Slashdot Mirror


Oslo Buses to Run on Sewage

Mike writes "Rather than let their sewage go to waste, the city of Oslo recently announced that it plans to cut carbon emissions by converting 80 public buses to run on biomethane generated from raw sewage. The city plans to adapt two sewage plans with the technology this September, and the new biogas buses will be quieter and will cut 44 tones of C02 per bus per year."

68 comments

  1. No, they run on the big bang! by QuantumG · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I mean, if you're going to claim that something runs on X because you put Y into it and you get Y from X, then you might as well extend it back as far as possible.

    Morons.

    --
    How we know is more important than what we know.
    1. Re:No, they run on the big bang! by wisty · · Score: 4, Funny

      Let's just take it back one step. Oslo buses to run on people!

    2. Re:No, they run on the big bang! by muffen · · Score: 1

      I mean, if you're going to claim that something runs on X because you put Y into it and you get Y from X, then you might as well extend it back as far as possible. Morons.

      ... in this case it makes complete sense because driving behind one of them smells like shit!

    3. Re:No, they run on the big bang! by MarkRose · · Score: 1

      Oslo buses to run on people!

      I do suppose that's much better than running over people!

      --
      Be relentless!
    4. Re:No, they run on the big bang! by Hognoxious · · Score: 1

      It's as if Roland never passed away.

      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
  2. Cut out the middle man... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    ... and put the toilet right on the bus!

    1. Re:Cut out the middle man... by johnm76 · · Score: 1

      Fart'n'Go? Or rather Bring'yer-own-kind-of-rebate?

    2. Re:Cut out the middle man... by ardor · · Score: 1

      Upon entering the bus, passengers have two options: pay for a ticket, or start eating beans and provide fuel for the vehicle. Don't forget to lift the lid, sir, we don't want to make a mess, do we?

      --
      This sig does not contain any SCO code.
  3. A Few Days are all we have, so count them as they by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Gives new meaning to the verse "Buses farting up the street" in James Schuyler's legendary poem, A Few Days.

  4. LAMP-POO! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Linux, MySQL, PHP, Apache and POOP

    PS - I AM NO COWARD

  5. Smelly by sneilan · · Score: 0, Redundant

    So that's where all my farts go. Into the bus. And I thought it was homeless people that made buses smell!

    --
    "I like it when the red water comes out.."
    1. Re:Smelly by pushing-robot · · Score: 5, Interesting

      It's fortunate that methane is odorless, then.

      It's always good to see methane captured and burned into carbon dioxide, since CH4 (methane) is a far stronger greenhouse gas than CO2. On top of that, you can do useful work with the energy—like power a bus fleet—which saves even more carbon emissions.

      --
      How can I believe you when you tell me what I don't want to hear?
    2. Re:Smelly by thetsguy · · Score: 0

      Well, Now you know what to do when the bus runs out of fuel.

    3. Re:Smelly by slackbheep · · Score: 1

      Hope you're near a dairy farm? :o

  6. Original link by RockMFR · · Score: 5, Informative

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/blog/2009/jan/27/biomethane-energy

    For now on, every time a Slashdot editor posts a link that isn't the original source of the story, I'll be posting the original link.

    1. Re:Original link by MichaelSmith · · Score: 2, Funny

      For now on, every time a Slashdot editor posts a link that isn't the original source of the story, I'll be posting the original link.

      Bless you my son.

    2. Re:Original link by SupremoMan · · Score: 4, Funny

      For now on, every time a Slashdot editor posts a link that isn't the original source of the story, I'll be posting the original link.

      Good for us that Slashdot does not have a post count. Otherwise you would initiate integer overflow in no time.

    3. Re:Original link by ag0ny · · Score: 2, Insightful

      For now on, every time a Slashdot editor posts a link that isn't the original source of the story, I'll be posting the original link.

      So are you quitting your job in order to focus on this full-time?

      Thanks for your sacrifice!

    4. Re:Original link by Hognoxious · · Score: 2, Funny

      Perhaps his job quit him? There's a lot of it about.

      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
    5. Re:Original link by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      http://www.tu.no/natur/article129664.ece :P

    6. Re:Original link by TapeCutter · · Score: 1

      Hmmm, "Original Link", someone will get that a username in 10, 9, 8,...

      --
      And did you exchange a walk on part in the war for a lead role in a cage? - Pink Floyd.
    7. Re:Original link by daveime · · Score: 1

      I heard a sound like a thousand slashdot editors crying "fr33 st00f pl0x", and then were suddenly silenced.

      Who's going to give them freebies for promoting their latest crap as news stories now ? I suppose they can all just go and live in your basement eh ?

