Slashdot Mirror


E-Paper On Cereal Boxes

coastin writes "Wired Mag has an article about electronics maker Siemens, readying a paper-thin electronic-display technology. They say it is so cheap it could replace conventional labels on disposable packaging. Imagine items on grocer's shelves that flash commercials at you as you walk by. From the article: 'When kids see flashing pictures on cereal boxes we don't expect them to just ask for the product, but to say, "I want it", said Axel Gerlt, an engineer at Siemens tasked with helping packaging companies implement the technology.'"

41 of 447 comments (clear)

  1. Can you think of a better way by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    to alienate parents?

  2. Epilepsy? by slavemowgli · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Flashing stuff on boxes all over the supermarket? That's got to be a nightmare for those suffering from epilepsy.

    --
    quidquid latine dictum sit altum videtur.
    1. Re:Epilepsy? by dr_dank · · Score: 4, Funny

      Flashing stuff on boxes all over the supermarket? That's got to be a nightmare for those suffering from epilepsy.

      In this age of data mining, persons afflicted with a seizure at the supermarket will quickly receive a coupon for a free shake from Baskin Robbins.

      --
      Where does the school board find them and why do they keep sending them to ME?
    2. Re:Epilepsy? by |/|/||| · · Score: 3, Interesting
      Absolutely. I can't stand animated web pages -- the last thing I want is animated packaging.

      There are potential benefits here, though. For one thing, if you can add some buttons to make the display interactive, you can fit a lot more information onto the label.

      --
      [javac] 100 errors
  3. How utterly depressing by Toby+The+Economist · · Score: 5, Insightful

    > From the article: 'When kids see flashing pictures on cereal boxes we don't
    > expect them to just ask for the product, but to say, "I want it", said Axel
    > Gerlt, an engineer at Siemens tasked with helping packaging companies implement
    > the technology.'

    Western culture appears to have lost its vision.

    New technology being thought of in terms of how much you can make a child coerce its parent into buying cereal?

    We're amusing ourselves to death.

    1. Re:How utterly depressing by tomhudson · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Its illegal in my jurisdiction to have advertising (magazines, etc.) directed to children under 13.

      This is over and above any broadcast requirements.

      This could be a good thing if it gets parents more used to saying "Mo!" to their kids. After all, a pissed-off parent is already hostile to your product.

      And I REALLY don't want to see the ads for Preparation H!

    2. Re:How utterly depressing by guitaristx · · Score: 4, Funny

      This could be a good thing if it gets parents more used to saying "Mo!" to their kids.

      Is that anything like saying "Ni!" to old women?

      --
      I pity the foo that isn't metasyntactic
    3. Re:How utterly depressing by LithiumX · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Vision?

      Haven't a great many of the popular advances in the 19th and 20th century been driven by marketing, and the desire to draw attention for purposes of profit? The earliest visions of the phograph's uses were more oriented towards automated marketing than towards the memoranda and music they were actually used for. Color printing was exclusively for the purpose of making product packaging more appealing, and television only became possible as a mass-market item when it was married to marketing (to this day, commercials are the life blood of the networks).

      Early radio broadcasts were practically commerials with a thin veil of entertainment laid over them. It took a little while for radio commercials to seperate from the actual content (when they started announcing the products during frequent breaks, rather than the programs constantly hawking a product within a poorly contrived story).

      Holograms were invented simply to see it done, but the bulk of the funding came from companies who sought to apply them as the new wonder-label (which turned out to remain prohibitively expensive for some time, and just never that appealing).

      Western technology has been driven by three primary needs:
      * direct threats - be it war, disease, famine, etc. Death avoidance.
      * misguided ambition - attempting to create something unrealistic, and ending up with something unexpected (and often unnoticed for some time)
      * commerce - the inherent desire to make people give you money

      Altruism is a noble thing, but it's greed that makes the world actually turn.

      --
      Do not confuse "Freedom of Choice" with "Free Will".
    4. Re:How utterly depressing by BobPaul · · Score: 3, Funny

      When kids see [snip] cereal boxes we don't expect them to just ask for the product, but to say, "I want it"

      They already do this. They're kids.

    5. Re:How utterly depressing by SquadBoy · · Score: 5, Insightful

      All three of mine soon learned that whining was the best way *not* to get something. This remains one of the things their mother and I agree on.

