In Defense of the Anonymous Commenter

Hugh Pickens writes "Doug Feaver has an interesting story in the Washington Post 'in defense of the anonymous, unmoderated, often appallingly inaccurate, sometimes profane, frequently off point and occasionally racist reader comments that washingtonpost.com allows to be published at the end of articles and blogs.' Feaver says that during his seven-year tenure as editor and executive editor of washingtonpost.com he kept un-moderated comments off the site, but now, four years after retiring, he says he has come to think that online comments are a terrific addition to the conversation, and that journalists need to take them seriously. 'The subjects that have generated the most vitriol during my tenure in this role are race and immigration,' writes Feaver. 'But I am heartened by the fact that such comments do not go unchallenged by readers. In fact, comment strings are often self-correcting and provide informative exchanges.' Feaver says that comments are also a pretty good political survey. 'The first day it became clear that a federal bailout of Wall Street was a real prospect, the comments on the main story were almost 100 percent negative. It was a great predictor of how folks feel, well out in front of the polls. We journalists need to pay attention to what our readers say, even if we don't like it. There are things to learn.'"

Comments

Re:The non-value of First Post

[HexOxide]

I'm sorry, but I am finding it really hard to see how you could confuse:

"There is no value in 'First Post!'"

for:

"The first post has no value."

Re:I disagree

[Snark365]

As I Canadian I could I have to agree entirely on the libel issue. We're the libel chill capital of the world. Personaly I believe that the only way for newspapers to prosper is to abandon the idea of making a prophet. Publicly funded organizations such as my own native CBC are--in my opinion--the optimal may to report news. NOTE: Any Canadian can tell you that the CBC is absolutely dreadfull but I personaly believe that this is the result of them being forced by the government to compete with private companies for ad revenue.

Re:I disagree

[Kjella]

I comment on stuff, even if i think my comments aren't up to par with the editorials,

Your sense of humility and modesty is excessive.