Native Windows PE File Loading on OS X?

ozmanjusri writes "Coders working on Wine for Mac have found that the Mac loader has gained its own undocumented ability to load and understand Windows Portable Executable (PE) files. They found PE loading capabilities in Leopard that weren't there in Tiger. Further dissection showed that Apple is masking references to 'Win' and 'PE' in the dll, which means it's not an accidental inclusion. Is Apple planning native PE execution within OS X?"

Comments

Not for Win32 compatibility

[SigILL]

I don't think this is intended for Win32 compatibility. Apple has every reason not to do that, because it will mean there will be no more native versions of high-profile applications such as Photoshop. Adobe is probably already pissed off there won't be a 64-bit version of Carbon, which requires them to rewrite the entire UI of Photoshop in Cocoa to be able to release a 64-bit version of it. Giving them an easy way out by offering Win32 binary-level compatibility isn't in Apple's best interest there.

However, consider that the PE file format is also used by Microsoft's Common Language Runtime (CLR/.NET). Therefore, I think this is a preparatory move to start offering a native implementation of the .NET platform for OS X.

Re:noooo FP

[onefriedrice]

> please not - i don't need every windows malware able to run on my mac...

Except windows malware is just that: malware written for Windows. While it could potentially run, malware wouldn't automatically become a problem. You'd have a much easier time accidently running OS X malware than Windows malware. Think of it as WINE for OS X (which is apparently exactly what it is or will be except Jaguar can load the binaries itself). People running Windows binaries via WINE on Linux don't experience the same problems with malware because the expected security flaws in the underlying OS and/or applications aren't there.

In short, if Apple plans to implement a built-in WINE-like ability to run some Windows binaries in OS X, there is no reason to suspect it will cause a breeding ground for Windows malware. Malware only has the opportunity to run if it can somehow get installed.