Slashdot Mirror


How Will Recent Financial Downturns Affect IT Jobs?

An anonymous reader writes "So, with the financial crisis and loss of jobs everywhere, what are the chances of getting a good IT job? I'm going to graduate this year with a BS in Software Engineering majoring in Network Security. I'll be looking for a job as a penetration tester eventually, but I hear that is hard to get right out of college so I'll be looking for a job as a Junior Network Admin or similar type of job to start off in. Is there a lack of jobs in this field? I figure computers always need fixing so they have to have some sort of IT personnel on staff to maintain the core of their business. Anyone have a good insight on this issue?"

26 of 372 comments (clear)

  1. Best Advice is to Stand Out by alain94040 · · Score: 5, Informative

    I was a new grad once. It was horrible: it took me 10 months to find my first job.

    I'm sorry to have to be the one to break the bad news to you, but your grades in school don't matter anymore. What recruiters look at is your experience. Which, by definition, you don't have. So your resume ends up at the bottom of the pile.

    As soon as you have some kind of job, then companies are much more willing to take you seriously. It's stupid but it's true. I make the same mistake now when I am the one hiring.

    Now I'm happy to also give you some good news. You're probably not graduating until the summer. That's great. First of all, the economy will be just about to turn around (the media won't tell you, but they also didn't tell you one year ago that we were in a recession). Second, it gives you some time to add experience to your resume: internships matter a lot, volunteer for an open source project, etc.

    Don't have the time? You really have two options: play by university rules and be a bland student, or stand out and go the extra mile. Guess which ones gets the job?

    --
    FairSoftware.net -- the community where software developers start fair businesses

    1. Re:Best Advice is to Stand Out by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

      internship internship internship.
      take a 3 month - 1 year break and do an internship. with a big corp. sometimes you get hired direct from the internship.

    2. Re:Best Advice is to Stand Out by Swizec · · Score: 4, Informative

      I've always found it incredibly stupid for a person to just go to school without doing anything on the side. First time I started working on projects on the side was in first year of high school when I played around with phpBB and later on started working on some of my own stuff. Of course during the summers I've had programming related jobs all through high school, makes sense really since there's heaps of empty time.

      During last year of high school I also started working lightly during regular school months and it's really paid off. Two years into college now and I've already got a few years of real-world experience under my belt. When I get out of college ... whenever that happens ... I'll be far from an empty slate and it thus shouldn't be too difficult getting a job. If all else fails I can just continue working for the people I'm already working for since we seem to be getting along well.

      Seriously, any still-schooling people otu there reading this. GET A FUCKING JOB because grades DO NOT MATTER!

    3. Re:Best Advice is to Stand Out by kaiidth · · Score: 4, Informative

      I'm going to have to third/fourth/fifth (depending on comment lag) the 'Get a job whilst you're still in school, experience counts' viewpoint. It really does help. And if you find yourself jobless even temporarily, make sure you do something with the time. Ideally, that would be the internship that has been mentioned here, but sometimes it'll have to be even less formal than that - this is where networking comes in. Unpaid/very minimally paid work on something isn't as great a CV bullet as an actual job but it is a lot easier to come by. Any connections that you have may come in useful; any college professors/researchers you might know from your university career may be able to provide you with something, although they're less likely to be able to pay you.

      Open source code may arguably count in this, but it's very dependent on what the project is. If I'm hiring I generally look for something that I can find, download and see working. If, like so many projects, it turns out to be an itch that got scratched and then immediately placed on line with no testing or docs, I'd be impressed that it was placed online at all but wouldn't rank it very highly as experience. If on the other hand I can see evidence of what you did during your work on the project I might rank it somewhat higher, assuming HR ever let me see the CV (they have their own viewpoint on what 'experience' means).

      I know this sounds obvious but it's very important to actually get around to applying, to do a little research before the interview, and to turn up to job interviews when the date has been agreed. Last hiring session I went on, only half of the people I invited for interview turned up. One of those who didn't emailed and apologised, so I sent him another interview date that he failed to meet either, which was facepalm-worthy and rather sad... two of those that I did interview hadn't bothered to look up the software packages mentioned by name in the original advert. And that was in the midst of the credit crunch.

      Good luck to the OP and to all in their position, and if you do end up medium to long-term unemployed my advice to you is to keep busy and make sure you keep using your skills and abilities, find something you want to work on - I went back to studying when jobless after the dot-com boom, and one friend of mine wrote a book whilst unemployed! Also, get out of the house on a regular basis, even if it's only to yoga class or something. Unemployment is a nasty state if you let it get you down and is very likely to leave you feeling depressed and worthless (for no good reason - unemployment can happen to anybody), so keep your eyes open for that and find strategies to keep your spirits up.

