Slashdot Mirror
Broken Patent System? Google, Apple Disagree
Whiney Mac Fanboy writes "The AlwaysOn Stanford Summit featured the panel discussion 'The Patent Crisis: Crossroads for the Business of Technology.' Speakers included patent lawyers from Google, IBM, and Apple. According to The Register, Google's and Apple's patent jocks had diametrically opposing views. Google's head of patents believes the system is in crisis: 'The Patent Office is overburdened,' she said. 'The volume of patents going in is huge. And the quality of patents coming out — it could be better.' But Apple's chief patent counsel said the US patent system was 'not broken' and 'not in crisis,' calling it 'the best in the world.'"
...it never needs replacing!
But who do I take sides with? Who is the evil one here, the one in the wrong? Are you sure the article isn't missing a paragraph by a Microsoft manager or something, I need to attack somebody needlessly and follow someone mindlessly!
Jonathanjk.com
Heh :-)
Calling it 'the best in the world' is quite an insult to other patent systems.
It's an iPod shuffle! oooh, burn!
I like basketball!!1!
That night Apple submitted a patent for "A handheld device capable of playback of digital audio."(No link needed, this is the full text of the submission) which was immediately, and without review, approved by the head of the USPTO himself.
Apple: Our patent system is the best because it allows us to make money from trivial ideas before others can exploit them Google: Our patent system is in crisis because it sometimes threatens those of us who make money by exploiting your trivial ideas
technical writing / development
That'd be the sound of your cognitive dissonance knocking. Google/Apple = good, patents = bad. But, Google/Apple like patents!
I wish they wouldn't run stories like this...now what are we supposed to think?
They never did say how it was best ;)
The old saying "The enemy of my enemy is my friend"?
You have "The enemy of my enemy, the enemy of my enemy and the enemy of my enemy" Does that make them all my friends or all my enemies?
Your dad was mis-quoting Churchill.
In other news, after deciding that US patent system is the best there is, US also claims to be the most peaceable, cultured, intelligent and humble nation on Earth.
Shortly afterwards, US points out that as everything good, brave and beautiful comes from the US, so there is no need for the rest of the world, and declares nuclear war on it.
No sig for you!!