Fill Out CAPTCHAs, Digitize Books At The Same Time

alphadogg wrote with a link to a Networld article about a noble endeavor: putting CAPTCHAs to work for the good of humanity. A scientist at Carnegie Mellon is looking to create a new type of security check that will assist in a project meant to digitize and make searchable text from books and printed materials. Above and beyond that, the offering would probably be more secure than most current systems. "Instead of requiring visitors to retype random numbers and letters, they would retype text that otherwise is difficult for the optical character recognition systems to decipher when being used to digitize books and other printed materials. The translated text would then go toward the digitization of the printed material on behalf of the Internet Archive project."

Comments

Verification?

[traindirector]

CAPTCHAs work because the computers sending them already know what the text says; they start with it in text form and change it into a hard-to-read image. In the system discussed in the article, how will the computer verify that the user response actually matches the text? Sure, it could compare the response to its best guess, but if a program trying to guess the text was equally as sophisicated as the guessing computer, the guess would match.

I imagine the computer sending the picture of the image of hard-to-read text will further obfuscate the image in a way that makes it even more difficult for the computer on the receiving end to decipher, but the article doesn't acknowledge that this is one of the first logical questions in conceiving of / implementing this system in a functional way. The article really should cover this...