Slashdot Mirror


Delays to Canadian DMCA Could Doom Act

Jabbrwokk writes "Michael Geist reports legislation to create a Canadian version of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act has been delayed again, possibly because of massive public outcry, and possibly even because of opposition from the industry itself. Canada's biggest ISPs have banded together to oppose the proposed new legislation and suggest their own solution, which include allowances for expanded fair dealing, private copying, no liability for ISPs and legislation that concentrates its wrath on commercial pirates instead of penny-ante downloaders and seeders.'"

3 of 128 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Its the beer stupid by Telvin_3d · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Biggest difference in Canada? We have a habit of tossing out political parties that piss us off. We can get away with it because there are 4-5 major parties active at any one time, so easy enough to out with the old and in with the new. And there is always a couple parties that have to compete to be the new big dogs.

    And when we get rid of a party, they are gone. In 1993, one of the Conservative parties passed unpopular tax laws. They went from controlling 57% of the seats to controlling .6% (2 out of 295). Do that once or twice and your politicians will get the message.

  2. Re:We have been lucky by p0tat03 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I think the main reason for the saner laws in this parliament is due to the minority. If any party has a majority we'll get some pretty crazy bills passed through the House. IMHO we should just keep minority governments around forever - it keeps legislation sane and relatively nonpartisan.

  3. Re:Once more ... by Citizen+of+Earth · · Score: 4, Insightful

    On more than one occassion various industry groups in the US have threatened to cut Canada off if we don't do something about copyright infringement.

    I double-dog dare them to. They'd be shooting themselves in the foot by eliminating 26-million easily-accessible customers (English-speaking Canadians). But, more importantly, they wouldn't do it because they know that their rhetoric is bullshit.