Slashdot Mirror


Internet Blackout in Myanmar Stalls Citizen Report

StonyandCher writes "The government in Myanmar has reportedly cut off Internet access in the troubled country. The loss of Internet access in Myanmar has slowed the tide of photos and videos shared with the rest of the world but people outside of the troubled country continue to use new media sites and other technologies to protest military activity in the Southeast Asia country."

29 of 185 comments (clear)

  1. Site with TFA is loaded with flash by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

    Printer-friendly link.

  2. This, my friends.... by Man+On+Pink+Corner · · Score: 4, Interesting

    ... is exactly why you don't want to destroy the utility of the HF radio spectrum to sell it to broadband-over-power-line Internet providers.

    You don't want to put all of your communication eggs in one government-controlled basket.

    1. Re:This, my friends.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      is why they said the revolution would not be televised.

    2. Re:This, my friends.... by tloh · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Actually I was just being facetious. But I am curious to know the current state of ham radio in other parts of the world. Has anyone ever exchanged QSL with someone in Burma? Might be a good time for state-side hams to start listening and do some credit to the amateur radio discipline.

      --
      Stay sentient. Don't drink bad milk.
    3. Re:This, my friends.... by Vellmont · · Score: 4, Insightful


      is exactly why you don't want to destroy the utility of the HF radio spectrum to sell it to broadband-over-power-line Internet providers.


      Right. Because we all know an oppressive government that's willing and able to cut off internet access to an entire country won't be able to send a couple soldiers to gun down the guy down the street blasting HF in his ham shack.

      I think violating government spectrum policy would be the last thing such a person would be worried about.

      --
      AccountKiller
  3. Umm... only question: Why so late? by Opportunist · · Score: 4, Interesting

    The first thing an oppressive government usually does when unrest is rising is to make sure independent news and reports can't escape, so the only source for information is the official one. They actually took their time to do that, given that the civil war has started almost half a month ago.

    Well, maybe their astrologer said they should wait 2 more weeks 'cause then the stars are aligned or something.

    --
    We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
    1. Re:Umm... only question: Why so late? by damburger · · Score: 2, Informative

      I don't think your average autocratic police state is that tech-savvy - Burma is run by peope whose expertise lies more in the area of killing and torture.

      It may simply have not occurred to them to do this

      --
      If we can put a man on the moon, why can't we shoot people for Apollo-related non-sequiturs?
    2. Re:Umm... only question: Why so late? by aneeshm · · Score: 3, Informative

      I'm sorry to say this, but this is complete, total rubbish, probably born of ignorance.

      If you knew ANYTHING about the societies which were (they aren't now) run on a system of caste organisation, you would know that the monkhood is open to everyone.

      In India, in all Indic-influenced countries, one of the things that a monk undergoes is the renunciation of his ties with the world, including his birth, his caste, and his society. He is a free spirit. There is a saying, "Never seek the source of a sannyasi or a river." This basically means that once a person is a renunciate, that's it, you don't bother what he was before his new life, the old self is dead. This is the position taken by everyone, from the ultra-orthodox to the most liberal, and is the way things have been done for millennia.

      A part of renunciation includes conducting a full and proper funeral for the "old self", where all links to the past are cut. It is a difficult thing to do or undergo, but once it is done, that's it, it's over. You have no caste, no gender, no ties with the world, no regard for the taboos of your society, and no fear of the power structures within it.

      As for the allegation that monks do not do their duty to society - isn't it the exact opposite that is happening here? Aren't the monks acting as a rallying point for the protests?

    3. Re:Umm... only question: Why so late? by raju1kabir · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Maybe there is some way a communications satellites could boost the signal so that ordinary mobile phones could be turned into satellite phones?

      No, that won't make it possible for mobile phones to transmit with the strength necessary to reach orbit, or to cope with the signal delay.

      One interesting tidbit: On the Thai side of the very porous Burmese border, you can go into any 7-Eleven and buy an AIS One-2-Call SIM card for as little as 50 baht (about US$1.50). AIS often run cheap deals where you can get many hours of GPRS time for almost nothing. Along the border in Thailand you'll see cell towers, with antennas pointing in all directions, notably including into Burma. I find that I can get a signal from hilltops many miles into the country.

      Movement within Burma is restricted, but there is no practical way to stop something as small as a micro-SD card from moving to the border regions. So it should theoretically be possibly to set up an Underground Railroad for data, albeit one that works on a scale of days rather than microseconds. I think one of the main things preventing this at the moment is a lack of technical sophistication on the part of the people inside. I work with Burmese refugee groups from time to time, and it is amazing to me how many technological possibilities remain to be explored.

