Slashdot Mirror
Why Power Failures Can Always Lead To Data Loss
bigsmoke writes "So, all your servers run on RAID. You back up religiously. You're even sure that your backups are recoverable. But do you also need a UPS? According to Halfgaar (on Slashdot before to promote better Linux backup practices), yes, usually you do. He argues that despite technological advancements such as file system journaling, power failures can still cause data loss in most setups."
Power losses can cause data loss? Gee, you mean that my system that relies on electricity for everything it does can be adversely effected by power outages even if I take precautions? That's some good admin work there, Lou -- if only there was some sort of law that covered the tendency of things that can go wrong to go wrong...
Next week: Fires can make things warm, floods can make things wet.
Every year during my review, I just pray the words "slashdot.org" aren't mentioned.
I remember a discussion on the PostgreSQL hacker's list about recoverability and transaction logs.
You can't make a system that will not lose data, you can only make a system that knows the last save point of 100% integrity.
There are too many variables and too much randomness on a cold hard power failure. You absolutely need a UPS that gives you time to shut down cleanly.
The funny part is someone had to have thought they were safe without a UPS for this to become news.
Wanna fight ? Bend over, stick your head up your ass, and fight for air.
In my company, everything is behind UPSs. Our SAN is even behind 2 separate UPSs. We thought everything was configured properly, but you'd be surprised what comes to roost when you test everything.
We recently had a test night where all we did was test the UPS system and shutdown procedures, and there was a couple gotchas. Interestingly, by default the APC powerchute app we were using defaulted to shutting down the UPS completely after the [first] server went down - not good. This was buried fairly deeply in the configuration.
Equally important to any protection measure, be it RAID, Power Protection, whatever - is testing!
I really can't understand people who don't have a UPS. Don't you care about your data? At all? The UPS is not very expensive (My BackUPS 900 is very nice and only $100), and will last a long time (you just replace the batteries now and then). Once you are on UPS, you can stop worrying about any power issues, journalling file systems, crash recovery, and all that. The computer will never fail due to power. If you run Linux, it will also never fail due to the OS. If you are a normal user, that means your computer will never fail, period. Seriously, there is no excuse for not having a UPS. Go and get one right now!
Who the hell is talking about 5 minutes!? I'm saying you should be able to get a clean shutdown in 5 seconds if you prioritize it correctly.
"Prefiero morir de pie que vivir siempre arrodillado!"
Why 5 minutes? It usually takes less than a second to run a sync on the disks depending on how active they are. A couple seconds of runtime should be enough to do an "emergency shutdown" and avoid data corruption.
####@johncash:~$ time sync
real 0m0.004s
user 0m0.004s
sys 0m0.000s
"Knowledge is the only instrument of production that is not subject to diminishing returns" -Journal of Political Econom
If you're not at the machine, or don't know how to shutdown without a CRT, the disk can get messed up when the UPS runs out of power. Unless you only have a desktop machine with no network applications writing to disk (no BitTorrent); then you might be OK if you just walk away from your keyboard and let the system become quiescent before it loses power.