'Extreme Security' Web Browsing

Sarah S writes "The application security researcher Jeremiah Grossman described to CSO magazine how he takes extreme measure to stay safe online. The simplest tip he uses: two separate browsers: 'One, which he calls the 'promiscuous' browser, is the one he uses for ordinary browsing. A second browser is used only for security-critical tasks such as online banking. When Grossman wants to do online banking, he closes his promiscous browser, opens the more prudish one, and does only what he has to do before closing it and going back to his insecure browser.'"

Comments

Not sure how "secure" this scheme is...

[TripMaster Monkey]

How exactly is this strategy going to protect you from a keylogger?

Re:Not sure how "secure" this scheme is...

[ZombieWomble]

Well, looking at the article itself (I know, I know, heresy), the point is that there are whole classes of attacks (specifically "Cross Site Request Forgery" attacks, the focus of this article) which require significant effort on the part of websites to defend against, but which are trivially defended against by having users make a point of not accessing secure and insecure sites at the same time.

It's in no way presented as a solution to all security on the internet, but a way of addressing one specific class of problems in a simple manner with a minimum of effort. Unfortunately there's plenty of sufficiently smug people on /. who will continue to repeat this idea in this discussion without even glancing at the article.

Re:Not sure how "secure" this scheme is...

[hawkinspeter]

There are easy methods to defeat a keylogger though most of them rely on the server side. Asking for only certain characters from a password (e.g. characters 1,4,8 & 9); virtual screen keyboards (just mouseclicks are recorded); drop down lists to select characters.

confusing web security with girl-friend security

[oni]

What he's describing is not a way of keeping your computer safe, it's a way of hiding porn from your girlfriend. You use some browser that she's never heard of for all your illicit surfing. Then, she fires up your computer and starts running IE, she looks in your history and sees slashdot and CNN or whatever and doesn't think you're a pervert (which you are).

It's also a good idea to have "honeypot porn" which is basically, a few very innocuous sites that you vist in IE that you intentionally want her to find - because once she starts looking, she's going to keep looking until she finds something. Best to give her something to find. Let her think you go to maxim.com or something.

Re:thats annoying...

[FredFredrickson]

I use IE as my 'promiscuous' browser and Firefox as my safe browser - makes sense to me. But of course, this is not the only means I have of protecting myself but it helps in one important way... It reminds me that I should be careful. That makes as much sense as only wearing the bullet proof vest when you're doing non-dangerous activities.

If anything, I'd do it the other way around. Promiscuous browsing on IE will certainly get you infected (ever open a pron site with IE? I haven't in years, and I don't plan to start now- even if those exploits have been fixed). I explorer is the only browser I can remember that would just let a virus download and install itself while you battled 80 popups. I understand Iexplorer7 is slightly better, but come on- that's what people are targeting, new exploits will come up.

I do things exactly opposite. I use opera for all my browsing, and nothing gets through. Then I load up internet explorer for my online banking. (my bank requires IE). I see no danger in that, because internet explorer is clean when I do it, thanks to the fact I never use it (and I clean my system regularly) with hijack this and pv and what not.