Slashdot Mirror


French Assembly Adopts 3-Strikes Bill

An anonymous reader writes "After lots of turmoil, including a surprise rejection and a European amendment against it, Sarkozy's 3 strikes law has just been passed by the French Assembly [in French]: 'The first warning mails ... should be sent in the coming fall. In case of second offenders, the first disconnections should start beginning 2010.'"

3 of 343 comments (clear)

  1. Not yet by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    It has only passed the lower chamber. Now it has to be approved by the Senate with the exact same wording. In case a coma is changed, the assembly will have to debate, edit and vote again the law. Then it will have the pass the check of the constitutional council which could take down large chunks of the law. In other words, the battle is not over yet and the relief could come from Europe. Wait, fight, and see.

  2. Re:France vs. EU by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

    There is no such thing as "The EU Army". The EU is more like a council of countries and is nowhere near a central government. Yet.

  3. Re:Encryption doesn't do much. by JesseMcDonald · · Score: 4, Informative

    Either this is done with something like onion routing, or sites like rapidshare are used as the intermediaries.

    These are completely different approaches. Both use "intermediaries", but nested encryption is inherent in onion routing (and similar protocols as used e.g. by I2P), and there is no need to trust those adjacent to you, since they never know who you're communicating with or what data you're transferring. A site like Rapidshare, on the other hand, can see the content being shared as well as the IP addresses of both the uploader and the downloaders, and is thus fully capable of betraying all those involved.

    There is also an additional incentive to participate in some onion-routing networks beyond the benefits of "background noise": the more bandwidth you make available to others, the better your own transfer rates become. (At least that's how I2P works.) It's rather similar to the incentive for seeding in BitTorrent itself.

    --
    "The state is that great fiction by which everyone tries to live at the expense of everyone else." - Bastiat