Can String Theory Accommodate Inflation?

David Shiga writes "String theory is the leading contender for a "theory of everything" that could unite all the forces of physics. But a recent study suggests that it may be more difficult than scientists had hoped to square string theory with inflation — the widely accepted notion that the early universe had a period of especially rapid expansion. Some say this could even lead to the abandonment of either string theory or inflation, though no one is ruling out a possible resolution yet."

Comments

Dark Matter

[jpflip]

Dark matter is certainly a bizarre hypothesis, and the question you ask is natural - couldn't we just be wrong about gravity? It's somewhat easier to believe that Einstein's general relativity is modified than that the universe is filled with so much mysterious, unseen "stuff". This is the basic idea behind MOND (MOdified Newtonian Dynamics) theories, which has received a good bit of thought among physicists.

MOND doesn't look like the right solution, however. The last 2 or 3 decades have provided an enormous amount of observational data about the structure of the universe (large scale structure, galactic dynamics, gravitational lensing, light element abundances, the cosmic microwave background...), all of which is basically consistent with the simplest dark matter model ("cold dark matter") and inconsistent with any modified gravity theory. We don't need to imagine any particularly exotic properties to the dark matter, it just needs to be something that doesn't interact with electromagnetic forces (just like a neutrino only much heavier). Even very complicated MOND models fail to match observations, however (unless you add in a bunch of dark matter anyway).

Perhaps the most striking example is provided by observations of the Bullet Cluster last year. Basically we've found a pair of colliding galaxy clusters where the collision has separated the dark matter from the ordinary matter somewhat. Skipping over the details, this provides dramatic evidence that dark matter is real "stuff" - in essentially any modified gravity theory without dark matter, the gravitational forces still have to be coming from the same place as the visible matter! This is a very general argument, and observations like this have more or less put the nail in the coffin of MOND theories.

Astrophysicists are almost universally convinced at this point that something like dark matter exists. We're starting to map its distribution in detail throughout the universe, and the next major challenge will be determining its makeup - either by production in an accelerator or detection in dedicated experiments.