      Yes it takes *seriious* time and effort to do this but it is well worth it.

      --

      Cypherpunks: Civil Liberty Through Complex Mathematics. Those who live by the sword die by the arrow.
    6. Re:How utterly depressing by Seumas · · Score: 3, Insightful

      On the other hand. You, also, are full of shit.

      There's nothing I hate more than sanctimonious prick parents saying things like "well, you have no children so shut your mouth and keep your opinions to yourself!" or even more drug addicts who say shit like "You've never been addicted to meth, so you don't know - shut your mouth!".

      Look, I've never raised a kid (I've taken care of a number including my own siblings for great lengths of time over months or years, though) and it doesn't take a fucking rocket scientist to know certain truths . . . You know, like it's not hard to have a spine and raise your children without caving into their every want. Or... you know... you shouldn't beat your children or feed them ice cream every morning for breakfast.

      In fact, parents (like drug users) are often some of the stupidest people on earth. I don't mean this as a flame or troll - but honestly, squirting out a kid is something that doesn't require any intelligence or qualification or wisdom. In fact, a lot of people might suggest that it's the least intelligent and prepared and qualified people that squirt out kids the most frequently.

      Seriously - your comment is shit.

    7. Re:How utterly depressing by dhanes · · Score: 3, Interesting
      'zactly. Bravo.

      It only took two times of dropping to one knee in the middle of the grocery aisle, upending my son onto the other knee and a couple of quick whacks on his bottom to curtail whiny outbursts over whatever pretty shiny box with on it that he wanted. Not even hard whacks, it was the embarrassment and shame of having that done in front of strangers that did it. He's 4, and now is able to have a somewhat reasonable conversation about 'why' he can't have something. He might not like it, but he knows we have the final say.

      Now, all I have to do is give a little askance look at him and ask him if he needs to be spanked in front of everyone. He'll then try to reason his way into getting it, sometimes I give in, most of the time I win. The next time he see's that particular item in the store, he'll even reiterate the reasons I gave him for not wanting to buy whatever it was, couched in language like "I can't have that because it is full of those plastic oils and high fructose corn syrup? Right Daddy?" Unfortunately, 'high fructose' comes out usually as 'high fucktoes' ;)

      I love the stares from the other parents as they whip through the aisles trying to get out of there before their little one has another meltdown and they overhear these conversations.

      --
      Wait, What?
    8. Re:How utterly depressing by LithiumX · · Score: 4, Interesting

      If you want to bring in a number of auxilliary driving forces, you might as well enumerate the seven deadly sins. When you think about it, these provide almost all the core reasons why we have advanced as fast as we have, compared to other cultures throughout history.

      Many cultures have risen to heights, both technological and philosophical, some of which we ourselves can't yet lay claim to. But from a historical standpoint, Eurocentric societies have rapidly moved from being quite literally the armpit of the known world, to the absolute domination of the globe (both the US and modern Russia count as eurocentrically derrived, in the long run). Only China and the middle east can claim to have had a global impact worth comparing.

      Why? Simple. Europeans, back in the dark ages, identified, enumerated, and understood human nature. They knew their sins, which made them easier to pursue.

      Greed - the need to make money, and to find more ways of getting as much of it as possible.

      Sloth - just plain lazyness. We want our machines to do the work for us.

      Gluttony - the drive to produce more plentiful food, that tastes better, regardless of nutritional content or actual need.

      Wrath - newer and better ways to kill our fellow man

      Envy - one nation sees what another has, and wants it for themselves, so they have to figure it out for themselves.

      Pride - the need to produce something better than what's out there, to become famous for your creations, or for national pride.

      Lust - I'm not sure how to articulate why this actually drives western progress, but I'm certain it's the keystone to all our social evolution.

      --
      Do not confuse "Freedom of Choice" with "Free Will".
    9. Re:How utterly depressing by jafuser · · Score: 5, Funny

      Altruism is a noble thing, but it's greed that makes the world actually turn.

      Actually, it's conservation of angular momentum.

      --
      Please consider making an automatic monthly recurring donation to the EFF
  4. Re:The Wolf in Sheep's Clothing by middlemen · · Score: 4, Funny

    I envision the day when porn will be flashed on the cereal boxes and the kid's Dad goes "I want it!"

  5. Harry Potter by Deinhard · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Are we getting close to the moving photographs in the Harry Potter movies?

