The Pirate Bay Takes Over Anti-Piracy Domain
palpatin writes to let us know that The Pirate Bay has now taken up residence at IFPI.com, a domain once owned by the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry. The Pirate Bay says the site will now promote the International Federation of Pirates Interests. IFPI can still be reached at ifpi.org. Torrentfreak has up a brief interview with Brokep, one of the administrators of The Pirate Bay, who says: "It's not a hack, someone just gave us the domain name. We have no idea how they got it, but it's ours and we're keeping it."
Does anyone else have a problem with the justification of:
"yes, this shipment of cigarettes just arrived at our doorstep, we figured we'd keep 'em".
The Pirate Bay could have been rather more subtle about it:
1. copy the content of IFPI.org
2. change the content, subtly at first
3. publish ever more outrageous claims
4. wait for people to realize the site isn't owned by the IFPI.
A domain was registered. This domain was transfered to TPB. Where is the theft?
Who said that IFPI.com was ever owned by the IFPI?
Who said that they still own it, provided they ever did?
You have to register domains to have them. Having "your" domain isn't some sort of human right or part of your intrinsic rights when filing for corporation. Just because those four letters are some sort of acronym for your company/organisation/whatever doesn't mean you have all rights to those four letters and nobody else may ever create anything that could use that acronym and (god forbid) even register a domain name that consists of those four letters. There are actually only 26^4 ways to create four letter acronyms, and some (like ANAL or FUCK) ain't really useful. At least to most businesses.
We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
Furthermore, if this is the way the domain was obtained, it may make it harder for the IFPI folks to take back. Since the domain was at one time legally owned by them, and then abandoned, the domain name arbitrator could rule that they relinquished any claim to the name when they abandoned it. After all, if they really wanted the domain name, wouldn't they have renewed it?