      That's the trouble with do-gooders, they never think things through ... shakes head.

    8. Re:Original link by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And that's with 64 bit unsigned integers.

    9. Re:Original link by OriginalLink · · Score: 1

      It was worth it!

    10. Re:Original link by dkleinsc · · Score: 1

      How do you know he's from Russia?

      --
      I am officially gone from /. Long live http://www.soylentnews.com/
    11. Re:Original link by Hognoxious · · Score: 1

      He told an old Korean, the old Korean told a robot, and you know how information wants to be free - it didn't even need a UK civil servant to leave a disk on a train, though I'm sure one did at some point.

      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
    12. Re:Original link by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Good for us that Slashdot does not have a post count.

      It used to, until the new abomination of a userpage came out.

    13. Re:Original link by AtariEric · · Score: 1

      So, how's Hyrule?

      --
      Don't trust any concentration of power.
  7. I cut tones by releasing methane too. by pitterpatter · · Score: 5, Funny

    "the new biogas buses will be quieter and will cut 44 tones of C02 per bus per year."

  8. Good! by haeger · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I just can't get why this isn't used more than it is. I don't understand why we need to base the whole worlds economy on a few countries in the middle east with a democratic defecit.

    Ethanol isn't bad but it does use land that could be used to produce food to grow fuel instead, which seems like a bit of a waste to me. Also the environmental benefits are questionable, I still believe this is better than oil, just not by much.

    But methane is something that we all produce. Humans and animals alike. And methane is a very potent greenhouse gas so setting it on fire is actually a net gain for the environment (according to some), and it can be produced locally.

    So it should be used more. It has a lot of benefits and very few drawbacks. Now if we could only get cars that would run on it properly and not those petrol-converted-dont-really-want-to-run-on-biomethane-but-will-do-so-for-20km-on-a-full-tank kind of cars.

    --
    You are not entitled to your opinion. You are entitled to your informed opinion. -- Harlan Ellison
    1. Re:Good! by MichaelSmith · · Score: 1

      Waste won't give us enough methane to replace oil, but we can make methane directly from water, sunlight and CO2 so maybe that will be done in the long term.

    2. Re:Good! by sumdumass · · Score: 2, Informative

      $$$$$$ is why.

      It costs more money to harvest it and make it usable. Plus storage and transportation bugs have been worked out of the petroleum industry.

    3. Re:Good! by KnightNavro · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Transportation is the usual methane capture project killer. Landfills and wastewater treatment plants are typically located away from densely populated regions, for reasons apparent to anybody who's ever been downwind of one. As such, there typically isn't as well developed as it would have to be to make a project work.

      There are, of course, exceptions. Puente Hills Landfill in LA can generate 50MW. A more typical landfill can generate only a fraction of that.

    4. Re:Good! by Error27 · · Score: 1

      From the guardian article, they're projecting that biogas will be cheaper.

      "What's more, aside from the intial set-up costs, we expect to see an average saving of 0.40 per litre of fuel (based on an average diesel price of 0.67 per litre compared with biomethane at 0.27 per litre)".

      Of course, 200 buses is quite a small scale operation, but it's still very cool.

    5. Re:Good! by eennaarbrak · · Score: 1

      Ironically, Norway is a large exporter of oil (about 20% of GDP is oil/gas export). So while this token programme should be applauded, perhaps they could look at reducing how they help choking the rest of the world too?

    6. Re:Good! by sumdumass · · Score: 1

      Yea it's pretty cool but I think the scale is where the costs come into play. Also, you have to keep in minds some things about estimates -they are often optimistic in order to justify their goals.

      At one time, it was estimated that Ethanol would be cheaper then gasoline until the practical reality of it set in and they applied the same taxes to it. Currently, gasoline in the US is almost cheaper then ethanol in raw numbers compared at the pump. This means that when you take into account the differences in fuel efficiencies for most cars, ethanol of now more expensive the gasoline because it takes more to do the same work.

      So they are comparing the production cost of biomethane to the actual of diesel to them. This is most likely the pump cost meaning that they might turn around and find themselves in the same troubles as the french fry grease diesel people do when government wasn't their taxes.

  9. Old News by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    around the corner, we have a funicular powered by raw sewage (scroll down a bit). It's been in operation since 1899.

    So no, sewage-powered public transport is nothing new, and those Norwegians would know that if they ever left the Fjord.

    Word of advice to our cousins to the North: after a century of operation, it doesn't smell any better.

    1. Re:Old News by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So something is rotten in the state of Norway *and* the state of Switzerland?

