Slashdot Mirror


Justice Dept. Defends Microsoft Against Google

Frosty Piss writes "The Seattle PI reports that Google has complained to US antitrust officials about the hard-drive searching tool built into Windows Vista, saying that it stymies Google's similar search program. The complaint, lodged late last year, was revealed Saturday by The New York Times in a story about the Bush administration's handling of Microsoft antitrust issues. The real story, though, is not the Google complaint itself, but how the Justice Department is failing to enforce the Microsoft anti-trust decree. According to the story, Thomas Barnett, the assistant U.S. attorney general in charge of antitrust issues, sent a memo last month to state attorneys general across the nation, seeking to persuade them to reject Google's complaint."

10 of 329 comments (clear)

  1. Re:google is EVIL! by Phil246 · · Score: 5, Informative

    rtfa.
    Google is asking that microsoft provide a way for the user to disable it, so that other competing desktop search programs dont battle each other for system resources and ultimately both slow the computer down.
    They arent asking for it to be removed outright

  2. Re:google is EVIL! by Deviate_X · · Score: 5, Informative

    This is not true. You can disable built in indexing by unchecking indexing of the indexing locations (i.e. Outlook or the Hardrives) or by disabling the indexer in windows services list.

  3. Re:Thomas O. Barnett by Doc+Ruby · · Score: 5, Informative

    Why does it seem "strange" that Bush would appoint a Microsoft lawyer to the Justice Department that was supposed to stop Microsoft from abusing its monopoly, after the Clinton Justice Department got the court to declare Microsoft an abusive monopoly that had to be stopped? "Unjust", maybe, but how strange is it for a Justice Department that's got its chief, Attorney General Gonzales, lying to Congress every day to coverup Bush's political purges and cronyism? Not to mention all the Patriot Act travesties Bush's DoJ has committed. Haven't you heard what a zoo they're running over there?

    What you might not have heard is that Jack Abramoff, the crooked lobbyist who helped build Bush's crooked Republican Congress, got his start lobbying out of Bill Gates' father's law firm, Preston Gates. It would seem strange if Microsoft weren't getting the benefit of the crooked system it's helped train and build.

    --

    --
    make install -not war

  4. Re:google is EVIL! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative
    from TFA :

    Google has asked the court overseeing the antitrust decree to order Microsoft to redesign Vista to enable users to turn off its built-in desktop search program so that competing programs could function better, officials said. from the other article:

    There is no simple way for PC users to turn off Windows Vista's built-in desktop search program. Google has asked the court overseeing Microsoft's antitrust compliance to require the company to let users turn off the built-in search program, the New York Times reported. Granted there are *ways* to do it but they arent necessarily simple for clueless users
  5. Re:google is EVIL! by NSIM · · Score: 3, Informative

    Google is asking that microsoft provide a way for the user to disable it, so that other competing desktop search programs dont battle each other for system resources and ultimately both slow the computer down. They arent asking for it to be removed outright
    If that's all Google wants, then they could have saved themselves a lot legal fees. Windows Search is a service, it can be stop, started, disabled altogether from the Services management applet, or the command line, and there would be no problem in stopping it as part of an install for Google Desktop Search.
  6. Re:google is EVIL! by Deviate_X · · Score: 4, Informative

    There is already an API to the Service Control Manager API for google or anyone else to use.

  7. Re:Grep against Google by figleaf · · Score: 4, Informative

    1. The indexer only runs when no other applications are using system resources.

    2. Its a Windows Service you can easily turn it off.

    Why is slashdot full of trolls today?

  8. Re:Even If google is evil! by figleaf · · Score: 4, Informative

    You can easily turn it off. There are multiple ways to turn it off. Its Windows Service you can turn it off the control panel or the search options.
    If you like like the command-prompt then type 'net stop "Windows Search"

  9. Re:google is EVIL! by Punchinello · · Score: 3, Informative

    I cannot see how leaving Windows Indexing Service enabled hinders performance. It automatically goes idle when you are using your PC.

    --

    Remember... ZG9uJ3QgZm9yZ2V0IHRvIGRyaW5rIHlvdXIgb3ZhbHRpbmU=

  10. Re:google is EVIL! by Keeper · · Score: 3, Informative

    No, they are demanding that Microsoft lets people disable it.

    Then what are they complaining about? It can easily be disabled.

    Not only can the service be turned off, and not only can you specify which locations should/shouldn't be indexed, but there is a public api available that any 3rd party piece of software can use to turn it off or configure it.