      When you see the mental hunger of someone who has just made it out of Burma, ended up at a refugee welfare organisation in Thailand, and stays up until dawn surfing the web night after night, preferring to read the BBC web site than eat or go to the bathroom, it's clear why that sophistication is missing. People just have no exposure to information technology and haven't had any chance to develop their skills; those who do are either (1) wealthy and connected, (2) returnees from abroad, or (3) very exceptional self-motivators, who are in small numbers anywhere. What works there in terms of slowing the movement of information would never work in other countries.

      --
      "Patriotism is your conviction that this country is superior to all other countries because you were born in it." -- GBS
  4. Control=Cut off information by kcpearly15 · · Score: 3, Informative

    I guess this goes back to the idea that if you can control the information going to and from people, you can control the people themselves. It is really a statement of where the internet is today in terms of importance around the world. I would like to see if anyone from this country manages to make an "underground" makeshift connection to the internet. Also, does any one else find it interesting that the group forming together to protest for the rights of the monks is on facebook?

  5. Re:Ah, well ... by Sideshow+Coward · · Score: 3, Informative
    Perhaps the RFC for IP over Avian Carrier has the answers...

    http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc1149/

    http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2549/

  6. Satellite access a possibility? by Langfat · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I have never used a satellite internet provider, but I know that they do exist. Could someone on slashdot explain what is required for such service? I assume a modem which would be registered with a satellite provider. What is the feasibility of smuggling such things into Burma?

  7. WTF? Haven't you heard of Burmah Oil? by Colin+Smith · · Score: 2, Informative

    Myanmar == Burma

    It has large quantities of oil and gas...

    WTF do you think there are problems in the place all of a sudden? Do you think it's coincidence there are problems and unrest in oil producing countries now that world oil production has fallen for the last few years?

    http://www.worldoil.com/INFOCENTER/STATISTICS_DETAIL.asp?Statfile=_worldoilproduction

    --
    Deleted
  8. Re:Ah, well ... by Qubit · · Score: 4, Funny

    Time to start using pigeons...I wonder what sort of compression...

    Now I'm no birdkeeper, but have you ever tried to gzip a pigeon before?
    --

    coding is life /* the rest is */
  9. please... by joe+155 · · Score: 4, Informative

    as someone mentioned before, call the country Burma. That's the name which signifies that you don't accept the legitimacy of the murders who have stolen the country and ruled over it for all these years.

    Also, I don't get the anti-bush tag, he seems to be doing a lot more than most to help the situation...

    --
    *''I can't believe it's not a hyperlink.''
    1. Re:please... by Vellmont · · Score: 2, Insightful


      That's the name which signifies that you don't accept the legitimacy of the murders who have stolen the country and ruled over it for all these years.


      Bah. Countries are as countries do. If you have the ability to act like a government, you're a government. It's pointless and counter-productive to play some dumb name game where you close your eyes and pretend reality isn't reality.

      --
      AccountKiller
    2. Re:please... by butlerdi · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I do believe the name Burma came from when the British were the murders who had stolen the country and ruled over it for all those years.

      --
      "If the King's English was good enough for Jesus, it's good enough for me!" -- "Ma" Ferguson, Governor of Texas (circa
  10. Fucking Myanmar... by danielsfca2 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Isn't this shit sad? I mean, a tyrannical military government that nobody wants in power, who's abusing that power by willfully shooting civilians. Of course, our leaders don't give a rats ass beyond talking about how "concerned" or "saddened" or "disappointed" because Myanmar doesn't have any oil, or strategic position we can use.

    I'm not trying to say Iraq wasn't justified. It doesn't matter. Whether it was or not, I think Myanmar's military rulers need a good ass-kicking. And there's an ass we could kick overnight if we wanted to. Just bust in there to their headquarters and fire some automatic weapons at them just the same way they do to the innocent monks. That'll teach 'em. Throw in an election to put up a REAL government, and we'd be home by Christmas.

    1. Re:Fucking Myanmar... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      Err there already IS a real government and one with a Presedent-elect who is a Nobel Peace Prize laureate.

      The whole point of the protests is that the ruling junta never allowed her to take office after they won the election.

  11. Re:Ah, well ... by Leftist+Troll · · Score: 5, Funny

    have you ever tried to gzip a pigeon before?

    Compressing a pigeon is not difficult (though a little messy), it's decompressing it that I can't quite figure out.

  12. It's worse than that... by Langfat · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Burma DOES have oil. Chevron (US) and Total (French) are two of the biggest benefactors. China, Russia and India all have billions invested as well. So long as the money keeps coming, no one seems to care who is in power or how they exercise it...

  13. Re:routing around censorship by Markspark · · Score: 2, Funny

    there's really no need to worry about that.. Burma is a very poor country, and has no oil, so i see no reason why Bush would want to "liberate" the Burmese people.

