Slashdot Mirror
Best Videogame Compilations
The Press the Buttons blog has a rundown on some of the finest game compliations currently on offer. From the post: "After more than two decades of cranking out hit titles, the game industry has come to love compilation cartridges and discs. Publishers can crank out collections for relatively nothing in terms of cost, and fans can pick up a slew of their old favorites in a single box for a low price. However, as compilations have matured over the years some companies have become lazy about the process."
Complilations always seemed to me to be a way for the marketing departments to flog some dead horses... Repackaging a bunch of old games to try and make them seem shiny and new...
Since the cost of these games to the game industry is very low, wouldn't it be nice if gamers can pick the games they want from one source (i.e. all available games are sold via a middleman), instead of buying a 101-collection with only 2 desired games?
If iTunes can do that for songs, can a similar company do that for games?
Virtual Betting on Facebook for non-geeks.
MAME and rom sites are the best video game compilations around.
TFA was nice. Old games can be hard to find. Compilations (or reissues) make it a lot easier. Even not-so-old games (2-6 years old) can be difficult to find at times.
s /index.html?q=rpg%20archives
0 01QEP9/103-7875370-8027035?v=glance
0 01QEP7/qid=1135045711/sr=8-1/ref=sr_8__i1_xgl63/10 3-7875370-8027035?v=glance&s=videogames&n=229534
m agic-archives
Speaking of compilations, I've got a few of my own. I'm an old-school RPG fan. My personal favorites are:
The Ultima Collection: http://www.gamespot.com/pc/rpg/ultimacollection/
(Ultima I-VIII)
The Ultimate RPG Archives: http://www.gamespot.com/pc/rpg/ultimaterpgarchive
The Ultimate Wizardry Archives: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00
(Wizardry I-VII)
Forgotten Realms Archives: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00
(Pool of Radiance, Curse of the Azure Bonds, Secret of the Silver Blades, Pools of Darkness, Gateway to the Savage Frontier, Treasures of the Savage Frontier, Hillsfar, Eye of the Beholder, Eye of the Beholder II, Eye of the Beholder III, Dungeon Hack, Menzoberranzan, Blood and Magic, and the Baldur's Gate interactive demo.)
The Ultimate Might & Magic Archives: http://www.mobygames.com/game/ultimate-might-and-
(Might & Magic I-V)
Nothing beats old-school gameplay. These collections aren't for you if you're looking for eye-candy though. The games are at least 10 years old, maybe more.
Excellent list. I had to chuckle a bit reading it, as I have every one of those compilations you list. I agree they're well worth tracking down.
0 8GMVWG/104-0940037-0294322?v=glance
0 AYFPKG/qid=1135049473/sr=8-1/ref=pd_bbs_unbuck_1/1 04-0940037-0294322?v=glance&s=videogames&n=229534
I personally would also add
The Zork Legacy Collection (I know, text adventure and not RPG, but still worthwhile): http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00
(Zork 1 - 5, Zork Nemesis, Return to Zork)
The King's Quest Collection:
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00
(King's Quest 1 - 7)
Dreamers, shapers, singers, makers... Elric, the Techno-Mage
Yes but do you still get the Horming Missile in Megaman ?
The best one is Capcom Classics Collection not mentioned in the article. Those Street Fighter games still rock. Commando and Ghosts and Goblins still rock. I buy all these compilations. They don't make simple games for consoles like in the old days.
Some compilations are better than others. Midway totally needs to do a better job as they were clearly designed for an X-box controller and there is no way to change the controls. Taito's collection was just sad.
I don't want to sit in front of a PC when I get home after staring at a PC all day. The PS2 controller is better on my thumbs then my Nintendo when playing Mega Man all day. Messing with a emulator and shifty websites to download the ROMS isn't worth the $10 for a disc that just plays. A clear conscience is just bonus.
EA's Laptop Collection is pretty damn awesome: SMAC, SMACX, Red Alert 2, and Sim City 3000.
I'd buy it in a trice, if I could find anywhere in New Zealand that sells it...
(Amazon won't ship it overseas)
Repton.
They say that only an experienced wizard can do the tengu shuffle.
I collect games, so console and computer compilations tend not to interest me - I'd much rather have the original version (or, in the case of arcade games, a port from the timeframe of the original game) than a re-release.
My favourite compilations tend to be portable versions. I like being able to take several different games along with me without having to carry multiple cartridges.
By far, the best portable compilation I've ever seen is Konami Collector's Series: Arcade Advanced for GBA. It contains six arcade games that aren't emulated, but reprogrammed specifically for GBA. You'd be hard-pressed to find the difference. Also, each game is of a different genre (unlike compilations such as Pac-Man Museum). And finally, you can use the 'Konami Code' to unlock hidden features and updated graphics in each game.