    4. Re:Best Advice is to Stand Out by arth1 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Unless you have had an employer who works in those fields, your experience will be considered "hobby" and won't count for much, if anything. Every other applicant claims that they run linux servers and advanced networking at home, and have done so for a long time, but very few of them tell the truth. Some claim to have done so for an employer, but won't state references. An interviewer will generally disregard claims like these, unless they can be backed up.

      And yes, these days, interviewers /will/ call your references and check. Saying that you were responsible for X or contributed to Y if you weren't will be a bad move. If it just can't be verified, it's likely a waste of good CV paper.

      To recap, experience will in most cases mean having been employed for doing, and with references to back this up.

    5. Re:Best Advice is to Stand Out by ucblockhead · · Score: 5, Insightful

      That is not true. Speaking as someone who ran a search for employees, I can say categorically that "hobby" work that was interesting, and could be described to an adequate level of detail, directly counted for a couple of people we hired. In one case it was work that wasn't on the resume because "it was just a hobby".

      As an interviewer, I certainly expect claims to be "backed up", but this means that the interviewee can talk in great detail about what exactly they did, not that they have it attached to a job. I've seen far too many resumes that said something like "developed network protocol using C" only to have it turn out that the guy worked on a team of fifty that did that, and all that he actually did himself was read the docs for ten minutes.

      In my mind, hobbies count double, because if someone is doing technical work in their spare time, it shows a deeper interest in technology than someone who does things only for pay.

      --
      The cake is a pie
    6. Re:Best Advice is to Stand Out by Swizec · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Grades only matter if you want to work in academia (be a real scientist). Otherwise grades are only spice on top of your education. Not the other way around.

      Academia jobs, I believe, prefer people without experience because they aren't yet spoiled by the real world, just as corporations and such prefer people with as much experience as possible because they've "forgotten the useless crap from school".

      So really, depends on what you want to do, but working in the real world both pays better and is, to me, more gratifying since you see your creations put to work instead of just being peer-reviewed and if you're lucky at one point adopted by a real-world guy.

    7. Re:Best Advice is to Stand Out by TakeyMcTaker · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I agree with the parent and almost all preceding comments above +3, but I feel the need to clarify a little bit.

      Currently, the merits of higher education in the job field are:

      1. Job listings often specify a particular degree as a MINIMUM requirement. So you got that one.

      2. Completing a degree proves that:
      a. You can fool someone into accepting you into their program based on High School merits, which are universally flimsy.

      b. You can make about 80% of your contrived deadlines, or more.

      c. You took a test on relevant subject matter at some point, so interviewing you shouldn't be a complete waste of time.

      d. Despite dealing with all the complex life questions that come about when leaving home for more than a couple of months, you managed to get something done, or at least fool your professors to their satisfaction.

      e. You got over fending for yourself. Your new employers don't have to act as if they're your new parents.

      3. Job experience you managed to pick up while paying your expenses. Hopefully by now your new employers don't have to show you how to fill out an employment eligibility form, or handle a checkbook.

      4. You meet new school friends, many of whom are smarter than you, who can help you out.

      Anything else your education establishment claims is B.S. Sometimes, really friendly professors that like your work can arrange contacts, especially if they decide to be your mentor. This is rare, because professors can only handle becoming a role model for a small fraction of their students, and usually that's because they are trying to push more undergraduates into higher degree programs, or underpaid academic work in general.

      So your best bet, in general, is to concentrate on item 3. You can also compete on low price/hour.

              If you managed to get all the way through a degree without ANY relevant work experience, that usually means you were a spoiled trust fund baby brat, or at least your parents are rich enough to pay off your major expenses. Such brats usually spend most of their degree program partying, cribbing off their smarter frat/sorority friends, or paying for cash-strapped smart people to do their work for them. Tests can be crammed sufficiently otherwise. In this case, you will be dependent on your Greek friends to arrange for jobs for you, or on nepotism of some form. This latter option also precludes needing to post a question on Slashdot.

    8. Re:Best Advice is to Stand Out by SageMusings · · Score: 4, Interesting

      They will call and all that will be said is that yes you worked there. Short of getting fired and charged with a crime a previous employer will say very little during a reference check.

      Believe it! This is policy where I work. The issue is the organization could be liable for causing an applicant to not get the position they were seeking. In other words, we would probably get sued for saying Bob* was a shitty dev. We will only verify past employment.

      * My apologies to anyone named Bob or Robert.