    --
    i find your lack of faith in science disturbing!
  14. Burma has lots of oil by Langfat · · Score: 5, Informative

    Burma is a very resource-rich country. The problem is that rather than the wealth going to the people, it is funneled into the pockets of the military generals (who then splurge on their daughters' weddings)

    At the risk of sounding like a broken record, Burma has tons of oil. Chevron and Total are the two Western companies profiting the most, but China, India and Russia all have significant (read multi-BILLION dollar) investments as well..

  15. Brilliant global politics by Hrothgar+The+Great · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Your understanding of the issues surrounding this situation seem to be extremely poor, and the observations made in the post you are defending are equally ignorant and childish.

    The situation for the US, or any Western government which might want to get involved militarily in Myanmar today is simple - involve your military today in Myanmar, and you will almost certainly find yourself facing the very threatening military might of China, their strongest ally.

    It would require you reading maybe half of one of the dozens of articles written about the Myanmar mess in the last week or so to understand this. I'm actually kind of disgusted with the laziness displayed in this forum, but I guess it's nothing new. Go back to digg or whatever, seriously.

  16. Re:Why Is This Modded Up??!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Clearly, the situation in Myanmar is all America's fault. If they hadn't invented the Internet, then it couldn't be cut off.

  17. Morse? by Attaturk · · Score: 4, Interesting

    If they've cut off every single international phone line you can still radio data in and out. People tend to think that going high tech is the way to break out of these kinds of situations - e.g. satellites etc. - when often going back to flashing light semaphore or carrier pigeon is more likely to succeed.

    Losing the connection to Burma slightly, the Romans employed four flags on poles to communicate messages up and down Hadrian's Wall. In ideal conditions they could get a 4-bit message from one end to the other (70-something miles) in a matter of seconds - that's a pretty good bitrate for something with no electricity behind it. Granted you can't get streaming video of monks being beaten up at that kind of bandwidth but radio's a different story.

    And setting up mobile radio stations is probably easier than installing a massive communications line of wooden poles without the military noticing. Many brave individuals carefully concealed both receivers and transmitters throughout occupied Europe often at great personal risk, for example. Communications routed around damage even back then. I'm sure there are people within that country right now beaming data out. I wonder where messages in bottles cast out on their beaches would wash ashore. You could squeeze quite a bit of memory into a bottle.

    Anyway, I think what I'm rambling about is that there's always a way. I just hope there are enough people with the balls out there taking these risks and, much more importantly, I hope that their messages do not fall on deaf ears. Sadly I feel some of the more powerful countries, who might otherwise be in a position to levy some immense pressure on the Burmese junta, are somewhat under-staffed at the moment. Although it's fair to say that some other countries - that are most definitely not under-staffed - remain on the outside of this affair for rather more cryptic and apparently self-serving reasons.

    All said with humble and awkward apologies for commenting on the topic while enjoying a comfortable yet-to-be-oppressed privileged lifestyle.

  18. internet censorship in Myanmar brought to you by by sdedeo · · Score: 3, Informative

    the American firm Fortinet, which runs the Myanmar Wide Web.

    --
    Protect your liberties. Donate to the ACLU
  19. Re:Where are you, George? by nagora · · Score: 3, Insightful
    China is already bleeding the US in Iraq (via its proxy Iran)

    Oh, grow up.

    Iran and Iranians are only too happy to aid the insurgents in Iraq for the very, very simple reason that a bunch of total cunts dropped weapons of mass destruction on them in the form of nerve gas and bio weapons. Who were these bastards that went beyond any acceptable limits of civilised behaviour? Well, goodness me! It seems that it was the good old US of fucking A and it's ongoing mission to bring democracy and strong IP laws to the world! And strangely, dropping plagues on Iran has led to anti-American feeling there?! They're just unreasonable, those ragheads.

    If America had treated my country the way the US treated Iran, I'D be an insurgent too, and I suspect you would too, without any need to listen to anti-China fairy stories.

    Apart from anything else, there's a mountain of reasons to hate China without having to make new ones up. Unless, of course, you are really just trying to justify some other totally unconnected policy.

    TWW

    --
    "Encyclopedia" is to "Wikipedia" what "Library" is to "Some people at a bus stop"
  20. Re:internet censorship in Myanmar brought to you b by Slashcrap · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Software produced by Fortinet, but not administered, supervised or maintained by Fortinet, is used by the government of Myanmar to censor the MWW.

    Yes, you're quite right. Fortinet are only making money out of the situation and therefore should be entirely excused of any suggestion of wrongdoing. Likewise anyone selling arms to the Burmese government should also be excused because they're not the ones actually shooting monks in the fucking head.

    If you disagree with my comparison, please do feel free to let us know exactly where the difference lies.