Slashdot Mirror
New Rocket Engine Successfully Tested
inetsee writes "XCOR Aerospace announced that their new methane-oxygen rocket engine has been tested successfully. This is reported to be the first successful test of an engine using the combination of methane and oxygen as fuel. The fuel has higher specific impulse than kerosene and oxygen, but until now has been thought to have too much 'technology risk'."
There hasn't been much use, because rocket design has been on a different track than XCOR. Kerosine engines are primarily used for their high thrust to weight ratios, which help get a rocket off the ground. Once the rocket is in flight, the first stage is usually dropped in favor of a more powerful engine, such as Liquid Hydrogen/Oxygen engines. LHOx has the highest specific impulse of any fuel deployed to date; even more efficient than the methane-oxygen engines they're proposing.
The problem is that XCOR is working on a different track than NASA and the large rocket manufacturers. They're focusing on winged takeoff and landing, where high thrust to weight ratios aren't as important, and can be sacrificed for greater efficiency. (For comparison, the kerosine F-1 engines on the Saturn V produced 1.5 million lbf compared to the 7,500 lbf targetted by this engine.) So the methane-oxy engine development has less to do with politics, and more to do with the practical matters of meeting the targetted design goals.
Javascript + Nintendo DSi = DSiCade
Different kind of risk.
The risk being talked about here is program risk... ie... the risk that using unproven technology will result in cost and schedule impacts to the project due to unforeseen problems. Not the risk of things going boom (although that can impact cost and schedule too... XD) Using proven, well-understood technologies reduces risk.
Think of it this way... if you're given a task to develop a program for $C dollars inside of Y months, are you going to use a well-established programming language or are you going to go with some new half-developed (but really nifty) one where you're playing debug the compiler as you work on your project?