Slashdot Mirror
Countering the Arguments Against Unbundling Windows
An anonymous reader sends in a link to a blog posting by Con Zymaris arguing for competition regulators to force the unbundling of Windows from consumer PCs. The argument takes the form of knocking down one by one the objections raised by "unbundling skeptics."
you think apple doesn't have support costs? i know an apple service tech, he's a busy man.
If you mod me down, I will become more powerful than you can imagine....
Ok, so the article reads like any other piece of "news" drivel.
The guy pulls numbers out of his ass (despite references, he still makes most of it up).
Idiotic claims like "OS was 5% of a PC cost x years ago and now is 50%". Well enjoy the idiot award. because *ONE* court case in europe managed to quote ONE example of where they claimed the cost was 50% does not mean that's what it is for EVERY PC.
Good god. Take and apply to and...well...oh yeah! Slashdot news. Right.
You can get rich if you own a politician, but you have to be rich to buy one in the first place.
It hasn't. Silly people who either have suffered a sharp blow to the head rendering their long-term memory of Microsoft's conviction as an abusive monopoly, or who are simply not sufficiently intellectually potent to understand what that means make retarded statements like that.
The world's burning. Moped Jesus spotted on I50. Details at 11.
There's one flaw in your analogy - the quality of the software available in the average linux distro is superior to that produced by Microsoft. Microsoft will never again be able to catch up in the quality department.
There's a second flaw in your analogy - Microsoft doesn't manufacture PCs, so why should anyone who wants to compete with them at any level bog themselves down by doing so?
There's a third flaw in your analogy - that those of us who back a gift economy or a pay-it-forward economy are "rationalizing a fear of competing with Microsoft." Its possible to earn a living by giving away your code - businesses such as IBM (who are a lot bigger than Microsoft) have figured that out. Its just too bad that Microsoft can't compete by giving away code and then charging for services. They're not set up that way, and that's their biggest problem.
Now my giving away a few hard drives with linux preinstalled is not "bad for Linux co". They don't "lose promotional hard drives" - first, because there is no such thing as "Linux co", and second, because they were not their hard drives to begin with. To the extent that this creates a larger potential market, it still benefits your hypothetical "Linux co.", so its certainly not a drain on the economy. Or are you going to argue that all the companies who give away free promotional samples are wrong?
Then we'll be hearing about how the "evil convicted monopolist" is hampering their sales
What sales? These people are "too good" to get out there and sell. Instead, they'll argue that they should just have a tax to do what they want. Yawn, classically liberal.
Vista is an atomic bomb with a slow fuse. When it goes off, there will be no linux left.
This is my sig.
i play xbox 360 with my brother sometimes... its very cool... my brother is 30 years old hes pretty smart... he has 45 iq its the same as heis shoe size.. pretu good considaring 100 is full.... nentendo is cool but xbawks 360 is beter... i am masetr chief from halo... bcz when i played halo for the second time i knew what was going too happen befor eit happend... so im takeru... its pretty cooll... sonic is cool... i dont like tails though bcz hes sonics girlfrend... i want2 be sonics girlfrend.... sonic is so fast and handsome its increddibnle... sometimes... together... my mom and dad are brother and sister... its prety cool i gess... i herd its prety normal in america.... they love eachother like a father and daugher... theyr so cute together... together... sometimes... xbox... my brother is in wheel chair... but hes cool because hes smart... yea... the boy in the basements said he isnt smart and he say bad thing about my dad... but its no mater... he is chained up... in basement... together... xbox... yea... maybe... xbox is pretty cool bcz they its like games... together... sometimes... i hear screaming from basement... dosnt mater... the boy there is happey.... yea...
These companies, or their representatives, are welcome to offer Dell, et al, deals for loading their OS in place of Windows. Whether you like Windows or not, it does offer value to consumers who want to purchase a computer. So far, Linux, et al, have not been able to prove they have the same value. Forcing computer manufacturers to cripple their product for a minority group of people at best is ridiculous. Prove your OS has more value then Windows and the rest will fall into place. Here's a hint though, anecdotal evidence won't cut it.