New Possible SIDS Genes Identified

ScienceDaily is reporting that researchers at the Mayo Clinic have identified two more cardiac genes that could contribute to sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). From the article: "In the two recent separate studies, researchers examined caveolin-3 (CAV3) and the cardiac ryanodine receptor (RyR2) and found molecular and functional evidence in both to implicate them as SIDS-susceptibility genes. Researchers examined the tissue of 135 unrelated cases of SIDS -- in infants with an average age of 3 months old -- that had been referred to Mayo Clinic's Sudden Death Genomics Laboratory for molecular autopsy. In each study, two of the 135 cases possessed mutations in either CAV3 or RyR2."

Comments

Re:Color me skeptical, but...

[Idarubicin]

Something that occurs in less than 2% of studied cases is a "potential contributing cause"?

Yep. It's not that unusual, actually. Physicians and epidemiologists start out with a number of dead people. They look for commonalities: symptoms, age at onset, unusual blood chemistry, etc. If they don't know what the root cause of an ailment is but they see similar patterns across a number of deaths, they coin a name for it. Here, it's Sudden Infant Death Syndrome--SIDS.

The name tells you what happens but doesn't explain why. Saying "I have a runny nose and I've been sneezing a lot" would let me put you in the Sudden Adult Sniffling Syndrome (SASS) group, but it doesn't actually tell me what caused your ailment. It turns out that SASS actually has a number of different causes that ultimately lead to the same outcome. You may be having an allergic reaction to pollen. You might have a rhinovirus infection. Maybe you have a brain tumour. For this particular symptom, we have a lot of ways of evaluating the course of the disease and the status of the patient.

With SIDS it is much more difficult. There may be many factors that make an individual susceptible, some genetic, some environmental, some a combination, some requiring a lot of bad luck.

A comparison might be drawn with ALS (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, known in the U.S. as Lou Gehrig's disease). In ALS, the motor neurons die off slowly, over the course of months or years. It starts in the periphery of the body and works its way up to the brain. Under the 'umbrella' of ALS, about 10% of cases are classified as 'familial'--that is, a patient is related to other individuals with the disease. Within this category, about 20% of cases are linked to one of several mutations in the gene SOD1 (superoxide dismutase). (One would expect most of the other familial cases to be related to other genes or gene combinations.) So while only about 2% of ALS cases are linked to SOD1 mutations, it is without a doubt a "contributing cause".