    Seeing Nick Nolte's mug shot scowling out at me from a post office wall would be most disconcerting.

    Then again, a moving poster of [insert favorite model here] would be most intriguing.

    --
    Successfully condensing fact from the vapor of nuance since 1998.
  6. Grocery store? by michaelmalak · · Score: 4, Interesting
    Forget the grocery store (especially these days with groceries ordered over the Interent). Why, with e-paper, I'd want my cereal box to be web enabled, because it would be a whole lot better than reading the cereal ingredients over and over again over breakfast.

    Boy, did the prognisticators really miss that one -- everyone kept talking about web-enabled microwaves. Little did they know the web-enabled cereal box would come first.

  7. Yeah, right by GigsVT · · Score: 5, Informative

    I work for a retail label printer.

    Average prices for labels run about $3-$10 per thousand. The most expensive labels on metallic stock with lots of spot colors might be $30 per thousand.

    That's still 3 cents per label for the most expensive ones. I doubt they could even sort out the power supply for these things that cheaply.

    --
    I've had enough abrasive sigs. Kittens are cute and fuzzy.
    1. Re:Yeah, right by orasio · · Score: 4, Funny

      I work for a retail label printer.

      I feel your pain, brother. I work for a retail color laser printer. Printers are the worst bosses. This one pays me cash, the bank once said something about yellow dots in my money, and refused to accept a deposit.

  8. Just what the environment needs by Rhys · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Something less recyclable than paper to package all our crap with. That's flashy and annoying. And uses (and landfills) batteries.

    On the bright side you'll always know if the product is fresh or not. Not fresh: no display. Of course then you won't know till you open it if you have Cheerios or Chex Mix.

    --
    Slashdot Patriotism: We Support our Dupes!
    1. Re:Just what the environment needs by r5t8i6y3 · · Score: 3, Informative

      and prior to recycling there is the impact of resource consumption.

      i wonder how many more resources go into the production of e-paper over tree/hemp/etc. paper? anyone feel like doing some back-of-the-envelope calculations?

      i feel very concerned when i notice so much focus on recycling and very little focus on consumption. if you are concerned about the earth/your home/"your back yard" ask yourself "how can i consume *less*?" because by consuming less we make the recycling problem smaller.

      if this site http://www.weeeman.org/ is at all accurate, we geeks are using quite a bit of our share of the earth's resources with each new computer we purchase. according to this site, if we divide the earth's resources evenly amongst the current population, our individual "earthshare" is equal to ~two football fields. purchasing *one* computer uses ~4.25% of your earthshare. if you purchase six computers you consume 25% of your earthshare. and this doesn't include _any_ of the other things you are consuming (car, house, other electronic devices, etc.).

      here's a couple more sites for more information about e-waste:

      Basel Action Network - BAN
      http://www.ban.org/

      Computer TakeBack Campaign
      http://www.computertakeback.com/

      btw, here's where you can get the most eco-friendly paper i know of: http://www.livingtreepaper.com/products.html

      peace

  9. It's much worse than that... by hackwrench · · Score: 5, Insightful

    New technology being though in terms of not how to inform consumers but how to bypass the most informed and target the least informed, depending on them to persuade the better informed. Note: the child frequently doesn't actually want the cereal itself in this particular situation, but just the pretty box.

    I can't tell you how many boxes of Frosted Flakes I ate for the primary goal of getting the Disney Afternoon figurine inside. There were also numerous times I thought I wanted something, but didn't actually know what it was.

    1. Re:It's much worse than that... by lrucker · · Score: 4, Interesting
      That's nothing new. When I was in high school I had a job for 1 day as an annoying mall survey person - not the one who accosts you in the mall, but the one who asks the questions once you've been captured.

      Had to ask a woman (mid 20's, high school drop out, and quite frankly couldn't even approach pretty without plastic surgery) if, after looking at an ad, she thought some shampoo that cost more than she made in an hour would make her "beautiful". Was totally shocked when she said yes, and decided I couldn't do a job where the point was to find people's misconceptions and exploit them.

  10. First things first by mean+pun · · Score: 4, Insightful
    Before we get all the useless and annoying applications of e-paper, could we please get something useful first: a comfortable e-book reader?

    Pretty please?

    Oh, and make it uncrippled. Yes, I'm looking at you, Sony.