    2. Re:Old News by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      For the record, the original (norwegian) article doesn't say anything about "first".
      The english article linked above contains an interview where they refer to earlier projects like this.
      The slashdot summary doesn't say anything about "first".

      In other words: No one ever said they were first ... until you came along.

  10. Not really new tech. by Z00L00K · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Gas-driven (not gasoline) buses has been around for at least a decade. It's just that they use a different type of gas.

    --
    If builders built buildings the way programmers wrote programs, then the first woodpecker would destroy civilization.
    1. Re:Not really new tech. by MichaelSmith · · Score: 2, Informative

      Gas-driven (not gasoline) buses has been around for at least a decade. It's just that they use a different type of gas.

      Do you mean to say that methane driven buses haven't bee used up to now? I know for a fact they are used in Sydney and Melbourne though the CH4 comes out of the ground.

  11. My Voluntary contribution by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Where can I send my voluntary contribution?.

  12. Old school by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    LinkÃping in Sweden has driven their fleet of buses on sewage biogas since 1996 or so.

  13. This was just the obvious next step by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    As if the public transportation system in Oslo wasn't shitty enough!

  14. Substitute by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Could it be that Oslo can afford an expensive but green system like this because Norway has an enormous income from the export of oil and gas taken from the sea bed ?

  15. ive a new bus design by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    it has a sliding toilet seat right under you so you can s##t, and help power the bus, of course you ned to bring your own toilet paper and it will have a tiny sink so you can wash up after.
    HAHA

  16. I'm not impressed... by Genda · · Score: 3, Funny

    American television has been running on crap since the late 50s.

    1. Re:I'm not impressed... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      so.
      true.

  17. hydrogen and electricity, baby by amn108 · · Score: 2, Informative

    Exciting times. In my opinion electrical motor is the way to go though. The problem is the potential energy around us is not available as electrical power by itself, the latter needs to be produced and also stored. Which is where photovoltaics come in - given that Earth is radiated with about 50 - 250 watts of energy per square meter of land, our sun will give us all the power for electricity we need, even with our suboptimal solar panels of today. There is also hydrogen, the most abundand stuff in the Universe, and progress is being made there as well. The problem is our economy. Which slowly has to adjust, and that takes time. It takes time before the folks that profit from oil recovery collect enough money for their pension, and leave something for their sons and daughters and finally lay off that "gold mine" which is killing us slowly, and it takes time to collect the guts to start investing in something new and divorce our economy from oil, so that it does not collapse all too fast when oil is finally left alone where it rested for millions of years. It takes time to change the public perception of transport and consumption and the culture associated with it too. Speaking of the whatever non-scientific reasons for the slow change towards cleaner future, George Monbiots book "Heat" is a good read.

    And just for some food for thought, Oslo where I happen to live, has bought two THiNK cars last year, the company behind these cars had to loan money from the government to make it to 2009. What I am trying to say is the mass of people is the last element you need to convince, and only after everything else is in place, do they start to think about alternatives to their combustion engine cars. And Oslo folks are really stubborn. They will not give up their family wagons all too easily or hastily.

    1. Re:hydrogen and electricity, baby by kvezach · · Score: 1

      Storing hydrogen is a pain. How about that wonder metal (metal?) discussed in another article, Boron?

  18. Mad Max by Randy+Savage · · Score: 1

    If this is possible, then why was petrol such an issue in (the rather disappointing) Beyond Thunderdome?

  19. asdf by zaunuz · · Score: 1

    .......just when i thought Oslo couldn't become a shittier place to live (i'm half serious, hate that placE)

    --
    this is probably the most boring sig in the world
  20. Nothing new by captainpanic · · Score: 1

    Both the technology to use sewage for bio-methane and methane burning cars are not new.

    The bio-methane production is called anaerobic digestion, check wikipedia for more info:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anaerobic_digestion

    Although I applaud every initiative, this is not news.

  21. Smell by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Well the bus shouldn't smell any different.

  22. Interesting... by Bob-taro · · Score: 1

    ... I wonder how much methane I could collect from my septic tank?

    --
    Prov 9:8 Do not rebuke mockers or they will hate you; rebuke the wise and they will love you.
    1. Re:Interesting... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you would have to heat your septic tank to about 100F, and increase your % solids and lower your liquid content. But in the end, if it was just you and your family (assuming three other people), the amount of methane you would produce would be so insignificant, its not worth your while.

      To make it begin to be worth your while, 100,000 people would need their sewage pumped into your septic tank, but only the solids (which is .1% of the total flow).

  23. Storage and transportation by phorm · · Score: 1

    Petroleum has to be harvested from the ground in viable locations and then transported (sometimes long distances) to the end-user

    Methane-related gas, however, is produced pretty much everywhere, and is pretty damn local.

