Slashdot Mirror
The $200 Billion Broadband Rip-Off
Jamie noted that Cringley has a piece about the US Broadband situation. He talks about where we were and where we are: 'not very fast, not very cheap Internet service that is hurting our ability to compete economically with the rest of the world' and about the $200B the phone companies got to make it that way.
While you're right, of course, about this being a story about government regulation, I don't see how that negates the contradiction I pointed out in my post. Without regulation, corporations would have even more leeway to stifle competition and transparency - examples of which abound, especially outside of western culture (example: the now richest guy in the world, the Mexican telecom magnate and his monopoly in Mexico).
A-Bomb
Except this isn't an example of "unbridled market capitalism". The original copper network was a private/public compromise built on private property seized by the government with its power of immanent domain.
The federal government allowed monopoly control of the copper by one company, as long as it agreed to follow certain rules that a normal company would not need to. That is why multiple phone companies were allowed to compete on the same copper.
Now we have the case where companies are not fulfilling their part of the bargain and the government isn't enforcing it any more.
Not the Netherlands - they have a +$45 billion trade balance and a budget surplus. Financially, they are golden. The only G7 country that is in similarly great financial shape is Canada.
...the Mexican telecom magnate and his monopoly in Mexico
A very heavily government protected monopoly. Hardly a case of "lack of regulation" I guarantee you. In fact it's a prime example for the libertarians to use against regulation. What we need is for the public to keep a close eye on how things are regulated and actually use their vote to weed out the crooks, otherwise it will only get worse.
What?
Your bullshit call is for the most part the only thing that is bullshit. The grand parent is correct you can travel between any of the original 13 EU members without stopping. Since the Schengen agreement all interior border controls were removed and the only border and customer enforcement is around the edges. If you have an EU passport its relatively easy to move around and work in EU countries.
The grandparent slightly overstates when he said "any country in the EU" since I don't think the newer members have signed on to these open borders yet.
The EU has really become the United States of Europe. Its more like the early United States since the states still retain a lot of power, but assuming it holds together it will probably continue to become more like one nation over time.
@de_machina
Rule of Slashdot #0: You and people like you are not representative of the larger population. - A.C.
Actually, "corporate personhood" only protects the owners (i.e., shareholders), not employees. Employees of a non-corporate company (i.e., a partnership) are no more or less liable for their actions that those of a large corporation. In principle, employees are responsible for their actions, and management is responsible for actions of their underlings, though in practice it is hard to convict people, this has nothing to do per se with their status as a corporation. The difference is, in a partnership, if an employee screws up while performing duties for the company, all partners have potentially unlimited financial liability. In a corporation, liability to the owners only extends to the assets held by the corporation.
There are lots of other ways in which corporations are treated as people, but most of it comes down to "they are non-person entities which can own property" -- this is the root of their ability to be slandered or libeled, their ability to be a party to a lawsuit, and so forth.
There is a partial solution. Thanks to the telephone investment earlier, you can get a T1 anywhere, and pay from $300 to $600 / month for 1.5Mb service. Get the neighbors together for a coop, add some WLAN, and you have almost broadband in the sticks that doesn't have multi-second latency like satellite. Get enough neighbors together with a lily pad WLAN, and you can upgrade to T3. (I know people who have done this. Don't use consumer WAPs designed for indoor use. Use outdoor models for a few $100 more that have lightning protection.)
If you can get line of sight to a friend/business partner in a nearby city, you can get 54Mb via a point to point wireless connection. With parabolic antenna, you can go quite a ways. The current record is 237 miles from a city to the side of a mountain in Venezuela (the mountain is critical to this setup as otherwise the horizon would block line of sight at this distance).
Finally, cell phone service goes many more places than broadband, and cell carriers offer broadband plans via their network. (So long, and thanks for all the honey...)