Slashdot Mirror
Open Source DRM Solutions?
Feint writes "I'm working on an business platform for inter-company collaboration based on an open source software stack. As part of that platform I would like to integrate some sort of digital rights management for the documents in the system. The vast majority of articles about DRM are focused how good or evil it is to apply DRM to digital music or video. I haven't seen many articles address open source solutions for protecting business data like CAD / MS Office / PDF / etc. documents, which is a real need in business today. Can the Slashdot readership suggest some open source DRM offerings other than the Sun DReaM initiative, which hasn't had a release since Jan. 2007?"
I'm sure some of us could, but why would we want to? Design our own prison? Encumber data? Stop whistleblowers?
For every problem, there is at least one solution that is simple, neat, and wrong.
DRM depends on proprietary software. You are encrypting a file, then giving the user the key to decode it, while telling the program in question to decode the file, but only allow it to be used in one of a few ways (eg. display PDF, but don't print).
Such a system is untenable with proprietary software (just need to find the right memory address), and absolutely impossible with open source software, as you can simply remove the line in the program that tells it what actions not to allow. (See xpdf). With proprietary DRM systems, the companies just hope it's difficult enough to decipher the compiled code of the proprietary programs, that it takes a while before someone finds the right spots in memory to probe/change, and publishes the details... Then, they make trivial changes to the DRM system, and call it a new, "fixed" version that everyone should start using quickly (before someone figures it out).
The only thing DRM can do effectively, is to prevent the first opening of the file. After you send that first key (eg. via server), no matter what the DRM involved, the user can (trivially) strip the DRM off, and do whatever they want with the unencrypted file.
If that is what you want... I would suggest using public-key encryption to protect the file instead of a commercial "DRM" system. Either PGP or SSL (keys in combination with a password) can make absolutely sure only the intended recipient can make use of the file, even if others obtain copies of it. If you are expecting any more control over what others do with the file, you are simply denying reality.
All that said, here is one open source DRM system: http://www.sidespace.com/products/oggs/
Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
DRM is a twisted variant of crypto. If Alice sends a message to Bob using GPG, Eve can't read it because she doesn't have the key. In this case, Bob is the intended recipient, and Eve is the unintended recipient. In the case of DRM, Alice encrypts software and gives it to Bob. So, if Alice doesn't give Bob the key, Bob can't use the software. If Alice does, then Bob can break the DRM, having both the key and the code.
So, in DRM, Bob and Eve are the same person. DRM is not only socially undesirable, it's sexually perverse.
"When you have eliminated the unacceptable, whatever is left, however improbable, must be the truthiness" - Holmes
Aditionally, at some point, people will just not put up with that nonsense anymore - with HDDVD players refusing to work with projectors or whatever because one little detail in the HDCP chain isn't exactly right, and other horror stories like this.
The alternative is easier nowadays: Piracy - It Just Works. With sites like ThePirateBay and easy to use Bittorrent clients like uTorrent and the likes, and with fast net connections, pirating HD content is seriously becoming easier for average users than getting it in a legit way.