Slashdot Mirror


Halo 3 Criticized In Murder Conviction

oldwindways writes "An Ohio teen was found guilty of murdering his mother and shooting his father in the head after they took away his copy of Halo 3. One has to wonder if this is going to have any effect on the games industry. Clearly, the AP thought they could stir up something controversial by asking the IP owner for a statement: 'Microsoft, which owns the intellectual property for the game, declined to comment beyond a statement saying: "We are aware of the situation and it is a tragic case."' I suppose the good news is they did not accept his insanity plea, so no one can claim that Halo 3 drove him insane. Even so, I don't think anything good can come out of this for gamers." Unfortunately, it seems somebody can claim that the game was a contributing factor; the judge who presided over this case said he believes that the 17-year-old defendant "had no idea at the time he hatched this plot that if he killed his parents, they would be dead forever." GamePolitics has further details from the judge's statement. It doesn't help that the boy's lawyers used video game addiction as a defense.

4 of 839 comments (clear)

  1. Christian Killers: Blame Christianity? by MRe_nl · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    There is no doubt that many of the soldiers responsible for the recent death and destruction in Fallujah are Christians. And there is no doubt that many Americans who call for more death and destruction in Iraq and elsewhere are Christians as well. Christian Killers.

    The phrase should be a contradiction in terms. If someone referred to Christian adulterers, Christian drug addicts, Christian prostitutes, Christian pimps, Christian gangsta rappers, or Christian acid rockers, most Christians would get an extremely perplexed look on their face. But when Christians in the military continue killing for the state, and Christians not in the military call for more killing in the name of the state, many Christians don't even raise an eyebrow.

    In some respects, this is the fault of religious "leaders." Christians in the pew are in many cases just blindly following their pastors, priests, elders, and ministers who, instead of preaching the gospel, are preaching the same pro-war politics their congregation hears on the Sean Hannity radio show or else they are not denouncing the debacle in Iraq for what it is: unscriptural, immoral, and unconstitutional. Conservative religious leaders are in some cases nothing more than cheerleaders for George Bush and the Republican Party.

    But even if a Christian hears nothing but pro-war propaganda from the pulpit, it is still no excuse, for Christians have access to the truth if they will just put forth the effort to look for it. They have a Bible they can read for themselves. They have the example of some principled Christian leaders who have opposed the debacle in Iraq from the beginning. They have an abundance of alternative news sources to receive information from besides the pro-war propaganda they get from the Fox War Channel and the War Street Journal. It is unfortunate that some Christians won't read anything unless it was written by some other Christian they know and usually agree with. God forbid that they should read something by someone outside of their denomination, circle, or "camp" - or even worse, someone they consider to be a nominal Christian or not a Christian at all.

    To justify their consent or silence, and to keep their congregations in line, Christian leaders repeat to their parishioners the mantra of "obey the powers that be," a loose paraphrase of Romans 13:1, as if that somehow means that they should blindly follow whatever the president or the government says, and even worse, that it overturns the commandment "Thou shalt not kill" (Exodus 20:13; Deuteronomy 5:17), which is repeated in the New Testament (Matthew 19:18; Romans 13:9). The way some Christians repeat the "obey the powers that be" mantra, one would think that they would slit their own mothers' throats if the state told them to do so.

    No one, Christian or otherwise, would fault a man for killing another man in self-defense. Only the most diehard pacifist would refuse to act in self-defense if he was attacked. This would have to include the protection of one's family as well.
    Accidents happen. And sometimes someone is tragically killed. This does not make the perpetrator a murderer.

    Most Christians would wholeheartedly agree with these first two propositions. The problem is with war; specifically, the fact that all wars are not created equal. The vast majority of wars in the world's history have been destructive, unjust, and immoral.
    Obviously, an aggressive, preemptive war against a country with no navy or air force, an economy in ruins after a decade of sanctions, and that was no threat to the United States is not a just war.

    A Christian fighting for the U.S. Government in Iraq doesn't fall under any of these circumstances.

    After Bush launched his nebulous "war on terrorism" by having Afghanistan bombed back to the Stone Age to supposedly rid the world of Osama bin Laden, al-Qaeda, and the Taliban, he announced to the world his "axis of evil" and went to war against Iraq to, depending on what day it was, rid the world of the evil Saddam Hussein or because

    --
    "Kill 'em all and let Root sort 'em out"
    1. Re:Christian Killers: Blame Christianity? by Shakrai · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      In some respects, this is the fault of religious "leaders." Christians in the pew are in many cases just blindly following their pastors, priests, elders, and ministers who, instead of preaching the gospel, are preaching the same pro-war politics their congregation hears on the Sean Hannity radio show or else they are not denouncing the debacle in Iraq for what it is

      Yeah, there isn't a single member of the religious community that's denounced the Iraq War. And the 50-some percent of the American population that's opposed to the war is entirely made up of Atheists as well.

      Obviously, an aggressive, preemptive war against a country with no navy or air force, an economy in ruins after a decade of sanctions, and that was no threat to the United States is not a just war.

      You left out the part about the leader of that country oppressing 2/3'rds of his population and killing his own people with poison gas. Mind you I'm not convinced that's sufficient reason for the US to get involved but at least try and tell the whole story.

      A Christian fighting for the U.S. Government in Iraq doesn't fall under any of these circumstances.

      Most soldiers would tell you that they are soldiers first and Christians second. You follow the orders of your Commander-in-Chief and here's a hint: His name isn't Jesus.

      After Bush launched his nebulous "war on terrorism" by having Afghanistan bombed back to the Stone Age

      Afghanistan was already in the Stone Age. Perhaps you forgot the part where the Government of Afghanistan harbored the man who murdered thousands of Americans and refused to hand him over to face justice?

      Christians who support or remain silent about Bush's "war against terrorism" are terribly inconsistent

      Wow, religious people aren't always consistent. Do you want a +5 for that insightful observation?

      The fact that the president himself never killed anyone is irrelevant - Adolf Hitler never gassed a single Jew.

      I'm surprised you managed to go 10 paragraphs without Godwin'ing yourself....

      that it is honorable for Christians to enthusiastically participate in U.S. wars of aggression

      Wars of aggression? Afghanistan is a war of aggression? Hmmph.

      --
      I want peace on earth and goodwill toward man.
      We are the United States Government! We don't do that sort of thing.
    2. Re:Christian Killers: Blame Christianity? by filthpickle · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      I know, also see the resonable answer below his that got modded flamebait. Bad form mods, bad form.

    3. Re:Christian Killers: Blame Christianity? by Shakrai · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      Your contributions were most illuminating.

      I hope they were as illuminating as your flamebait'ish sig

      --
      I want peace on earth and goodwill toward man.
      We are the United States Government! We don't do that sort of thing.