Another fine compilation for GBA is Atari Anniversary Advance. It contains, like the Konami one, six arcade games. Unlike the Konami compilation, the games are emulated. There are some problems like slowdown and sound issues, but it really feels like you're playing MAME on the go. Another issue is that nearly all of the games used nonstandard controls (like a spinner for Tempest, trackball for Missile Command, dual sticks for Battlezone, etc) so that the GBA controls don't quite match the arcade ones. Still, it is an excellent compilation with several true classics.
Bridging the gap between handhelds and consoles, the recent trend of dedicated direct-to-tv devices is interesting, and has resulted in several that definitely count as compilations.
In particular, the Commodore 64 DTV stands above all others. It has 30 C64 games ranging from merely tolerable filler to true classics. But what makes it absolutely incredible is the dedication and love poured into it. It has lots of hidden secrets, and can be hacked to add real C64 hardware like disk drives so that you can play (or code) original games on it!
The Atari Flashback 2.0 is also great for similar reasons. It has a larger and better library than the C64 DTV, but also less hacking potential. You can add a cartridge port from an original Atari 2600, allowing it to play real 2600 games, but it has no major secrets and the homebrew possibilities are limited by the cartridge medium of the original system. It is as much a labour of love as the C64 stick, though, as is made obvious by the newly manufactured 2600 joysticks that have the proper connectors, allowing them to be used on the original system!
The Namco II 5-in-1 joystick is also worth a look. It has less games and no additional potential, but the games themselves are great. The joystick feels a little loose, making the controls a tad difficult on some of the games. This is (almost) made up for by an innovation that results in the best home version of Pole Position ever: the knob on the joystick twists and acts as a steering wheel, which gives the game absolutely FLAWLESS control. This is a must-buy if you love Pole Position, and well worth looking into if you like any of the other games on the stick.
Despite what I said at the beginning, there are some compilations available for PC and consoles that are worth investigating.
On PC, the Ultima Collection
Sure they put in some excellent Zelda games from the NES and from the N64 but would it have killed them to put Link to the Past on the disc? It's a game that most SNES emulators I've played have trouble with. I'd love to have a version that I know works and that doesn't require me to trot out the SNES to play it.
I wish they'd rerelease some of the old Dos games like Stonekeep, Crusader 1&2, Acendancy, ect. I do have a 486 box that I still use for games like that, but it's becoming increasingly difficult to find old hardware at a reasonable price. I've also looked into dosbox, but it's never quite the same.
Mega Man at number 2? Honestly, I can't understand that. I was not a fan of them (and after awhile, the "Man" names ... they were really reaching) ...
... shouldn't be RANKED number two.
I mean, Mega Man is number 2, just
MoM++ - A Classic Expanded - [Master of Magic 1.5]
http://mompp.sourceforge.net/
Then again, maybe the author of the article got the GameCube or XBox version, and saving isn't so much of a headache in either one of those. Also, don't know about the other consoles, but the PS2 version should only be around $20... that's how much I paid for mine.
I do agree with the #1 pick, though-- even after all this time, Super Mario All-Stars is still a wonderfully put-together compilation.
This almost seems more like a list of classic classic compilations: outside of Sonic Mega Collection, these compilations are ten years old or better. Some of the compilations coming out today are just as good if not better than many on the list -- I'd say that Mega Man Anniversary Collection is better than Mega Man: Wily Wars by way of including all eight of the entries in the Mega Man series proper, as well as the two arcade games, as opposed to just the original trilogy.
I can get behind Mario All-Stars as Number One, though. The later edition of the game included Super Mario World, making the game an unbelievable value for Mario side-scrolling goodness. The individual games are apparently good enough to stand on their own as $30 rereleases for the Game Boy Advance, so getting five for the then-price of $50 was one heck of a steal, especially considering the games got a fresh coat of paint in the sound and graphics department (not to mention the ability to save, something SMB3 always needed).
The Phantasy Star series remake is supposed to be the best RPG collection in the making, if only they ever finish it. PS1, 2, 4 all graphically enhanced.
http://ages.sega.jp/ps2/home.html
I bought a GBA recently specifically so that I can play all the arcade game compilations from way back when. Love that stuff!
Most recently I got one that had Time Pilot and Yie Ar Kung Fu on it, used, for 7 bucks.
Good way to waste time at airports.
Since I can't tell them apart, I treat all ACs as the same person.
I seem to remember that back in the 90s LucasArts would put out a collection of 5 or 6 games and sell them for a reduced price. There were their Star Wars bundles (which would include games like "Dark Forces," "X-Wing," "Tie Fighter," and "Rebel Assault"), and there was also at least one Adventure Bundle, with "Day of the Tentacle," "Sam and Max Hit the Road," and the Monkey Island games. I think it'd be pretty neat for LucasArts to rerelease some of those bundles - I'd definitely be interested in playing some of those again.