Slashdot Mirror
SF Admin Gives Up Keys To Hijacked City Network
snydeq writes "Jailed IT admin Terry Childs relinquished his hold over San Francisco's multimillion-dollar FiberWAN, handing his administrative passwords over to San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom, who was 'the only person he felt he could trust.' Childs is still being held on $5 million bail for his lockout of the city's FiberWAN, a case that has been called into question since an insider came forward with details about both the network and Childs himself. The case hinges on No Service Password Recovery commands Childs allegedly configured onto several Cisco devices, as well as dial-up and DSL modems the SFPD has discovered that would allow unauthorized connections to the FiberWAN. Childs intends to 'expose the utter mismanagement, negligence, and corruption at DTIS, which if left unchecked, will in fact place the City of San Francisco in danger,' according to his motion. The Department of Telecom and IS has cut 200 of its 350 IT positions since 2000 — pressure that may have contributed to Childs' actions, according to interviews with current and former DTIS staffers. Newsom secured the passwords without first telling the DTIS that he was meeting with Childs."
I agree completely.
There seems to be a lot more going on here than what we see.
The conspiracy side of me thinks that there's something fishy going on in the department. He found out and got fired because of it. Except he acted fast and hijacked the network. Hence why he only gave the password to the mayor...
How is not doing your job criminal exactly? Grounds for dismissal, sure, but jail?
"You know, Hobbes, some days even my lucky rocketship underpants don't help" -- Calvin
Anyone having spent that much effort creating a network - and succeeding - would become paranoid and protective of it. I challenge anyone to invest so much in any project and then happily see it messed up by people who are less competent.
However the situation is still messed up, the City should never have allowed one person to take on so much responsibility, and at the first sign that he was becoming indispensable, they should have moved him to another project.
If someone is essential for a project, replace him as soon as you can...
In fact the whole story is a good case study for outsourcing - a small, competent network firm would have done as good a job, and treated the incompetent managers simply as clients, not bosses.
The blame lies squarely with the City, not Childs.
My blog
Let's try this one instead:
You're responsible for maintaining a nuclear reactor. Your manager, who has no idea how to actually runs the reactor comes in and demands to be given all of the necessary keys and passwords to the reactor. The reactor is currently working flawlessly, and there is no obvious reason for your manager to need access to the system.
Do you:
A. realize that this could be very bad for the company, and protect the company by refusing to turn over access to an unqualified person?
B. turn over access to the access to an unqualified person, and just hope that they don't do anything which results in anyone's death, or your working 16hr shifts for the next 3 months straight.
I would argue that choosing "B" could be criminally negligent, and that A is the better choice, however, he should also immediately go to HR and explain why he's violating the order.
In this particular case, he might've saved the city of San Francisco millions of dollars in lost productivity from someone getting access who had no clue what they were doing.
Build it, and they will come^Hplain.
"Your mental illness is not real."
Mine is very real. I doubt you've ever spent 6 months in a hospital trying to tell people that human beings are being infected by a computer virus. (note: the computer virus was real, and i was the only person who could actually get it off the machines, because it was infecting the BIOS and had 'symptoms' like going to the desktop in the middle of a full screen video game, that other people dismissed as being 'real')
To this date, with medication I still am hazy on if computer viruses can infect human beings, on a bad day, i look for malware in every OS on every computer i have, with every tool available to me, including many useful FOSS tools like dban which allows complete erasure of the drive...
"You are the product of a society that is unable to deal with stress and disappointment."
I'll give you that, but you've never gone 6 days unwilling to eat food or drink tap water because it's poisoned, luckily this symptom has been dealt with with medication.
you've probably never hidden in a basement with aluminum covering you to block the mind control waves either. related to this is using a FM radio from the 1980's and 3 cell phones, wrapped in aluminum foil to see if they really block broadcaster waves. While you're still slightly concerned about the type of high energy particles that can go through entire mountains...
"Have you ever looked at mental illness in other countries. It is tiny compared to the USA."
That may be, in a rural environment, telling people about stuff i was worried about every day and shit my family would likely instead of taking me to a doctor, that they couldn't afford would just humor me, and try to keep me eating foods and drinking water. Also, I would likely die at a much younger age, because of the lack of medical treatment overall. Not being treated by doctors is not the same as 'not having mental illness.'
"You embody the problem with the world today. A lack of conviction and discipline that has spread like wildfire."
Except my mental illness is real, my doctor even increased my medicines last week, because he though i was having too many symptoms with just 1 medication.
"Go on with your drug induced normality. You will not be mourned."
If only the drugs actually caused normality. Mine do not, i still have paranoid thoughts ever single day, they're random and unpredictable, and medication only does so much. I don't hear voices, i don't 'see things' that other people don't see, i don't walk around calling people names that i don't recognize, as if i was in a dream, and i don't wind up in a hospital writing notes about everything that i'm worried about thinking that magically if i write it a system administrator of the universe (it's all just a simulation in a computer after all) would be able to deal with the problems if i simply wrote enough notes...
I have 4 boxes of various paperwork including my 'note' writing phase.
you sir, have never been mentally ill so you know not what it is like. you've never been convinced, with you were in a hospital that another mental patient could read your mind, and control you for not looking at the pictures of their family when they asked you nicely to look at the photos.
https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html