Slashdot Mirror


Desktop Cold Fusion Reconsidered

Armchair Anarchist writes "Nature.com reports on Rusi Taleyarkhan of Purdue University in West Lafayette, Indiana, who is once again claiming to have achieved ultrasound-induced fusion in deuterium-enriched acetone. Other experts are sceptical, but Taleyarkhan is keen to have other scientists check his results."

3 of 241 comments (clear)

  1. Before you jump to conclusions... by freedom_india · · Score: 5, Informative
    Before you jump to conclusions like the Robot Lawyers episode, here's a scrap from the article:

    "Although the neutron count doubles at some points in the experiments, Putterman says that neutrons produced in random showers of cosmic rays, rather than fusion events, could be responsible. But Taleyarkhan points out that the neutron count was smaller in detectors further from the reaction chamber.
    To prove that the neutrons are coming from fusion as bubbles burst, Putterman and Suslick suggest that the team closely monitor exactly when the neutrons appear. The current experiment simply counts up the number of neutrons detected over minutes, so correlations with bubble bursts cannot be seen."

    They are NOT yet sure whether the neutrons come from bubbles or from cosmic rays.

    So let's not start the usual jokes about using car stereos to power cars, sound waves harming swan ears, etc.

    --
    "Doing what i can, with what i have." ~ Burt Gummer
  2. Re:Cold Fusion by Rei · · Score: 5, Informative

    Unjustly dismissive. First off, even initially, Taleyarkhan rallied about as much support as he did opposition. Now, even much of his initial opposition considers his work valid. Sonofusion seems to be quite a real phenominon (albeit, currently six orders of magnitude from breakeven).

    Here's a very interesting paper by him in Oct. 2005, in which they discuss many of the recent developments, including the potential for nonlinear scaling of efficiency and even the possibility of criticality. It's a very interesting read.

    --
    The *special* hell.
  3. Re:One thing screams "HOAX!" by pubidiot · · Score: 5, Informative
    From their Oct 2005 paper ...
    It is significant that 2.45 MeV D/D fusion neutrons were measured only when chilled, well-degassed, cavitated D-acetone was used. That is, no neutrons were measured when room temperature D-acetone, or as expected, normal acetone, was used.
    So the obvious and cheap control was done after all.