      --
      -- Posted from my parent's basement
  2. Sorry but... by clickclickdrone · · Score: 4, Informative

    The economy globally has tanked. My firm has just shed *another* 400 IT jobs. I know many people who got made redundant just before Christmas. Firms are collapsing left right and centre and those left are cutting right back to keep afloat.
    Personally,I'd take pretty much any job you can get right now,IT or otherwise. It's not a time to be picky.

    --
    I want a list of atrocities done in your name - Recoil
  3. Experience over education, 7 times out of 10 by dada21 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    As the CEO of a small IT company in the US (mostly Midwest-focused), I'd say we hire more out of experience than education. We're consultants, though, but we have helped hire full timers for our customers who want someone there manning the stations all the time.

    For those in college now, GO INTERN. It doesn't matter how much you make, but how much you can mark up that portfolio. If you're graduating and can't find work, then WORK SOMEWHERE. I can't begin to tell you how many people I've interviewed who are 5-6 months out of college but aren't working anywhere, even Starbucks. The lack of showing responsibility by not doing something is a turn-off.

    For us, business is way up. Clients are keeping their hardware longer, which means more maintenance work. They're getting more focused on information security (external and internal), as well as keeping what they have in tip-top shape. We're turning away work.

    Here's a big part of being a successful IT employee: be mobile. Fully, if possible. Try not to sign any long term leases, and DO NOT BUY property even if mom and dad or the grandfolk offer to get you something. I took on work in LA in 2008 because they couldn't find a decent consultant locally, even paying for my flights and hotel stays. If you're mobile, your chance of getting work goes way up. Once you move, stay mobile-capable if other jobs pop up. Don't just look close to home or close to school, look everywhere.

    One area that is seeing rapid growth is in health care clinics (not big hospitals). I think we field a few calls a month from possible clients who have to maintain a large infrastructure and are sick of high priced consultants. That's when we usually try to place full timers rather than work a contract out in an environment that really needs full time management of IT.

    I personally would stay out of software development if you don't have any real portfolio of work done, but in terms of maintenance, the job market looks pretty reasonable in the 4 markets I monitor. It's just a matter of that dreaded experience that most college graduates have none of. It would be very hard for me to hire someone on degree alone. My last 3 hires didn't even graduate college, but are phenomenal at showing up on time, doing their job right, and giving our clients 150% of themselves when needed.

    1. Re:Experience over education, 7 times out of 10 by entrigant · · Score: 4, Insightful

      The lack of showing responsibility by not doing something is a turn-off.

      I'd be interested to hear the reasoning behind this. How does not working show a lack of responsibility? We work to provide for ourselves. If I have the means to provide for myself without needing a job for an extended period and I choose to take advantage of it to take my time making sure when I do need employment I find some place where I am happy, how does that equate to being irresponsible?

      If I had the means I've never work again. I'd use my time persuing my interests and hobbies. I'd take the time to enjoy life and contribute to society in ways that I enjoy doing.

      Yet I'm irresponsible?

      If I must work under someone else then I might as well make sure I will enjoy what I do, and that will benefit my employer as much as it does me. I don't care if it takes 5 days or 5 months to find such a position.

    2. Re:Experience over education, 7 times out of 10 by fishbowl · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "Here's a big part of being a successful IT employee: be mobile. Fully, if possible."

      Don't buy a house. Don't be active in a local community. Don't make friends. Don't develop local business relationships. Don't get married. Don't have kids. Don't even get pets.

      I don't know how you measure "success."

      On one hand, I *am* willing to do "100%" travel if the compensation is good. (But my travel rate is several times my normal rate.)

      I had to be very harsh with a persistent recruiter who could not understand why I wasn't motivated to relocate to Salt Lake City Utah (from San Diego California). Sometimes "Being mobile" has a cost that I mark very high.

      --
      -fb Everything not expressly forbidden is now mandatory.
  4. As an interviewer I agree by EmbeddedJanitor · · Score: 4, Insightful
    In my last job I, and about 5 others, spent a lot of our time selecting new grads. Of the six of us, only one looked at grades much. We all realised that universities and grades are very contrived and are not good indicators of how people will perform in the real world.

    Get involved in some open source project, not just as a peripheral person but **really** get engaged and make a very useful contribution. Show that you can word with others, solve problems (the fun technical stuff), help finish off documentation (shows you can also do the boring stuff that is important) and get some references from the project leads.

    What most employers really look for is the "bushy tail factor": people who are flexible, practical and can learn new stuff fast.

    --
    Engineering is the art of compromise.
    1. Re:As an interviewer I agree by jez9999 · · Score: 5, Funny

      Show that you can word with others

      Word.

