Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Linux Gains Native RTOS Emulation Layer

Posted by ScuttleMonkey on from the still-waiting-on-the-developer's-flyback-time dept.

nerdyH writes to tell us that the Xenomai/SOLO project is attempting to deliver VxWorks and other RTOS emulation for any Linux kernel. "Some weeks ago, I started laying the groundwork for porting the Xenomai emulators natively over the PREEMPT_RT kernel. Unlike the co-kernel based Xenomai version, SOLO does not require any kernel support from additional modules or patches. It is fully based on the standard POSIX library, and runs as a regular process controlled by a single image Linux kernel. As a first step, a VxWorks emulator has just been rebuilt over this new framework."

2 of 89 comments (clear)

  1. Realtime, VxWorks, Dolla Dolla Bill Yall by Epistax · · Score: 5, Interesting

    The benchmarks that are really expected by real time in my area are things like consistency. For example if we set a task/thread to execute every 125 milliseconds, the closer it hits the mark the better. Time lag in either direction puts that OS in the "No" category. Another important asset of an RTOS is well defined task preemption: No task gets preempted by one with worse priority. Time slicing might be enabled so that a task gets preempted by one of the same priority, and better priority tasks always preempt if they are ready to go. Also if a high priority task is waiting on a resource owned by a low priority task, that low priority task gets an elevated priority equal to the high priority task. As a last ditch effort to provide mutual exclusion / data protection, threads/tasks need to be able to disable system interrupts. Remember kids, in the RTOS world one task can take down the whole system.

    VxWorks is the only OS I've played with so far that allows this, but I'm VERY curious to see what people can inject into the Linux kernel. VxWorks is.. shall we say... NOT CHEAP. And inter-version migration is a pain... and god help you if you aren't using off the shelf hardware...

    1. Re:Realtime, VxWorks, Dolla Dolla Bill Yall by pla · · Score: 5, Interesting

      VxWorks is.. shall we say... NOT CHEAP.

      Have you ever actually had to code for Vx?

      You couldn't pay me enough (literally - I've turned down jobs that wanted me to work with it... I should probably take it off my resume) to deal with that POS (by which I don't mean "Point Of Sale") on a regular basis.

      Actually, in fairness, as an OS, it doesn't suck too much. But the build tools... Let's just say WindRiver clearly subscribes to the "firmware should hurt" coding paradigm. The IDE made OutLook look stable and friendly, the command line build tools simply didn't work (literally - WR couldn't even have tested them, because they failed phenomenally even on a clean install and a "hello world" module), the revision control had no objection to overwriting parent revisions without forcing a new fork... Ugh. I'll probably have nightmares tonight just from thinking about it.

      Oddly enough, it surprises me to see it still talked about. When I suffered with it nearly a decade ago, it looked like a near-certainty that Linux would tap that last nail in its coffin. How ironic, that Linux should now give it new life via emulation.