Slashdot Mirror
The Tree of Life Consolidates
Roland Piquepaille writes "The Tree of Life is an expression first used by Charles Darwin to describe the diversity of organisms on Earth and their evolutionary history. There are only two life forms, — eukaryotes, which gather their genetic material in a nucleus, and prokaryotes, such as bacteria, which have their genetic material floating freely in the cell. Until recently, eukaryotes, which include humans, were divided into five groups. But now, based on work by European researchers, the Tree of Life has lost a branch. After doing the largest ever genetic comparison of life forms they concluded that there are only four groups of eukaryotes."
While a tree-structure is algorithmically convenient and very enticing... the "tree of life" is not a tree.
Ie it is not a "directed, acyclic graph".
Unfortunately it has 'cycles'.
Blame retroviruses; they can take genetic material from one species and insert it into the genome of another thereby creating cross-branches.
As I recall, from my genetics days, baboon retroviruses are a great example of this. Again, IIRC, domestic cats and humans both contain fragments of baboon retroviruses.
Its possible that the "Cambrian explosion" is a sign of the appearance of retroviruses on the scene.
The thing is that it is significantly harder to reason about graphs; trees are so much easier to deal with.
So its very tempting to see things like this as trees and to 'simplify out' the nasty cross-branches.
(I've studied genetics, computer science, logic and discrete math)
In the free world the media isn't government run; the government is media run.
In the pursuit of knowledge, every day something is added.
In the pursuit of understanding, every day something is removed.
In Xanadu did Kubla Khan
A stately pleasure dome decree