EXT4 Is Coming

ah admin writes "A series of patches has been proposed in Linux kernel mailing list earlier by a team of engineers from Red Hat, ClusterFS, IBM and Bull to extend the Ext3 filesystem to add support for very large filesystems. After a long-winded discussion, the developers came forward with a plan to roll these changes into a new version — Ext4."

Comments

Yes but

[Anonymous Coward]

Yes, but will it be enough if you had energy to boil all the oceans?

Interesting bit from wiki/ZFS:

ZFS is a 128-bit file system, which means it can provide 16 billion billion times the capacity of current 64-bit systems. The limitations of ZFS are designed to be so large that they will never be encountered in any practical operation. When contemplating the capacity of this system, Bonwick stated "Populating 128-bit file systems would exceed the quantum limits of earth-based storage. You couldn't fill a 128-bit storage pool without boiling the oceans."

In reply to a question about filling up the ZFS without boiling the ocean, Jeff Bonwick, an engineer at Sun Microsystems who led the team in developing ZFS for Solaris, offered this answer:

"Although we'd all like Moore's Law to continue forever, quantum mechanics imposes some fundamental limits on the computation rate and information capacity of any physical device. In particular, it has been shown that 1 kilogram of matter confined to 1 liter of space can perform at most 1051 operations per second on at most 1031 bits of information [see Seth Lloyd, "Ultimate physical limits to computation." Nature 406, 1047-1054 (2000)]. A fully-populated 128-bit storage pool would contain 2128 blocks (nibbles) = 2137 bytes = 2140 bits; therefore the minimum mass required to hold the bits would be (2140 bits) / (1031 bits/kg) = 136 billion kg.

To operate at the 1031 bits/kg limit, however, the entire mass of the computer must be in the form of pure energy. By E=mc2, the rest energy of 136 billion kg is 1.2x1028 J. The mass of the oceans is about 1.4x1021 kg. It takes about 4,000 J to raise the temperature of 1 kg of water by 1 degree Celsius, and thus about 400,000 J to heat 1 kg of water from freezing to boiling. The latent heat of vaporization adds another 2 million J/kg. Thus the energy required to boil the oceans is about 2.4x106 J/kg * 1.4x1021 kg = 3.4x1027 J. Thus, fully populating a 128-bit storage pool would, literally, require more energy than boiling the oceans."

Why EXT4 ?

[Anonymous Coward]

Ext4 is an extention of ext3, much like ext3 is an extention of ext2. The plan is to ensure backwards compatability and sanity for when things break, and with filesystems.. things break.

There are many factors that influence filesystems, not just "how fast it can write", but rather.. how it breaks when it does.

While the fanboys of XFS, JFS, ZFS may promise that their filesystems are faster, had no problems, secure and will not eat your data, it simply is not as proven as ext2 and ext3.

Scream fanboys scream, someone will listen, but the problem is that these filesystems are not proven in the field, or in some circumstances even in the kernel itself.

Re:Why only 48 bits?

[r00t]

With a block size of 32 kB (64 kB is expected to be supported soonish) the 48-bit numbers will take you 1 byte over the maximum file size that apps can support. There is no UNIX-like OS that lets an app handle files bigger than 2**63.

We'll need to adjust other things if filesystems ever get so huge. The whole design probably needs a rethink, but we can't do it now. We don't know what the future holds in terms of seek times, transfer rates, sector sizes, etc.

Re:Sounds like a good idea.

[CRCulver]

This'll fill the gap between now and when Reiser4 is declared stable

Reiser4 will never be declared stable in the Linux kernel because Hans Reiser refuses to make his code conformant to kernel coding standards. There has been long and wearying discussion of this on the LKML.