    1. Re:First things first by Castar · · Score: 4, Informative

      Exciting developments on that front, actually!

      Two e-ink based readers are supposed to be released soon: The Hanlin V8/V2 and a device from iRex. The iRex reader is supposed to support Linux and be released in "early 2006" in Europe. The Hanlin V8 with a proprietary OS is supposed to be released "by the end of this year" in China for around $300, with the Linux-based V2 being released in May worldwide at about $320.

      My money is on iRex, since they're backed by Philips and have a larger screen, but they might be more expensive than the Hanlin device. We'll see!

      --
      I yearn for you tragically. A. T. Tappman, Chaplain, U.S. Army.
  11. I can see it now... by Dan+Morenus · · Score: 5, Funny

    A disgruntled cereal packaging company employee quits, and a few weeks later at 5:00pm some fine Sunday all the boxes on the supermarket shelf simultaneously and inexplicably start flashing goatse...

    --
    -- Conserve binary trees; recycle your email. --
  12. Curse or Blessing? by BeBoxer · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Part of me thinks e-paper is going to be really cool and will allow us to make some neat gadgets. But at the same time, I'm terrified of what the marketing folks are going to do with it. We are already at a point where advertising pervades our environment everywhere we go. When it all starts flashing and jumping and pointing and demanding our attention at all times I think I'm going to go totally insane. I really think I might just snap and actually go crazy. And I suspect I'm not alone.

  13. Re:The Wolf in Sheep's Clothing by AKAImBatman · · Score: 4, Interesting

    There still has to be a digital input to the ePaper. Like an LCD, it will always be possible to hack it to display something else.

    You mean, in the same way it's possible to "hack" the FPU out of a CPU into another unit? THINK about it. If they print all the circuitry as a single device, you'd have to have fab-quality tools to directly interface with the ePaper. That is NOT my idea of a "hackable" piece of ePaper. (Especially since it would be cheaper and easier just to purchase a generic ePaper display.) And that's assuming that they don't further cut corners with tricks like not adding eInk to areas that don't change in the animation.

  14. Medicine vials? by mypalmike · · Score: 4, Funny

    Miniature displays in color could appear on consumer-goods packaging, including medicine vials, in 2007, with a resolution of 80 dpi, Gerlt said.

    "You say the defendant, Local Pharmacy Inc., failed to warn your late husband about possible side effects of the drug?"

    "Yes, sir."

    "Show me the bottle. Let's see here. 'Not to be taken with alcohol. May cause dizziness, blindness, and death.' Clearly, if he had read the bottle, he would have known about the 'death' side-effect."

    "Sure, but the label didn't say 'death' until just an hour ago. It said 'headaches'."

    --
    There are 0x40000000 types of people: those who understand 32-bit IEEE 754 floating point, and those who don't.
  15. Grassroots Press Story ca. 2099 by Zordak · · Score: 3, Funny
    Grassroots Press
    For Immediate Release.

    A recent conference of historians meeting in the bombed-out shell of a Hyatt hotel held a panel discussion on the cause of the downfall of human civilization as it was once known. The group uanimously traced the downfall of civilization to the following statement from the early part of this century:

    Imagine items on grocer's shelves that flash commercials at you as you walk by.
    "What were they friggin' thiking!" exclaimed noted historian Dulcinea Bumkis. "I mean seriously -- wasn't there anybody who looked at this and thought, 'That's the most idiotic idea I've ever heard.'" Another historian noted that a little-known insurrectionist going by the handle "Zordak" on a popular message board advocated just such a position, but he was quickly drowned out by a chorus of six-year-olds chanting for Cocoa Puffs.
    --

    Today's Sesame Street was brought to you by the number e.
  16. Re:It's coming by Gabe+Garza · · Score: 5, Funny
    > Soon we'll have advertising on every inanimate surface.

    Why would we limit ourselves to inanimate surfaces? I envision a day when I go to a seafood restaurant and the oysters have a self-updating "I've been out of water DD HH.MI.SS" display attached to their shells; the lobsters have a "My claws currently weight WW ounces each, and I was harvested only HH hours ago" display on their carapaces; and the waiters have dazzling, dynamic pieces of flair attached to their uniforms that vibrantly inform me how much they love their job.

  17. And that is how western civilization crumbled... by The+Famous+Druid · · Score: 4, Funny

    ... in the Supermarket Riots of 2008.

