Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

UK Can't Read Its Own ID Cards

Posted by samzenpus on from the forest-for-the-trees dept.

An anonymous reader writes "Despite the introduction of ID cards last November, it has emerged that Britain has no readers that are able to read the cards' microchips, which contain the person's fingerprints and other biometric information. With cops and border guards unable to use the cards to check a person's identity, critics are calling the £4.7bn scheme 'farcical' and a 'waste of time.'"

6 of 205 comments (clear)

  1. No readers? No surprise! by IBBoard · · Score: 4, Insightful

    While I won't go as far as being paranoid about "it was always the governments plan and they just want the data on everyone", it doesn't surprise me that our government isn't even capable of introducing both halves of an ID scheme at the same time.

    Until they fix it they've basically just introduced an over-expensive photo ID. Well done, Labour!

    1. Re:No readers? No surprise! by segedunum · · Score: 4, Insightful

      While I won't go as far as being paranoid about "it was always the governments plan and they just want the data on everyone", it doesn't surprise me that our government isn't even capable of introducing both halves of an ID scheme at the same time.

      I'm even more cynical than that. While the government will probably get some data on people, judging from other such projects that have gone before it will be extremely poorly coordinated and it will be a far bigger security risk than anything else because they won't be able to keep a lid on the data. It just strikes me that a lot of companies have got cosy with the government, promising them things that are almost certainly not going to work in order to fleece them of billions of pounds. Billions of borrowed pounds in the current climate, that is.

  2. Re:Look at Belgium by AlXtreme · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Stop making fun at Belgium and follow in their food steps.

    *puts mayonnaise on his fries*

    Joking aside, it seems like the Belgians have done this right: You need a code to access the information from the passport, similar to your bank/creditcard. Not perfect, but at least it isn't readable by everyone.

    --
    This sig is intentionally left blank
  3. Re:Where exactly are these cards? by u38cg · · Score: 4, Insightful

    No, you can get one if you want one, and certain classes of people have to have them - asylum seekers, airport workers, and a few other categories. Perhaps gypsies and jews should be added to the list, *sigh*.

    --
    [FUCK BETA]
  4. Why is this news? by DavidR1991 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    They've only just started finalising and using these cards. Why is it surprising that there are no readers around?

    It's akin to saying that Blu-Ray or DVDs were a waste of time because initially there were no players for them - Hello, you need to wait for people to catch up, especially if the equipment is expensive (and although they're not consumer products, the same rules apply - places need to wait for grants or work out their budgets before buying or using said machines).

    Besides, practically no-one has these cards yet - and I doubt anyone will for a while, especially since they cost cash to get (It was ~£50 last I heard)

  5. Re:privacy by Hyppy · · Score: 4, Insightful

    How exactly does "an ID program that works" eliminate all crime?