Slashdot Mirror
Flawed Survey Suggests XP More Secure Than Vista
SkeeLo writes "One of Vista's big selling points is security, but a report from CRN concludes that Vista offers little in the way of security advancements over Windows XP. Ars Technica analyzed the report and found some methodological problems. 'The report faults Vista for "providing no improvement in virus protection vs. XP," but of course Windows Vista does not ship with antivirus software — something the reviewer fails to mention. Faulting an AV-less Vista for not stopping viruses is a bit like faulting a door without a lock for opening when the handle is twisted.' That's not all: 'It was also disappointing to see CRN completely ignore the issue of buffer overflows, which has been addressed well in Vista by most accounts. This was a major weak spot with XP, and so far, Vista looks strong in this area, strong enough that Vista may never get its own "SQL Slammer." Why CRN didn't address this is a mystery, as it is no minor matter.'"
My comment was based on my experience earlier this week on Monday, only the second time I've been close enough to be able to identify a Vista install, and the very first time I'd used it. It had just been installed (as well as Office 2007) by one of my colleagues on a brand new HP laptop. No, didn't get asked to Allow or Cancel anything, but what I did experience didn't surprise me in the least.
From the instant I hit Ctrl-Alt-Delete (and this is after waiting for the machine to finish choking itself) it was the same familiar Windows experience - watching the HDD LED as if it's going to give some sort of indication as to when it might be safe to go on to the next step as the machine crawls through the login procedure - totally unresponsive for the majority of the time.
People bag Windows about insecurity, DRM and UAC all the time - they're not the things I have problems with. I play the game, keep machines patched, AV installed if the shareholders demand it, and so on. My only real gripe with Windows it simply that I habitually find small sub-tasks to do like clip my fingernails or organise desk-drawers while waiting for countless delays my Windows box gives me. Screwed if I'm going to spend a month of my life waiting for start menus to render.
Where with a different OS, I'd start the kettle boiling and check my email while that's going on, in Windows I launch outlook and then go and see to the kettle, because I know which will make me wait longer.