Slashdot Mirror
Universal Refuses To Renew On iTunes
UnknowingFool writes "It appears for the moment that Universal will not renew its long term contract with Apple for content on the iTunes store. While the details are not known about the exact nature of the dispute, many speculate that it has to do with Apple's stance on fixed pricing and Apple's refusal to license their DRM. The worse case scenario may include Universal pulling its entire catalog from iTunes. Both sides stand to lose out with 1/3 of of new releases coming from Universal and an estimated 15% of Universal's sales coming from digital downloads. Apple's market share is about 75% of digital downloads, and digital downloads are growing while CD sales are shrinking."
iTunes isn't the one pushing DRM, its the record labels like Universal who insist on it. Apple knows its customers don't like DRM and they'd sell more without it, but the copyright holders are the ones worried about losing revenue in the long term without DRM. You've got it completely confused.
Right. And what exactly do they not like about their deal with Apple?
They want to charge you more for their music. They'd like you to purchase multiple tracks for each device you own, and they'd really like it if you couldn't burn those tracks to CD.
Your post makes no sense because Apple has no say in the dealings that Universal does with other on-line retailers. Yes, competition is great. Theoretically, if Universal was uncomfortable with iTunes' dominance in the marketplace they would make sweetheart deals with other on-line retailers to provide cheaper music with more freedom to drive people away from iTunes, and the consumer would win. But that is not what is happening, because they're just too greedy, and the other tech companies too easily roll over to the whims of the entertainment industry. iTunes is successful in part because they're the only ones who have stood up to the record companies.
Instead, Universal uses its dominant position to strong-arm more money out of companies like Apple and Microsoft -- you'll recall that Universal stayed out of the Zune music store until Microsoft agreed to give then a cut of the Zune hardware sales. That's all that this is about.
ENDUT! HOCH HECH!
It's not "Apple's" AAC tech, AAC is an open MPEG-standard, and anyone can implement it. A lot of Phones can play the files, and the only reason your $30 MP3 player can't is because the manufacturer decided not to pay for the license to decode AAC (which is significantly cheaper, simpler and safer than MP3 anyway)
Anyway, I believe that DRM-free iTunes tracks can be converted to MP3 by simply right-clicking them and selecting "convert to MP3" in iTunes.
DRM-free tracks are the ultimate compatibility to other players.
The reason Apple wouldn't license their Fairplay DRM is because that would endanger the "safety" of the DRM, and the record companies would be angry if it was easily cracked (or so they say)
No-DRM is better than licensed-DRM, however you put it.
So now no more iTunes sales for:
* Baby Boy Da Prince
* Bee Gees
* Drake Bell
* Black Child
* Brandon
* Big Tuck
* Big Tymers
* Blak Jak
* Bloodhound Gang
* Mutya Buena
* Vanessa Carlton
* Jamie Cullum
* Domination
* Down AKA Kilo
* Dispatch
* Drake Bell
* Godsmack
* Gotan Project
* Chris Gotti
* Pat Green
* Harry O.
* Heavy D.
* Infinite Mass
* Ja Rule
* Elton John
* Jack Johnson
* JoJo
* Juvenile
* Jordan Flynn
* Kaiser Chiefs
* Brie Larson
* Murphy Lee
* Lindsay Lohan
* Lloyd
* Damian Marley
* Stephen Marley
* Mika
* Mushroomhead
* Mystic
* Natalie
* Pharoahe Monch
* Prince
* Rakim
* Rammstein
* Scissor Sisters
* Strive Roots
* Sunland
The rest are here.
I'm not a fan of iTunes and have never bought anything off them, but Universals reasons for ditching them can only be nefarious. Okay so Prince isn't going to care, and Elton probably won't either. But if anyone knows the other artists it might pay to tell them what their label has done and that now might be a good time to think about their future with Universal.
"Nine times out of ten, starting a fire is not the best way to solve the problem." - my wife
I'd like to know who is selling less crippled music? With Microsoft's solution, to play on the PC, you need Windows Media Player, correct? Music from the Zune store only plays on the Zune. Allofmp3 is closed.
Apple does let you burn their DRM'd songs to CD, meaning you can play them in any CD player. You can also rerip. It's a crappy solution to get it onto a non-iPod player, but it's possible. Do other solutions offer this?