Slashdot Mirror


Ubuntu Download Speeds Beat Windows XP's

narramissic writes "Doing a download speed test of his Time Warner cable connection, James Gaskin discovered something odd, something that he is quick to note isn't a rigorous benchmarked lab test. The discovery: His Ubuntu machine 'returned a rating from the Bandwidth.com test of 22-25mbps over several tests' while the same test done from a Windows XP PC returned a rating of 12-14mbps. The two computers used in the test are 'almost identical: both off-lease Compaq small form factor D515s, part of the very popular corporate desktop D500 family. Both have Pentium 4 processors running at 2GHz. The Ubuntu machine has 768MB of RAM, while the XP box has only 512MB of RAM. Both run Firefox 3 as their browser.' Gaskin's question: Can a little extra RAM make that much difference in Internet download speeds or does Ubuntu handles networking that much faster than Windows XP?"

3 of 515 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Even if the answer is no... by Hairy+Heron · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    And just to further add, I've already stated this whole test is full of shit. My parents have a XP box with 512 megs of RAM that is running all sorts of bullshit crap all the time (cause they think they need all manor of crap running on the systray) and they max out their 22mbps cable connection. It's just hilarious to see all the stupid "BUT IT HAD MORE MEMORY!!" comebacks to try to invalidate this idiotic "test" from the article.

  2. Re:Even if the answer is no... by no-body · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Try to understand: http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=cynical
    If you would, your post would have been superfluous.

  3. Re:Linux on the desktop by ravenshrike · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    If you use redtube for anything other than making fun of the really weird shit, you're not only cheap, but you can't navigate the intertubes properly and settle for low quality free pron.