Slashdot Mirror


NC Judge Takes "A Fresh Look" At RIAA Subpoenas

NewYorkCountryLawyer writes "When some North Carolina State students recently brought to the attention of the Court the apparent illegality of the RIAA's investigations by unlicensed investigators, they also caught the attention of the judges. After reading these new papers, District Judge Louise W. Flanagan, who admits that she's been routinely signing the RIAA's ex parte discovery orders in the past, has indicated that she is now going to take 'a fresh look' at the RIAA's tactics. She issued a stay of the subpoena, ordering NC State not to respond to it, and referred the motions to dismiss the cases to a Magistrate Judge for him to take that 'fresh look' at what has been going on."

4 of 86 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Oh well... by arth1 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Unfortunately, I believe their answer to the law not allowing this isn't to change their business methods, but to change the law. Here in the US, this seems to be the easiest and cheapest solutions -- the price of your average politician is too high for individuals but low enough to not make a dent in a corporation's coffers.

    Do us all a favor the coming November -- look up the contributors to your representatives before voting, and strike anyone who has accepted money from the entertainment cartels or their lobbyists.

  2. Re:Good by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Treat these subpoenas like they came from the mafia or a drug cartel. Make them go out of their way to do something crazy, like having proof.

    They have proof*, the issue is whether the proof was legally obtained.

    They have no proof, since it can not be verified it is correct.

    Here credibility enters the stage. Only officers of the police (etc) have sworn the statement to forfill truthfullness.

  3. Good by SilverBlade2k · · Score: 5, Insightful

    About time a judge follows the law instead of following the money.

  4. Re:Hurray for justice! by mrsteveman1 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Actually in the U.S, justice is a whore, she fucks the highest bidder.