Slashdot Mirror


Hard Evidence of Voting Machine Addition Errors

goombah99 writes "Princeton Professor, Ed Felton, has posted a series of blog entries in which he shows the printed tapes he obtained from the NJ voting machines don't report the ballots correctly. In response to the first one, Sequoia admitted that the machines had a known software design error that did not correctly record which kind of ballots were cast (republican or democratic primary ballots) but insisted the vote totals were correct. Then, further tapes showed this explanation to be insufficient. In response, State officials insisted that the (poorly printed) tapes were misread by Felton. Again further tapes showed this not to be a sufficient explanation. However all those did not foreclose the optimistic assessment that the errors were benign — that is, the possibility that vote totals might really be correct even though the ballot totals were wrong and the origin of the errors had not been explained. Now he has found (well-printed) tapes that show what appears to be hard proof that it's the vote totals that are wrong, since two different readout methods don't agree. Sequoia has made trade-secret legal threats against those wishing to mount an independent examination of the equipment. One small hat-tip to Sequoia: at least they are reporting enough raw data in different formats that these kinds of errors can come to light — that lesson should be kept in mind when writing future requirements for voting machines."

4 of 275 comments (clear)

  1. One thing to say... by Brad1138 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Paper Ballots - Paper Ballots - PAPER BALLOTS!

    --
    If you could reason with religious people, there would be no religious people
  2. I've just got to ask... by Nursie · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ... How hard can it be?

    Seriously, how hard?

    Someone presses a button and a counter gets incremented. Big whoop.
    Any error at all in a programming exercise that goddamn simple is evidence enough for me to call for a full on corruption investigation.

  3. I'm amazed by this every time that I by zappepcs · · Score: 4, Insightful

    see another story about vote machine problems. If it was a NASA rocket motor there would be congressional investigations, news people camped out waiting for news of the investigation at NASA headquarters etc.

    But this gets shoved under the carpet at every turn like a bit of dirt that not even MSM wants to report on.

    It makes me sad to be American, well, sad that such things happen in America. We are supposed to be better than this. We were (I think) and I hope that we are better than this soon. It's disgusting.

    The machines themselves are not complex pieces of equipment that take rocket scientists to develop or maintain. According to someone that should know, they are not even as secure as an ATM machine. How fucking sad is that?

    Why, yes, I do have some suggestions. Where is the forum for me to submit them?

  4. Re:That may be... by Jeremiah+Cornelius · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Look.

    These machines are intended and designed to prop-up the parlour-game of democratic basis for American government. They are not meant to "work". They are meant to reduce the definition of "democracy" to merely "voting" for the general public - and then to manage that vote. If they decrease the confidence of a certain segment of the public in the whole process, then they are also serving their secondary purpose: The devolution of the US to Banana Republic status.

    The coup was completed in 2000. The dramatic operations began 40 years earlier, but it took awhile.

    You don't see this. You think you still live in the same country that you were born in, that you attended Elementary School in, that you call the same name.

    But it just isn't true. Visitors to your country get it in a very short time - but most of them clamp their mouths shut - it is quickly apparent that Americans are uncomprehending.

    This isn't just Republicans. Sure - the Republican leaders are the sharp and shiny spear-tip, slicing the American side. The Democrats are just as on board - the solid wooden shaft, following this through the body. The elite of these - Cheney's and Pelosi's - will keep their mansions and their millions, their holidays in Vail and Sun Valley.

    They will never join the people who "voted". That would be to join Dr. King, or Mel Carnahan.

    --
    "Flyin' in just a sweet place,
    Never been known to fail..."