Slashdot Mirror


Four Indicted in Pirate Bay Case

paulraps writes "Suddenly the founders of the Pirate Bay are not so hearty. The four men behind the popular file-sharing site were indicted in Sweden on Thursday on charges of being accessories to breaking copyright law. And this is more than just a shot across the bows. The prosecutor reckons that they can be hooked for 'promoting other people's copyright breaches' but there will be no walking the plank: instead, they face fines of up to $200,000 and the confiscation of all their hardware. 'The Swedish prosecutor listed dozens of works that had been downloaded through The Pirate Bay site, including The Beatles' Let It Be, Robbie Williams' Intensive Care and the movie Harry Potter & The Goblet of Fire. Plaintiffs in the case include Warner, MGM, Columbia Pictures, 20th Century Fox Films, Sony BMG, Universal and EMI.'"

8 of 709 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Done their homework? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    Rephrase:

    The blindingly obvious facts are that the people using TPB torrents clearly value all of the media that those ZOMG EEVIL FASCIST MAFIAA BULLY BOYS are creating, because they're downloading it at a rate of terabytes per day. As their products aren't necessary to life and are clearly for entertainment value, all of your whiny, breast-beating claims of ZOMZOMG PRICE-FIXING DEFRAUDING FRAUDITUDE amount to exactly JACK fucking SHIT. You don't need their products to live, you just want to have them for free and then want to whine that your precious freedoms are being ripped from you when you can no longer gank them under the guise of YAAARGH DIGITAL FREEDOMZ FOR TEH TRUE ARTISTZ!

  2. Re:Dangerous Nonsense. by cliffski · · Score: 1, Troll

    If you meet me for lunch and I have a side order of fries, and tell you to help yourself, that's sharing.

    if I go out to work each day and work my ass off to make movies, and you go work as a plumber, and then I see you watch the movies I work at for free, yet expect me to pay you if you do some plumbing, then that isn't sharing, its called 'freeloading' or 'leeching'.

    But any sensible discussion about the moral rights to other peoples hard work here is fruitless. Someone has already been modded up for using the term 'MAFIAA', so its all downhill hero-worship of TPB from here on.

    --
    DRM-free indie games for the PC and Mac: Positech Games
  3. Puh-leeze by KarmaOverDogma · · Score: 0, Troll

    That has got to be one of the lamest arguments I have ever heard.

    Google's referencing of copyrighted .torrent files is a small, arguably incidental, part of what it does; the Pirate Bay uses advertising for the *almost* exclusive purpose of facilitating file-sharing of copyrighted materials.

    True, there's probably some .torrent files on the site that allow the sharing of files without copyrights, but that's not the reason for the vast majority of traffic on the The Pirate Bay.

    Go ahead, mod me flaimbait now.

    --
    uR iGn0ranc3, Their Power
  4. Re:Jews by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    In my country we have song:

    In my country there is problem
    And that problem is the Jew
    They take everybody money
    And they never give it back

    Throw the jew down the well
    So my country can be free
    You must grab him by his horns
    Then we have a big party

    If you see the Jew coming
    You must be careful of his teeth
    You must grab him by his money
    And I tell you what to do

    Throw the jew down the well
    So my country can be free
    You must grab him by his horns
    Then we have a big party

    Throw the jew down the well
    So my country can be free
    You must grab him by his horns
    Then we have a big party

  5. what the internet needs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    I've said this many times but I'll repeat once again, this general purpose net connection stack tcp/ip has to go. In its place a large defined set of protocols can allow broadcast style networking for the internet savvy consumer, and if Microsoft had the lead in engineering this, you can be sure that most computers would be compatible, and Microsoft could also sell "Microsoft Gateway" products to let Apple participate.

    This set of protocols could allow trusted machines to receive properly licensed and authorized content but still filter out other less useful but more dangerous content/extentions like exe's, zips, tar.gz's, bz2, py, and iso's, and additionally any encrypted content, and the major webserver venders would have to outlaw application/octet mime types to regain control of the internet-turned-piracy haven that the thieves like warez groups and gnu have perverted, not to mention all the pornography and child molesting an open internet produces.

    Its time to make the net safe again for our families and businesses.

  6. Re:I'll take you up on that by Vr6dub · · Score: 0, Troll

    Sorry dude but I don't think you could pay someone to copy that painting. It looks like something I would have done in grade school. I understand art is in the eye of the beholder but...DAMN!

  7. Re:Illegal != !civil by illegalcortex · · Score: 0, Troll

    This is pointless. Other than being an ass, I don't see any point to your comments. You continue to fail to post any actual links to law, court cases or legal analysis that back up your wild hypotheses. Please enjoy your fantasy.

    If you'd like to actually DISCUSS this instead of being an ass, please feel free to get back to me.

  8. Re:high demand commodities by gnuman99 · · Score: 0, Troll

    Bullshit.

    Marijuana is a *controlled* substance because it is a mind-altering substance like other illegal and some legal drugs (Oxycotin, morphine, coke, etc.). It's been only been deemed legal for people with a prescription to use it. People that are terminally ill. People that will not drive under it's influence and kill others because their are stoned out of their mind.

    Furthermore, pott is more damaging to your lungs than smoking a pack of cigarettes,
        http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7217601.stm

    And it is addictive.

    Hell, most sane nations are now in process of getting rid of all the cigarettes as the damage to society mounts.

    Only substance that then remains is alcohol though that has its benefits in *small* amounts and just as bad as controlled substances in medium/large quantities... (see drunk driving or http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20080130.wsaskgirl0130/BNStory/National )

    Anyway, anyone possessing controlled substances without a permit should be jailed for a long, long time. To facilitate people killing themselves, *free* access to these substances should be provided in monitored environments where they can take as much as they want. They will only be released once *sober*. And all people driving intoxicated killing others should be charged with *exactly* the same crimes as other murderers.