    2. Re:As an interviewer I agree by EastCoastSurfer · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Later I wondered why I had selected this person and realised that he had the worst formatted resume of the lot. This guy can't format a word document. He is a terrible typist. In fact he didn't seem to care how it looked.

      I hope you aren't relying on this hire to manage your backups or do anything else that you deem critical. If his attention to detail is that lax on something that is presumably important to him, imagine how lax it'll be on something that's important to you.

  5. Penetration Tester by Ukab+the+Great · · Score: 4, Funny

    The good news is that there are some companies who'll see "penetration tester" on your resume and immediately hire you.

    The bad news is that many of those jobs will involve creepy bosses and excessive amounts of astroglide.

  6. Pen Test, start with Big 4 or sister companies by Goblygoop · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I worked as a pen tester a couple years ago. Some may not agree, but go for one of the Big 4 accounting firms or their sister companies. The company name is huge on resumes, you learn lots of business stuff. Knowing how to properly document, follow procedures, create repeatable tests is extremely important. You can learn this in both sides, either audit or implementation. I started in implementation. Knowing how to build something makes it much easier to take apart (pen testing). You learn how the technology is implemented and what mistakes are normally made. I went from there to auditing and pen testing. I was immediately the top "tech" star (which was sad), but I didn't know how to properly document. Audit firms are masters of documentation. From there you can jump into full on pen testing. People that don't have a rounded background are not good pen testers IMO. If you are in DC area, you have many options. Audit has sox and fisma, fiscam and a boat load of others.

  7. Re:Paying your dues by pavera · · Score: 5, Insightful

    this is the worst advice on this board.. There is no such thing as "climbing the ladder" multiple studies by economists at Stanford and Harvard have confirmed this. Aim high, get the job you want for the pay you want or stay in school, any other choice will hurt your earnings potential for literally decades to come.

    If you "take whatever you can get" now, you will artificially hurt your earnings potential because generally you will only ever get a cost of living raise and 3-5% of 40k for 20 years puts you way way behind 3-5% of 60 or 70k over 20 years. And unless you can change your career, you won't get a big bump in salary when the economy improves. Even if the economy gets a lot better, they aren't going to suddenly give you a 20 or 30% raise for the same or similar job you've been doing for much less.

  8. Re:not specific to "network admin" by pavera · · Score: 4, Informative

    Uh... how so? The article cited studies by Standford and Harvard economists who studied the lives of graduates during the 80-82 recession the 90-91 recession and the 87 market crash... In all 3 cases graduates of those years significantly under earned graduates with similar degrees from the years immediately surrounding the recession years for example the graduating classes of 78,79, and 83 all earned significantly more over the next 20 years than their peers who graduated during the recession. Same for the market crash in 87, classes of 86 and 88 earned much more over the next 20 years... obviously 20 years haven't elapsed yet on the 91 recession, but the trend is still in place through 15 years graduates of the classes surrounding the recession are much better off.

  9. Follow the pork, Luke by PolygamousRanchKid+ · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Major hiring industries for the next few years, are going to be anyone, directly or indirectly, who receives a slice of the pork pie that the US government will be distributing.

    Follow the news, and prepare applications for any industry that is looking for government money. If the industry gets rebuffed by the government, oh well.

    If an industry gets some pork, send them your applications immediately.

    Good, healthy companies are just going to ride out the next couple of years with the folks that they have, and won't be hiring.

    --
    Schroedinger's Brexit: The UK is both in and out of the EU at the same time!
  10. Bullshit by Samschnooks · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I can't begin to tell you how many people I've interviewed who are 5-6 months out of college but aren't working anywhere, even Starbucks. The lack of showing responsibility by not doing something is a turn-off.

    That's YOUR opinion.

    There are folks who worked their asses off in school and decided to take a break. Which is a good thing because, I don't know about you, I wouldn't want someone who hasn't relaxed a bit; otherwise, they have a tendency to burn out.

    Many of those places won't have anything to do with someone with a BS or higher because they're "over qualified".

    There could be family issues that is none of your business. Just because you're an employer doesn't mean you need to know every little thing about their life.

    That's the trouble with employers these days, they have all of these "shoulds" and "oughts" about what makes a good hire that's based on nothing or worse, experience based on a previous hire or two.

    And the trouble is, if there's the slightest non conforming aspect of someone's work history, they're marked for life. And yet, American business wants folks who "think outside the box". No they don't. Because folks who really do are rejected out of hand because "they're irresponsible" or some other asinine label.

