Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

RIAA Wins In Court Against UW Madison

Posted by Zonk on from the when-you've-said-wisconsin-you've-said-it-all dept.

Billosaur writes "A judge has ordered the University of Wisconsin-Madison to turn over the names and contact information for the 53 UW-M students accused of file sharing over the university's networks by the RIAA. 'U.S. District Judge John Shabaz signed an order requiring UW-Madison to relinquish the names, addresses, telephone numbers, e-mail addresses and Media Access Control addresses for each of the 53 individuals.' The ruling came as no surprise to the university, which had previously rejected the request of the RIAA to hand out their settlement letters to alleged copyright violators on their campus. The school feels the RIAA will have a hard time tracking down who did the file-sharing anyway, as the IP addresses the RIAA has for the violations may be mapped to computers in common areas, making it difficult to determine just which people may have made the downloads."

5 of 200 comments (clear)

  1. No "win" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    They didn't "win in court". They filed suit, which UW Madison said they'd have to do before they'd give up the records.

  2. Misleading Headline. Not "Win".Not against UW. by NewYorkCountryLawyer · · Score: 5, Informative
    It's a misleading headline.

    It was an ex parte proceeding. It was not a "win". There was no one else in court. No one to oppose it.

    It was not against University of Wisconsin. It's against the "John Does".

    --
    Ray Beckerman +5 Insightful
    1. Re:Misleading Headline. Not "Win".Not against UW. by NewYorkCountryLawyer · · Score: 4, Informative

      They were probably not served with the papers. Therefore they would have had no opportunity to oppose it.

      --
      Ray Beckerman +5 Insightful
  3. Yes and no by geek · · Score: 4, Informative

    It's directed more at Universities and parents. They know full well kids wont take the moral high ground and stop pirating. They are aiming these suits at the kids to show parents who the boss is. I know several parents who've taken action against there kids for fear of the RIAA knocking on their doors. My father, when this all began, even took time out to come talk to me about whether or not I was pirating songs on his cable modem (I was 25 at the time and staying with them while in college still).

    Lawsuits are rarely profitable on a corporate scale. They are more or less used to scare a certain segment of the population, in this case, parents and gaurdians. This in turn puts pressure on the actual offenders. They aren't looking for compensation for the theft which is what lawsuits were supposed to be for to begin with. Instead it's being used as a message which, to me, is an abuse of the system and the judges and lawyers involved should be taking action to stop it as it significantly reduces the credibility of their own system.

  4. Re:Moral of the story by WiSparky · · Score: 5, Informative

    Unfortunately, you need to provide your MAC to the university to register for the network connection in the first place. So they already have it.
    Actually, that's only partly true. UW networks that the average Badger (i.e. likely not to know how or why to spoof their MAC) would plug into are in one of three flavors.

    ResNet (wired in rooms in older dorms and wireless in common dining areas and new residence halls). ResNet requires every computer connected to it be registered with a campus NetId (http://www.housing.wisc.edu/resnet/netreg.php). Those registrations are attached to MAC addresses so that a device may move around ResNet without having to register to every new jack it encounters. Also, so that a quarantined machine stays in the quarantine subnet until it's cleaned. These registrations expire every 120 days, and IP leases roll faster than that, but the address doesn't change very often as you tend to get the same IP on a renew.

    DoIT (Division of Information Technology) Wireless, called UWNet, http://www.doit.wisc.edu/network/wireless/ is the main campus wireless and is in classroom buildings, the unions and libraries. A NetId is also required to authenticate each time one connects. These IP addresses probably move around faster. I'm sure DoIT complies with whatever policy is in place for keeping these records, but who knows how long that is.

    Wired library computers. These are the working girls of the campus network. One needs a student ID number to access them, but finding a lost card or snooping for a number is not hard. Nor is guessing the 1 digit activation code that needs to be added on the end to authenticate. Again, who knows how long these records are kept.

    Also, students in the res halls tend to use a certain jukebox program (comes with a popular music player) that advertises its shared library only within that hall's subnet - so no one external to that subnet is able to see that traffic.

    Long way around to saying these John and Jane Does are going to be a bit hard to pin down. Should be fun to watch.