evidence in my report.
Never even had to go to court and testify.
Things are more complicated, today. You are right to get a computer forensic expert involved. Many of the disk-recovery services like Drivesavers provide forensic services in addition to data-recovery.
~~~~~~~
"You are not remembered for doing what is expected of you." - Atul Chitnis