Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Australian IT Workers Concerned About Migrants

Posted by ScuttleMonkey on from the same-story-the-world-over dept.

sien writes "In Australia it is being asserted that Australia's intake of migrants skilled in IT is taking jobs and lowering wages for Australian citizens. It appears that in all developed countries, not just the US, the case that immigrants are lowering wages for IT workers is being made. Would programmers in the developed world be better off without immigration that favors IT or is there an overall benefit for the industry with skilled workers going to the developed world and thus making the industry larger?"

4 of 406 comments (clear)

  1. boom bust cycle by bobby1234 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Once again the boom bust cycle continues...

    1. high demand results in increasing supply (more uni graduates and immigration)

    2. demand deminishes resulting in supply being met

    3. demand bottoms out => oversupply

    4. low demand => less uni graduates and less immigration

    5. demand begins to increase

    6. goto 1

  2. Age old rhetorical question by redblue · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Why is a global free market for goods considered good, but that for labor bad by so many inhabitants of "developed" nations?

  3. Re:A perfect world by MikeFM · · Score: 5, Insightful

    As an American (white male - lower middle class) I just want people to realize that immigrants aren't the real problem - foreign workers are the main problem. The best solution is to make it easier for those foreign workers to migrate here and get decent jobs here. We have minimum wage laws and free competition that other countries don't have. A large number of foreigners working for $2/hr would move here where they can make $20/hr. I'd sure as hell rather compete locally where all workers are under similar laws and living expenses than with someone that lives in a dirt hut and gets dirt pay. There would be a dip in wages as competition grew but it'd be much less drastic than the dip from jobs moving out of the country. What do we really think is going to be left as a source of income for us as companies keep migrating jobs? Blue collar jobs have been leaving us for years, white collar jobs have been following - what is going to be left?

    Make it easier for those workers to move into our western countries and encourage buying products produced within our own countries. That's how to keep wages high. Not by slowing migration. We want to force foreign countries to raise their minimum wage, improve their working and living conditions, etc and compete on a level ground with us. Pretty simple.

    --
    At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
  4. No, I'm not. by Kris_J · · Score: 5, Insightful
    As an Australian IT worker, not only am I not concerned about migrants taking my job, I actually work in an educational institution that trains international students. Migrants are not "taking Australian Jobs", that's just a tired old stereotype hauled out whenever some, usually, right-wing nutjob wants to rally support for whatever cause he or she is abusing at that moment.

    This is a small planet people, and everyone is just trying to get through life as best as they can.