    --
    Quidquid Latine dictum sit, altum videtur (anything said in Latin sounds important)
  18. Pathetic parents? by Nutria · · Score: 4, Insightful

    When kids see flashing pictures on cereal boxes we don't expect them to just ask for the product, but to say, "I want it"

    And I expect good parents to whack them upside the head until they say please.

    And then whack them upside the head until they politely shut up after the parent says "No".

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  19. If Google has taught us anything... by Trip+Ericson · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ...it's that in a world where all the advertisements are flashly, the plain one stands out.

  20. Adult? by Sv-Manowar · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I can see there being huge money in this for the first adult publication company to make moving porn magazines, or moving porn images on paper. The hype alone would eat up the initial cost in sales, and they could build up a huge brand on being the only one to offer it.

    The adult industry was the original driving force behind the internet progressing, so who knows what will happen next. If theres money in it, you can guarantee that the big adult companies will come knocking on the door after a while.

  21. ugh by slashdotnickname · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Imagine items on grocer's shelves that flash commercials at you as you walk by

    And imagine me walking to the nearest competitor that will not annoy me with real life pop-up adds.

  22. Phillip K Dick got it right by nycroft · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It seems that Phillip K. Dick's vision of a future where no one can escape annoying advertising is coming true. If we're not careful, Orwell's prediction of government controlled speech will come true. Oh wait...it already has.

    --
    Mr. Bond, they have a saying in Chicago: Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time is enemy action.
  23. I dont think so... by mustafap · · Score: 3, Insightful

    E-Paper or not, these displays will need power. From batteries. What an environmental nightmare.

    --
    Open Source Drum Kit, LPLC deve board - mjhdesigns.com
  24. interesting development.... by ChrisGilliard · · Score: 3, Interesting

    ink-printed images of today to a digital medium of flashing graphics and text that displays prices, special offers or alluring photos, all blinking on miniature flat screens.

    This means that as people check out, the cash register could swipe the RFID tag on the umbrella that was just sold and tell all the other umbrellas to raise their price on this e-paper by $1.00 because it might be raining.

    --
    No Sigs!
  25. Which is why there will always be two classes... by hackwrench · · Score: 3, Funny

    and why the proletariat will never be the ruling class or indeed revolt. The smart ones will move out of the proletariat, and it's the smart people that are disaffected in society that will rebel, both the rulers and the rebels using the proletariat as cannon fodder. It's a waste to prey on the misconceptions of the proletariat when there are more effective and economical ways to decrease their purchasing power and increase their utilizability.

  26. Re:Underrated by cagle_.25 · · Score: 3, Insightful
    I'm sorry; that's unbelievably simplistic. Or perhaps trollsome.

    We're talking about advertisers intentionally making it *more* difficult for parents to instill discipline in their children, and you're blaming the parents?!

    Reality check: being a parent of a two-year-old and a six-month-old means that you are devoting approximately 30% of your processor time already to making sure that the kids aren't (a) harming themselves, (b) harming others, (c) making a mess, (e) being properly fed and clothed, and (f) learning how to interact like reasonable human beings. That's the involved parents; the loser parents just ignore the kids until they scream.

    Walking down the grocery store aisle with one kid in the seat and one kid walking means that *if* you want to actually choose a product and place it in the cart, you will have to stop holding the two-year-old's hand and focus on the products.

    Your two-year-old, being smart like her daddy, might just decide that now is the optimal moment to go for something interesting, like flashing cereal boxes. Now what, Dr. Spock? I suppose you're going to "instill discipline" right there and she'll just straighten right up for you.

    News flash: unless you want to make every infraction a capital [1] offense, your kid will buck your will on a regular basis. The smart parent will decide which battles are worth fighting and which ones are worth reasoning through ... and reasoning through with them takes time.

    In short, getting a kid to the point where he or she has self-discipline requires ... um ... time and patience [2]. You have to have self-discipline yourself to pull it off, which means that you can't expect to press the magical "discipline" button and have them behave. Have fun raising your own kids.




    [1] Nothing short of the death penalty will guarantee compliance. My daughter responds pretty well to time-outs, but I spent part of my childhood proving that my dad couldn't spank me hard enough to make me obey him.

    [2] As in, I haven't had time for any hobby coding projects since my first daughter was born.

    --
    Human being (n.): A genetically human, genetically distinct, functioning organism.