    While it might not be solved by a "porta-pottie at the bus-stop", it's not that far-off to think that individual cities could have a waste reprocessing plant locally, cutting out a lot of the transportation costs. At that point the main cost is the plant, but hopefully one that would pay for itself.

  24. Landfills, plants, and refineries by phorm · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Yes, but oil-drilling rigs and refineries are often located even farther away, yet gas still get in from them...

  25. Literally by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Biomethane is the shit!

  26. "Biomethane" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is nothing new. I work at a sewage treatment plant, and granted we don't use this "biomethane" just because don't use digesters to capture it.

    In treatment plants that do have digesters, they capture the methane and use it to run their power generators. Look at Hyperion Treatment Plant in LA.

    In the end, I say congrats to Oslo for doing something with the sh*t that their population produces, but there is much more to this equation that they could also be doing, but that is topic for another day.

  27. Whew! by Locke2005 · · Score: 1

    Man, and I thought it sucked to be stuck behind a bus before! Who could have predicted that all those experiments my Norwegian friends did with lighting farts when they were younger would actually lead to a viable energy source?

    --
    I've abandoned my search for truth; now I'm just looking for some useful delusions.
  28. Public Transportation: It's the shit! by Niris · · Score: 1

    And I thought the bus system here in Fresno was shitty.

  29. Little Oslo is a planet of it's own Re:asdf by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Please feel free to leave (or stay away) if you don't like it here.

    Rough translation in italics. YouTube clip

    Artist: Delillos
    Song: Suser avgårde

    Det er grålysning og ikke en lyd i byen
    Og jeg er på vei hjem, til en oppredd seng
    Lille Oslo er en egen planet
    Alle gatene er forskjellige land
    Hvert strÃk en verdensdel
    Og vi suser avgårde, alle mann

    It is twilight and not a sound in town
    And I'm on my way home, to a ready-made bed
    Little Oslo is a planet of it's own
    Every street a different country
    Each hood a continent
    And we're speeding about, every one

    Og jeg er ganske full
    Og jeg gÃ¥r midt i bygdÃy allé
    Og mitt eneste mål er å komme hjem og sove
    Men fÃr jeg gjÃr det
    Er jeg nÃdt til Ã¥ se
    At solen kommer og at et menneske står opp
    Da er jeg trygg, da kan jeg sove godt hele da'n

    And I am pretty drunk
    And I walk in the middle of bygdÃy allé
    And my only goal is to get home and sleep
    But before I do that
    I need to see
    The sun rising and somebody waking up
    Then I'll feel secure, and I'll sleep well all day long

    Men kanskje blir jeg vekket av en fly alarm
    Selv om det bare er en test, sÃ¥ gjÃr den meg helt kvalm
    LÃper opp og skrur pÃ¥ radio'n hver gang

    But perhaps I'll be awoken by an air raid siren
    Even if it's just another test it makes me ill at ease
    I run and turn on the radio each time

    Det er grålysning og ikke en lyd i byen
    Og jeg er på vei hjem til en oppredd seng
    Lille Oslo er en egen planet
    Alle gatene er forskjellige land
    Hvert strÃk en verdensdel
    Og vi suser avgårde, alle mann

    It is twilight and not a sound in town
    And I'm on my way home, to a ready-made bed
    Little Oslo is a planet of it's own
    Every street a different country
    Each hood a continent
    And we're speeding about, every one

    Yeeeah - Yeah
    Yeeeeeah - Yeah
    Yeah - Yeah

    Suser avgårde, alle mann

    Speeding about, every one

    Yeeeah - Yeeah
    Yeeeah - Yeeah
    Yeeeah - Yeeah

    Suser avgårde, suser avgårde... alle mann

    Speeding about, speeding about... every one

  30. it's C OH 2, not C ZERO 2 by kayditty · · Score: 0

    I don't know anything about chemistry, but you'd think that someone seemingly interested in it (as the submitter presumably is) would know at least this. I'm also surprised that I'm the first to point this out!!1two

  31. Feedback loop? by GWBasic · · Score: 1

    The net emissions from a biomethane operated bus are zero, because the carbon originally came from the atmosphere rather than fossil fuels, but electricity is used at the sewage plant to convert the gas from the waste into fuel for the buses. Oslo city council is taking the electricity used to generate the fuel into consideration and calculate that carbon emissions per bus are 18 tonnes per year, a saving of 44 tonnes of C02 per bus per year.

    Why not generate electricity from the Biogas? If it's so easy to modify a diesel engine to use the gas, couldn't they just use an ordinary diesel generator?