  11. I Just Graduated by kevination · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Hey, don't worry too much. I just graduated in December from Michigan Technological University with a 3.1, packed up a U-Haul, and moved out to NYC without a job offer. No one's heard of MTU out here, but within a week I had two really good offers, and got my salary up pretty high by having the two companies fight for me. I had two summer internships, I was the GM of a student group, and I had a student job at the sys admin place on campus. Anyway, it's not so bad. I highly recommend you pick a place that you want to live (and that has a decent local economy), move there, and start pounding the pavement. I spent 3 months applying for jobs in NYC from Michigan, and it was essentially useless. Once you're local, you're golden. Good luck!

  12. People hire People by persaud · · Score: 4, Informative

    1. Experience: self-educate in an emerging technology in your chosen field. You have the advantage of being unbiased to legacy practices. With an emerging technology, no one has experience. In today's world of cheap hardware and open-source software, it has never been easier for motivated people to find a way to contribute. Treat the learning process as an extended interview, including your project emails and contributions.

    2. People: you're already at the bottom, nowhere to go but up. Don't further handicap yourself with low expectations, reality will be happy to reduce your expectations for you. Aim as high as you can imagine and work down as necessary. Rank the top ten companies or organizations (globally) with people who are experts in your chosen field. Identify some of these people by name and learn about their career path and current projects. Find a way to contribute to similar projects. Work backwards from their social network to your social network and try to have F2F conversations with local contacts who are best-of-breed.

    3. Budgets: use your F2F contacts to obtain intelligence on budgets. In a poor economy with layoffs, the remaining people often have too much work to handle. Creative volunteering and compensation ideas can get you involved in real-world projects where the experience is worth 10X the dollar value comp. It all starts and ends with people, be they HR, managers or customers. So focus on being useful and building relationships with people. The most valuable information is often very transient (e.g. time sensitive hiring opportunities) and communicated only by word of mouth.

    4. Recession: some of the best engineering creations have come from highly constrained environments. If you can be successful in an environment of fiscal discipline, you will only be more successful when boom times return. The same cannot be said for those who begin careers in boom times and are shocked by their first major downturn. There is no better time to start working than now. It doesn't mean you'll find a job quickly, but you will learn much more than by staying in school (which also costs money, even if deferred).

    10 years from now, business schools will have course material dedicated to the lessons of these unprecedented economic times. New grads have a once-in-a-generation opportunity to experience the kind of business environment where fortunes will be lost and won, as economic hierarchies adjust. Don't miss the excitement by hiding in school!

  13. Re:Bullshit-"behavioral interviewing" by plasmacutter · · Score: 4, Insightful

    And the trouble is, if there's the slightest non conforming aspect of someone's work history, they're marked for life. And yet, American business wants folks who "think outside the box". No they don't. Because folks who really do are rejected out of hand because "they're irresponsible" or some other asinine label.

    I'd like to point out "behavioral interviewing" and "personality tests" in this category too.

    There are federal laws banning the use of polygraphs in interviews, but this type of thing is VERY similar.

    I'm a pessimist and an introvert. This does NOT interfere with my ability to put on a professional face and be friendly to clients, but it does cause a great deal of stress when a potential job is at stake. Further, being a pessimist, while many people frown on it, has many positive qualities in a work environment, such as a propensity to properly assess and prepare for likely hurdles on a project.

    This doesn't matter though, as the slightest sign of discomfort is construed as some kind of black mark.

    The academic equivalent would be someone being passed up who knows their stuff but doesn't test well, while an incompetent who's good at telling people what they want to hear gets top marks.

    What really irks me though is when people give you tests or as questions on internal company policy. These are things you should be told in your training or in your interview by the HR staff; you should not be chucked out of the hire process because you are being forced to guess and you guessed wrong.

    --
    VLC FOR MAC IS DYING! IF YOU DEVELOP, PLEASE SAVE IT!!
  14. Re:Bullshit-"behavioral interviewing" by tengu1sd · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I prefer to think of myself as an optimistic pessimist. I see failure modes in systems and procedures. Part of my present role is to document and train in possible solutions.

    With that being said, one problem I've faced in the past was never being seen as taking problems seriously. $WIDGET is down, everyone else is shouting, don't you appreciate the problem. Gee, I understand the problem, wrote the chapter on how to resolve it, and can give you a planning estimate (which is always longer than my internal estimate). I'm not freaking out because I don't feel the need to put on a show.

    Oh by the way, when $SYSTEM was planned out, the stakeholders decided redundancy was too expensive. Would you like to review that decision? Learning to say that politely is still something that I have to approach carefully.